View Topic

Game Over on Round 7 Day

Root Host: Ruguo Other Hosts: Michi

Players · Votes · Posts

I thought alts were forbidden in Wintreath's Werewolves games

Not sure how to feel about NoName
If they felt like using an Alt maybe they're tired of being associated to their meta, who'd fit this?

From the way they've posted, I don't think they're a Wintreath native. It sounds like they play with you guys over at Bulba/Zelda, or wherever KoD is from. Still not sure if they've played with me, either, lol. So I expect this is their only account here, which they definitely created to hide their identity, though.

definitely not from bulba nor zd

They've openly admitted they've at least played SMM3 with us on ZD or are privy to the knowledge 

I have a few ideas but I'd rather not share them, yet.

Just caught up. I'll need to reread to make a proper scum list. For now my vote is going on Neon Abagail

VOTE: NEON ABAGAIL

I'm just your friendly neighborhood Spiderman or something why don't you trust me?

Neon I'm ngl I have no idea who you think is town/mafia can you enlighten me

Let's try a reads list. This never ends up going well.

Town

TGN

Cozmikrae

Laurentus

Moondrop
Neon Abigail
Aersoldorf
KingofDominaria

Red Mones
Wintermoot

NoName
Dolby
Anubhav Ghosh
ExLight

Vroendal

Captan Lunch

Gerrick

Wolf

why is basically anyone who isn't Gerrick, CL, and Lau where they are?

Why isn't Lau higher?

wintermoot isn't playing as well

Lau is a good player who can fake Cop. I don't think he has faked his check, hence why I put him as town. But the possibility is there. And I also don't have a tonal read on him, so my entire read is based on the check, pretty much.

Wintermoot is in the list of players.

Seems kinda odd to believe the claim if you don't already have pretty townie feelings about me, tbh. This line of reasoning is actually applicable to Aerso, too, tbh. 

I am yet to see a scum-Dolby post, I have no reads as of now. I am connecting everyone else's leads

is this a townlean on me ? You saw me scum in the CFC game about 10 months ago

I am yet to get some solid ground on my reads, and I don't have much in way of reading either. 

Let's try a reads list. This never ends up going well.

Town

TGN

Cozmikrae

Laurentus

Moondrop
Neon Abigail
Aersoldorf
KingofDominaria

Red Mones
Wintermoot

NoName
Dolby
Anubhav Ghosh
ExLight

Vroendal

Captan Lunch

Gerrick

Wolf

why is basically anyone who isn't Gerrick, CL, and Lau where they are?

Why isn't Lau higher?

wintermoot isn't playing as well

Lau is a good player who can fake Cop. I don't think he has faked his check, hence why I put him as town. But the possibility is there. And I also don't have a tonal read on him, so my entire read is based on the check, pretty much.

Wintermoot is in the list of players.

Seems kinda odd to believe the claim if you don't already have pretty townie feelings about me, tbh. This line of reasoning is actually applicable to Aerso, too, tbh.

Well, to be perfectly honest we don't have a lot of fake claims in XKI, except in the case of wolves on the chopping block who are trying to save themselves, so I generally believe most claims that are made early and under no duress. In my Champs game last year there was a guy who faked a claim with his very first post and when it became known that he lied I tunneled on him especially hard and ended up getting lynched myself over it. I just don't understand the though process for why a town member would fake something like that and it's especially dumb for a scum to do it, hence the reason I believe your claim. I even asked you a second time if my assessment of your claim was accurate and you doubled down in the affirmative. So are you now saying that you lied? Because that would really mess up my though processes if so.

@ Laur:

Why wouldn't we believe the claim?


Vote: Gerrick

@ CL:

I'm not starting anything yet. All I did was make the observation that you did flip scum in a game you practically ghosted yet were still in. If you post and add content like you are kinda-sorta doing right now, then you'll just go out into left field like you normally do until a dumpster fire erupts somewhere.

@ Dolby:

Hello there.

@ No Name:

Care to bounce ideas off the wall with me over placing people in a list? I'll show you mine if you show me yours. Pinky promise.

The experienced players: *argues over Lau's claim*

Me, obviously still a noob: "Why are we even arguing let's just lynch him and move forward based on the flip" (Sorry Gerrick I know we're supposed to be family)

I should have some more time today, I'll see if I can churn something out. I don't want this to turn out like the hydra game I spectacularly failed at

Let's try a reads list. This never ends up going well.

Town

TGN

Cozmikrae

Laurentus

Moondrop
Neon Abigail
Aersoldorf
KingofDominaria

Red Mones
Wintermoot

NoName
Dolby
Anubhav Ghosh
ExLight

Vroendal

Captan Lunch

Gerrick

Wolf

why is basically anyone who isn't Gerrick, CL, and Lau where they are?

Why isn't Lau higher?

wintermoot isn't playing as well

Lau is a good player who can fake Cop. I don't think he has faked his check, hence why I put him as town. But the possibility is there. And I also don't have a tonal read on him, so my entire read is based on the check, pretty much.

Wintermoot is in the list of players.

Seems kinda odd to believe the claim if you don't already have pretty townie feelings about me, tbh. This line of reasoning is actually applicable to Aerso, too, tbh.

Well, to be perfectly honest we don't have a lot of fake claims in XKI, except in the case of wolves on the chopping block who are trying to save themselves, so I generally believe most claims that are made early and under no duress. In my Champs game last year there was a guy who faked a claim with his very first post and when it became known that he lied I tunneled on him especially hard and ended up getting lynched myself over it. I just don't understand the though process for why a town member would fake something like that and it's especially dumb for a scum to do it, hence the reason I believe your claim. I even asked you a second time if my assessment of your claim was accurate and you doubled down in the affirmative. So are you now saying that you lied? Because that would really mess up my though processes if so.

No, my claim is real, but that doesn't mean I can't look at people's reactions to it. Bussing would be a very attractive option for the scum team, so it would be kinda pointless not to monitor people's reasoning on the back of the claim, either.

Let's try a reads list. This never ends up going well.

Town

TGN

Cozmikrae

Laurentus

Moondrop
Neon Abigail
Aersoldorf
KingofDominaria

Red Mones
Wintermoot

NoName
Dolby
Anubhav Ghosh
ExLight

Vroendal

Captan Lunch

Gerrick

Wolf

I haven’t even done anything, how am I at the top

also do we have like 3 wolves or something like what did Gerrik even do? All I was told is he was a “devil”
also my multiquotes didn’t work so why do we have a neighborhood spider man? You know who I’m talking about 

Let's try a reads list. This never ends up going well.

Town

TGN

Cozmikrae

Laurentus

Moondrop
Neon Abigail
Aersoldorf
KingofDominaria

Red Mones
Wintermoot

NoName
Dolby
Anubhav Ghosh
ExLight

Vroendal

Captan Lunch

Gerrick

Wolf

I haven’t even done anything, how am I at the top

also do we have like 3 wolves or something like what did Gerrik even do? All I was told is he was a “devil”
also my multiquotes didn’t work so why do we have a neighborhood spider man? You know who I’m talking about

Gerrick got day red checked by Laurentsu
My multiquotes also aren't working, sad

Let's try a reads list. This never ends up going well.

Town

TGN

Cozmikrae

Laurentus

Moondrop
Neon Abigail
Aersoldorf
KingofDominaria

Red Mones
Wintermoot

NoName
Dolby
Anubhav Ghosh
ExLight

Vroendal

Captan Lunch

Gerrick

Wolf

why is basically anyone who isn't Gerrick, CL, and Lau where they are?

Why isn't Lau higher?

wintermoot isn't playing as well

Lau is a good player who can fake Cop. I don't think he has faked his check, hence why I put him as town. But the possibility is there. And I also don't have a tonal read on him, so my entire read is based on the check, pretty much.

Wintermoot is in the list of players.

Seems kinda odd to believe the claim if you don't already have pretty townie feelings about me, tbh. This line of reasoning is actually applicable to Aerso, too, tbh.

No? I probably would've trusted a scum-read if they claimed Cop so early on in the game. I don't think me believing a claim has to correlate with how I feel about the person tonally. I can be wrong on day 1 with a tonal read. Following the flip of Gerrick I can always re-assess how I feel about it and come to a second conclusion.

Overwhelmingly, the claim seems genuine. I simply acknowledged why I didn't feel the need to town-lock you at this moment.

Let's try a reads list. This never ends up going well.

Town

TGN

Cozmikrae

Laurentus

Moondrop
Neon Abigail
Aersoldorf
KingofDominaria

Red Mones
Wintermoot

NoName
Dolby
Anubhav Ghosh
ExLight

Vroendal

Captan Lunch

Gerrick

Wolf

I haven’t even done anything, how am I at the top

also do we have like 3 wolves or something like what did Gerrik even do? All I was told is he was a “devil”
also my multiquotes didn’t work so why do we have a neighborhood spider man? You know who I’m talking about

Hey, TGN, Lau, here. Also known as the devil. Gerrick isn't scum because he behaved scummy and we're cold-reading him, he's scum because I have one that I may use during any given day phase, and I used it on him and the result was that he's scum.

EBWOP: One *cop check* that I may use...

Good to know I'm not the only person who has been having trouble using multiquote.