View Topic

Game Over on Round 5 Day

Root Host: ☆ Princess Abigail ☆

Players · Votes · Posts

While I want wagons on Jamie and Cait I also want some pressure on Bob because his vote on Leesbra feels opportunistic and aiming at a LHF plus they have yet to make an impression on me.

I really don't want wagons on Jamie / Cait but I can settle for bob Vote: GloriousBob

Icet, is your concern with Luka primarily meta (like based on activity level) or is there specific content that bugs you?

Vote: GloriousBob

if Numbers is coherent with their list they vote Cait and the wagons become threeway 2 votes tie among the people I have null/scum so that really works out for me

Icet, is your concern with Luka primarily meta (like based on activity level) or is there specific content that bugs you?

both in a sense?

It's kinda a vibe thing. I don't want to encourage them to not participate and etc but

Leesbra / GoldenOne town

ExLight town lean

Caitlin null

idt town luka makes these reads that early on in the game

I've left it alone for a bit to let the thread breathe and develop on its own terms, so I'll update my view of callahan now. I maintain some misgivings about the way they constructed their suspicion of me, but I also acknowledge that they haven't pursued it through the day. That lessens any impression of opportunism. I also note that others who know callahan better than I do generally seem to be either town reading them or at least less bothered by them than I was. I'm willing to listen to that at least for now.

idt town luka makes these reads that early on in the game

Thanks. Here's a more general question to help me engage with this notion, since I don't have any background with Luka. Would you say it's unusual for Luka to make reads in general that early in the game, or is it those specific reads that strike you as off?

Also I note I've been referring to nearly everyone as "they/them". I don't know your preferred pronouns, and if they're not displayed I tend to default to that. Please smack me if I am getting them wrong for anyone, or if you'd prefer something else.

You may be asking yourself, Bob... how is it that you manage to be so darn Glorious all the time?

The answer is quite simple. I make good decisions. For instance I'm making the decision right now to admin to Jay that I'm MacDougall. Because he probably will find that interesting.

Honestly Mac you are playing very un-Maclike game this game

Why is that?

Dear sweet one Mac is a dynamic system of which Bob is the most glorious.

In my earlier adventures through this beautiful whimsical land I overhead an adventurer by the name of Luka I think it was making reads here and there. Quite an unusual fellow. Quick to issue an opinion. Sort of lad that'd get himself into a mischief in a tavern in my experience.

Now... he was saying he'd be accused of having TMI... and I'm not about to say that means anything because it doesn't. But a couple of the people he made townreads on I didn't really share.

It was so long ago and I've had a belly full of ale so you'll need to forgive me but the people that it was were several and the only one I remember was Leesbra.

That's all to say I think Leesbra is a little bit ... perturbing. Non glorious. Not a lot but certainly a little and I suppose one would be forgiven for finding it interesting Luka was spreading the good word about the fellow.

Yes, Luka is sus
But many others, including myself, also townread Leesbra
So why do you specifically come after Luka for this?

Luka's read was the most flippant.

How do y'all feel about Michi --> Jamie?

Reasonably null.

Well, I have contributed enough for now imo

@GloriousBob I do ask of you to pls explain the reads in your readslist, because they aren't very explained. And I also don't see how you got to an SL on me

I'll be back later but I'll spend time with my lovely girlfriend now

Can't wait for the content of Icet and Serif

Also JJJ - there is no ISO here

The reasons are many and few. The reasons fluctuate between valid and invalid. The reason I suspect you I don't remember. Today is a new day. Now today I slightly suspect you for forcing scumreads. This isn't usually a read I'd make but in this spree of posting here you picked Ex Light and Numbers to push and both of them seem fine. Ex Light's reaction had the requisite town entitlement. Ex Light is quite townie. Numbers has also been... observant. Both of them feel like me in that they're still waiting and watching (at this stage, I am mid catch up). Which is fine. It feels like a gamestate in which the mafia might feel the need to start plotting the course for end day, and the moved you are making feel like a wolf doing that to me.

why does the website have my IP

Ah now this... this is a wolfy entrance.

Chortle

IceT is suspicious of me for meta.

How unfortunate.

And ExLight sheeping.

*sigh*

Ah mafia, o great love o mine.

Where to begin...

IceT having me as their bottom read is perhaps reasonable from the vantage point of someone with one game of meta on me and none of it Bob meta. Yet...

Jay who has hundreds of games of meta on Mac is not suspicious of me on meta.

Cait who has a few games of meta on Mac is tentatively townreading me.

Numbers appears to be the only one here with Bob meta and recognises this just Bob.

...

So one must ponder whether IceT is simply being opportunistic in voting for a player they can produce a surface level comprehensible reason for suspecting.

Outside of this I have found them to be the more suspicious of the list since entry. They made an archetypally nervous entry commenting on their IP address. Subsequent solving carried the hallmarks of the late entering mafia slot. A giant hodge podgy catch up post quote wall designed to look like a try hard town. Follow up machine gun townreads of varying quality quoting non AI posts loaded with TMI. Topping it off with a vote on the most Glorious.

Now I'm usually not one for OMGUS. Perish that thought indeed, but I was suspicious of IceT before I even read their suspicion of me so I won't accept such accusations.

As for ExLight well... 

I think they have had a side eye on me the whole game. Their gaze upon your Glorious has felt earnest in the sense that they are certainly genuinely trying to figure me out. I think their game has been townie and getting townier.

On a separate subject our other recent entrant to the game has felt ... townie but not overwhelmingly so. Just more level and reserved in their take making. Something about this game gives me the impression the town are all relatively findable by looking for the people who are more pensive seeming. While the wolves are among those actually attempting to create a narrative. To fill the silence generated by a waitful town crew.

I think I will retract my vote and suspicion on Leesbra for now. 

Vote: IcetFeelsPain

I'm reviewing Icet now. I'm mostly ambivalent, but there is one moment that catches my eye. Their reception of the argument between callahan and I was awkward.

Referencing callahan's gripes with me as "why they town read Jay" is hard to understand. And they were a bit quick to dismiss the whole thing as town/town.