View Topic

@Eastern New England

1.Why do you think Lau and LoS to be scum , please state the reasons however vague it is ?

2. Lau and LoS , how does their interaction seem to you ?

3. Will you vote me , in case the wagon on you becomes the largest , to save yourself , or will you chase Lau/LoS , providing some material for thought for the next day phase ?

4. How much will the town regret if the town loses you ?

5. Will the scum regret  losing you ?

@Eastern New England

1.Why do you think Lau and LoS to be scum , please state the reasons however vague it is ?

2. Lau and LoS , how does their interaction seem to you ?

3. Will you vote me , in case the wagon on you becomes the largest , to save yourself , or will you chase Lau/LoS , providing some material for thought for the next day phase ?

4. How much will the town regret if the town loses you ?

5. Will the scum regret  losing you ?

Erm I wouldn't suggest answering 4 though.

I think LoS is actually making a pretty good case against ENE.

In fact:

VOTE: Eastern New England

Also, Anu, the answer to 4 and 5 will be the same whether the person is Town or Scum:

4. Of course! I'm Town

5. Of course not, they're just happy a Townie is getting lynched!

I will wait for ENE to answer , provided we have around another 24 hrs . My reasoning has been poor in this game probably , but let's see how deep can I go in this game .

Also, Anu, the answer to 4 and 5 will be the same whether the person is Town or Scum:

4. Of course! I'm Town

5. Of course not, they're just happy a Townie is getting lynched!

I think LoS is suggesting that could be read as a soft claim depending on how they answer that question. Which would lead to a mod kill.

Anu

Like, did you just throw the two biggest bastards in the scum team and call it a day?

I have some vague (and probably wrong) reasons, but other than that pretty much.

If you're town , then you should site the reasons , as of the feeling you have that they might be wrong , just shake it off . The fact that I unvoted doesn't necessarily mean that I can't vote against you again .

@Eastern New England

1.Why do you think Lau and LoS to be scum , please state the reasons however vague it is ?

2. Lau and LoS , how does their interaction seem to you ?

3. Will you vote me , in case the wagon on you becomes the largest , to save yourself , or will you chase Lau/LoS , providing some material for thought for the next day phase ?

4. How much will the town regret if the town loses you ?

5. Will the scum regret  losing you ?

1. My LoS case is gone now (although some new material might have come up, read further down). I was mostly confused by why LoS was taking so much time to not be scum-read. His reasoning was well and LoS has always been/wanted to be the most town-y player, regardless alignment.
For Lau it just pinged me that he chose to heavily imply that Anu and Gerrick were defenders.
3. I don't know yet.

LoS

I actually think ENE is scum.

Interesting, how so?

For people who aren't aware (I believe you are but for the sake of others) I have a lot of meta on ENE.

When he's active, he's definitely more of a tryhard town (much more than you'd expect honestly). As scum he's typically very inactive and doesn't solve anywhere near as much (and he also has a habit of trying to act towny only when pressured). The reads post was probably at least semi-serious and I don't see how a towny comes to those conclusions (particularly a person who self admittedly can't read me and usually has me as null / town lean when I'm town and has only ever scumread me before when he was a wolf himself).

I think he's scum trying to get a low-effort townread by posting something brazenly wolfy (particularly because of my habit to TR this sort of behaviour). The reads post seems pretty out of character for him  but especially him as town.

He was already on my radar before this but he was mostly null.

Would go into more detail but my fingers are cold.

I feel like a lot is wrong with this post. First of all, you were the one that said my activity is NAI. I've been active as scum before. I've also played plenty of town games where I am inactive and don't solve. Sure I've said reading you is hard, but that isn't going to stop me from trying.

Why was I even on your radar? Either you are wolf human and are trying to get a bad case across or you are just reading me incorrectly as town and I'm leaning towards the latter.

Well, let me link you to his scum game. I wonder if you can spot any parallels.

https://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=6948.0

That's definitely an interesting read, thanks.

ENE, any chance that you could post a few reads with some detailed explanations for me please?

I'll read over the thread before the end of the phase and give some thoughts, I don't really have that much yet.

Er, I would want to figure out who the defenders are in case I could end up lynching one of them?

Also, Anu, the answer to 4 and 5 will be the same whether the person is Town or Scum:

4. Of course! I'm Town

5. Of course not, they're just happy a Townie is getting lynched!

I think LoS is suggesting that could be read as a soft claim depending on how they answer that question. Which would lead to a mod kill.

I believe ENE is aware of the rules , and if he chose to answer , he would have had kept his answer in check to prevent a role reveal

@Eastern New England

Just one question , I want you to answer. What do you make out of the Lau-LoS interactions ?

@Eastern New England

Just one question , I want you to answer. What do you make out of the Lau-LoS interactions ?

They seem to think alike, I guess? I don't know.

I actually think ENE is scum.

do you think that because there can be only one turtle?
but you do make a good point, in your other posts.
Vote: Make ENE Leave

I actually think ENE is scum.

do you think that because there can be only one turtle?
but you do make a good point, in your other posts.
Vote: Make ENE Leave

Can you quote the part which includes the good points

@Eastern New England

Just one question , I want you to answer. What do you make out of the Lau-LoS interactions ?

They seem to think alike, I guess? I don't know.

I thought the opposite, honestly, but not in a bad way. I think we have different ways of approaching the game, it's interesting.