View Topic

Game Over on Round 5 Day

Root Host: ☆ Princess Abigail ☆

Players · Votes · Posts

Speaking of Jay, he's a great player indeed. I must say he does seem to be townie or at least he passes enough as such but Callahan's read of him is so common and reasonable that Jay erring towards omgus when Jay knows people unfamiliar with him accuses him of such things doesn't sit right with your Gloriousness.

Hi Bob! Have we played together before? I don't recognize your username.

I have seen players accuse me of "Lamist" or whatever, or of "trying too hard". The language of those accusations doesn't tend to feature someone taking a post I made and twisting it into the worst possible interpretation of that post (at least not when the accusation is an honest one). More often the legitimate accusations are that I am stilted or too formal or that kind of thing.

Perhaps I am responding emotionally, but I have also been dealt difficulties in the not-distant past by wolves reading me as wolfy and throwing me off balance.

You are not real YOU ARE NOT REAL WHAT IS THIS?? Why are you trying to drag someone into what we are talking about right now? If you feel like you are responding emotionally, then please take a break from this thread, and come back to me when you have your emotions sorted out.

What is this reaction lol?? Bob is literally talking about Jay?

In my earlier adventures through this beautiful whimsical land I overhead an adventurer by the name of Luka I think it was making reads here and there. Quite an unusual fellow. Quick to issue an opinion. Sort of lad that'd get himself into a mischief in a tavern in my experience.

Now... he was saying he'd be accused of having TMI... and I'm not about to say that means anything because it doesn't. But a couple of the people he made townreads on I didn't really share.

It was so long ago and I've had a belly full of ale so you'll need to forgive me but the people that it was were several and the only one I remember was Leesbra.

That's all to say I think Leesbra is a little bit ... perturbing. Non glorious. Not a lot but certainly a little and I suppose one would be forgiven for finding it interesting Luka was spreading the good word about the fellow.

Yes, Luka is sus
But many others, including myself, also townread Leesbra
So why do you specifically come after Luka for this?

In my years, and they are many, two warriors in the cohort of the God butting heads has occurred ooooh so many times. Too many times to count. And I've gotten quite good at seeing it when I see it.

I think you two have the potential for this hiccup to be instead an origin story of a great alliance

I see some genuine Mac thoughts here below the surface, and I also like that Mac doesnt try to pit the two against each other

So Idc that ppl are gonna call this a bad read but Bob gets town points from me for this post

Well I do care so pls don't get mad over my read

I do want you to keep talking to me though, I understand you will leave this alone, but still, please do not just totally abandoned this.

I certainly won't abandon it. I tend to be very sensitive to thread climate, however, and I know that this kind of argument is often bad for it. Even if you are Mafia, many people will see any hint of annoying conflict and either dismiss all of it off-hand or they'll literally stop looking at the game. That should be avoided. So for the time being, I've said my piece about your grievances with me. I wish to see how others interact with that.

If there's something else you want to discuss with me, by all means. Let's do that. For example: do you have an initial impression of the other active players (e.g., Luka and Caitlin)?

Oh okay, got you, I don't want to make you upset at all. I'm just trying to understand things and give my input on things. I noticed Luka and Cait did argue, and you are right about how people dismissed it...because that is literally what I did when I noticed Luka and Cait started arguing, I was like nope, because I think it was over something silly. When I did read Luka, I felt like it was pretty obvious he was trolling, and I think he still is. Cait just seems NAI to me. I think most people are right now because nothing really caught my attention.

I had quite a few content tho at that point :thinking: Surely it can't all have been NAI

Leesbra: 1 (GloriousBob)
Luka: 1 (Caitlinuwu)
JaggedJimmyJay: 1 (callahan)
Caitlinuwu: 1 (Luka)
callahan: 1 (JaggedJimmyJay)


Very spread out VC, annoyingly. But I also don't rlly feel comfy putting a 2nd vote on a wagon, I already am the Luka voter, so I can't vote there, and I'd also feel iffy voting out the main content creator D1, because if Luka is town it'd be quite bad. Luka also said he will be gone, so if he is PR he also would be unable to claim this to prevent being voted out. But despite thinking JJJ was sus early on and Callahan had some - imo - pretty clear flaws in the push there... I also just have this feeling they might be TvT :/ And Leesbra is my only TL. And the 5th wagon is myself >.> So Idrk what to do to break this 5-way tie rn

I have played with Cait quite a bit also as it were.

Yet you already misread me if you're town ;-;

I have played with Cait quite a bit also as it were.

Werd.

My flat read is that I thought Cait seemed authentic in their poking at me earlier for my apparent formality/wording. That's something I recognize from many past first encounters.

Do you have an impression either of Cait in general or of the validity of my viewpoint?

I remain uncertain on Lady Caitlin. My experiences with Caitlin are that she is good at Mafia as both alignments, underrated as both alignments and capable of taking advantage of people who make too easy reads as mafia. The only thing that stands out to me as alignment indicative about her in my experience is sincerity of reads reasoning perhaps being something to keep an eye on as well as WIM level.

Lady Caitlin feels flattered >.<

Some of the squad here has indicated town reading ExLight. I'd appreciate hearing more about why that is. @Caitlinuwu @Luka I believe each of you apply.

What's your read on me?
Accurate one and Gun to the head one

Honestly, ExLight's pop-in here is underwhelming. Clearly, they read some of the chat but they only ask about whose alt Bob is (when that was said) and ask this

No reads at all

Some of the squad here has indicated town reading ExLight. I'd appreciate hearing more about why that is. @Caitlinuwu @Luka I believe each of you apply.

Scum would’ve voted cait to get early town cred from me

Imo this read is nonsensical

Sure maybe you'd give towncred? But others don't like bandwagoners, and I wouldn't like someone voting me

So Ex's position overall would most likely worsen if they hopped on?

Sorry for the spam everyone, just haven't been here for a while

And like I'd be up to live-interact with ppl but there isn't anyone here so it's just me posting

Thank you for engaging with callahan and I over the "argument" earlier, Cait. One question I have about callahan for those who've experience playing with them. Would it be unusual for them to go after someone in the pointed, direct fashion that they went after me if they are a wolf? For some people this would be ordinary to do, but I acknowledge not everyone would go for that kind of hard in the paint approach. There's a personality to that.

grumble why did it not break lines

Some of the squad here has indicated town reading ExLight. I'd appreciate hearing more about why that is. @Caitlinuwu @Luka I believe each of you apply.

Scum would’ve voted cait to get early town cred from me

bit of a bold claim considering you have never seen me roll scum

Don't love this reaction to Luka either

It just feels kinda... out of place? For this, the earlier pop-in and the only basis of trusting ExLight being a vibe read I'll try my chance here (or at Numbers, probably)

Vote: ExLight

Thank you for engaging with callahan and I over the "argument" earlier, Cait. One question I have about callahan for those who've experience playing with them. Would it be unusual for them to go after someone in the pointed, direct fashion that they went after me if they are a wolf? For some people this would be ordinary to do, but I acknowledge not everyone would go for that kind of hard in the paint approach. There's a personality to that.

Oh I think Calla would defs do this, this is kinda her signature move. I will say that usually she ironically seems less confident then she does here when town, but she also has had games like this where she's just super aggressive and attacks like that

She once even made videos accusing me & Luka with funny things in them, due to being that sure...

She's very direct

I have met Luka playing as scum before and their current game does not remind me of it, although they might have different styles in forum and discord mafia.

Cait reaction is NAI - if she's town she'd get annoyed at that senseless prodding and if she's scum she'd be annoyed at being pinned this early on.

Vaporeon person seems townie enough. The overreactions seem townie and coherent with them being new. Please avoid editing your posts though. @Leesbra can you link us your first game though?

I have a couple other people in my watchlist but I'll wait until I have a more tangible first impression on most of the cast before explaining why.

What an odd view of my annoyance

I think it was rather clear that I was upset over being insulted & that Luka stated I wasn't in his top 10 fave players

That doesn't have to do with the prodding?