View Topic

Time: Round 9 Day

Root Host: Michi

Players · Votes · Posts

Well this is an interesting development. Either the wolves are getting blocked, they've forgotten to input kill targets, or they're fucking with us (or some combination)...
(Also, sorry Neon)

Let's get some discussion going.
From least to most suspicious imo:
Marzipan
Dolby
Wintermoot
Arenado
Kane
Kiddian
TGN
BSR


Vote: BraveSirRobin

BSR is basically absent, which isn't totally against his MO, but he is definitely the silent wolf type. And I'm fairly certain he's done the no-kill fakeout as a wolf before.

Looking back at the votes from last round, I find it pretty likely that a wolf voted for Neon as that would've been an easy wagon to jump on. I suppose the ones who didn't could now hide behind "See I didn't kill Neon!" But when half the players vote for one person (assuming Kiddian's vote counted), I expect at least one wolf to be on there.

yrotagilbo eht ,hcihw fo gnikaepS

napizraM@
toomretniW@
odanerA@
enaK evitanigamI@
naiddiK@
niboRriSevarB@


)oga sruoh hsi-8 detrats ,llew( detrats sah yad eht wonk uoy taht oS

Well this is an interesting development. Either the wolves are getting blocked, they've forgotten to input kill targets, or they're fucking with us (or some combination)...
(Also, sorry Neon)

Let's get some discussion going.
From least to most suspicious imo:
Marzipan
Dolby
Wintermoot
Arenado
Kane
Kiddian
TGN
BSR


Vote: BraveSirRobin

BSR is basically absent, which isn't totally against his MO, but he is definitely the silent wolf type. And I'm fairly certain he's done the no-kill fakeout as a wolf before.

Looking back at the votes from last round, I find it pretty likely that a wolf voted for Neon as that would've been an easy wagon to jump on. I suppose the ones who didn't could now hide behind "See I didn't kill Neon!" But when half the players vote for one person (assuming Kiddian's vote counted), I expect at least one wolf to be on there.

I just gotta ask, why I’m second most suspicious to you?

Nobody dies twice in a row? Odd. The BSR absence theory could make sense. But it could also be a ploy by Gerrick, sit back, do nothing and then point the finger at anyone inactive. But that would be a little out there, even for me. At this point, I have nothing to go on, really, so I'll just wait for more information.

I just gotta ask, why I’m second most suspicious to you?

No offense, TGN, but I think I'm always gonna find you suspicious just based on the way you play lol. This game, you have only voted no lynch so far, and the only real comments you have made about someone were that you thought Neon might have been suspicious (but then didn't vote for her) and that Wintermoot D1 vote to make a tie wasn't that suspicious. It just seems like your talking a lot but not saying anything that might be used against you or anyone else. 

I'm not gonna edit those typos out no matter how much I want to lol

I'm not sure about BSR, if only because I assume there's more than one pie who could cast a vote in his absence and everybody else has been reasonably active. That doesn't leave me with much to go on at this point though. =/

Wintermoot took a reason why Abby should have been town and manufactured it into a wolf read tbh

Aren idk I view him the same way you view TGN

Please elaborate. Why should Abbi been read town? Based on what I knew at the time I still feel like my suspicions were solid given that she repeatedly called my actions scummy without explaining why, took actions that raised the odds of her being voted out and tried to explain them as a sacrifice for another player whose role she had no reads on, and made several illogical arguments about getting information off kills when there's little to be had this early in the game.

I think taken together they're valid justifications for suspicion.

.)emit dne esahp wen eht si worromot TSP MP03:7 ylhguor os( enildaed tnerruc eht retfa sruoh 5 ylhguor ot dednetxe eb lliw enildaed s'worromot taht pu sdaeh yldneirf a tsuj si sihT

.)worromot TSP MP03:2 neeb evah yllanigiro dluow hcihw( yllamron esahp eht dne ot emit ni emoh eb t'now I os ,worromot boj wen ym gnitrats eb ll'I

.puhcuot gnitsorf citemsoc eht rof yad a ecno rekab lacol ruoy tisiv dna ,seip lla dna yna hsart ,esyplacopekaC eht ecarbme os ,aionarap ruoy no sevirht taht emag a si siht ,tsomerof dna tsrif taht rebmemer dnA  .ylesiw etov ot rebmemer dna emit artxe eht yojne esaelp oS

napizraM@
ybloD@
toomretniW@
odanerA@
enaK evitanigamI@
naiddiK@
NGT@
niboRriSevarB@

kcirreG@

enaK evitanigamI@

)): .gnorw ti dellepS

Wow, no posts for over 24 hours? Anybody? 

I can see some potential merit in the BSR theory, but I’m not entirely sold on it yet. 

I’m trying not to tunnel vision Aren solely based off of a vibe, but I just want you to know I am squinting in your general direction. Your mother was a ham and your father garnished with elderberries. 

I’ll pop back in in a little while- if there’s no other lead, I will concede to the BSR vote. I need some info y’all. 

Oh thank god

Wrt to Wintermoot the long and short of it was nothing that he sussed Abby for was actually scummy unless you think kiddian is her teammate, which, no. Yeah Abby should’ve voted Kiddian but her voting for Wintermoot was an expression of genuine conviction AND made her death more likely, increasing odds from 33% to 50% for that day. Just bad play for scum who have to survive way more than we have to

Tbh I think I’ll just go for that vote

Vote Wintermoot

Abby’s arguments for getting info off of kills I’m not going to get into a debate over this, but she used them in a non-scum motivated manner thst placed her slots survival at major risk, which should’ve been recognized as towny

It's not such a bad play if you can then convince others that doing so makes you less likely to be a wolf. And that doesn't really answer my question, just repeating that her actions weren't suspicious or wolfy isn't elaborating as to why. Maybe it didn't actually turn out that way, but with what I knew then my suspicions were very valid, and this pretending otherwise is really going out on a limb here.

So for that reason Vote: Dolby.

Also, guys, you have to use the vote tags for a vote to register. You can't just bold it and have it count in the system. If you're unsure how to use the vote tags there's always the vote button on the far-right beside the spoiler button that will put it in for you.