View Topic

Time: Round 9 Day

Root Host: Michi

Players · Votes · Posts

Vote: Neon Abigail
The fact that she was throwing around accusations from the start makes her the best bet

I don’t think there’s a jester this game. I think Rule 4 was a funky reference and nothing more because this is supposed to be a vanilla game- though jester can be vanilla in certain variations of this game, I don’t imagine we’re following role lists like ToS

I’m keeping an open mind there because I’m still relearning metas outside of ToS and the like. 

Also I’m shifting BSR to sideeye after rereading Moot’s note about him coming in as late as he did. It’s still a neutral but… hmm 🤔 

I don’t think there’s a jester this game. I think Rule 4 was a funky reference and nothing more because this is supposed to be a vanilla game- though jester can be vanilla in certain variations of this game, I don’t imagine we’re following role lists like ToS

I don’t think that it would be in the rules if it was a reference, but that’s just me  (and I do follow roles like ToS)

I would also guess that the Crème Brûlée (or however you spell it) role is jester but eh.

I'm still somewhat convinced that Abbi is some kind of jester role or something similar. If they were a wolf I don't think they would have responded to an accusation that would provide them with some cover for them by categorically denying that its possible, that would only really leave one explanation, being a wolf.

I always feel like this at some point in a game of Werewolf...

I'm waiting a bit longer before making a vote...I think it's interesting that there was no kill last night, and since I think most everyone was active the most likely scenario is that an attack was intercepted like Kane asked about. I will point out that BraveSirRobin didn't appear until the night phase was over, but there's likely more than one wolf.

This is vanilla there's no jester here. I'm the towniest town

That's not necessarily true. Michi's OP mentions a Cupcake Bridge and Creme Brulee role, and we don't know what either is. One of them could be a jester role.

Arenado is correct in that you have been by far the most suspicious person by far, unnecessarily so, right out the gate, to the point that it only makes sense to me in two scenarios: you're a jester or you're a wolf that wants to look like a jester so people will avoid voting for you.

Could this be you? Courtesy of DALL-E Mini

.rees eht rof eman eht si eelurB emerC ehT  .srednefeD eht rof eman eht si edagirB ekacpuC ehT

.seip eht sediseb pu nettirw selor rewop rehto on era erehT

I always feel like this at some point in a game of Werewolf...

I'm waiting a bit longer before making a vote...I think it's interesting that there was no kill last night, and since I think most everyone was active the most likely scenario is that an attack was intercepted like Kane asked about. I will point out that BraveSirRobin didn't appear until the night phase was over, but there's likely more than one wolf.

This is vanilla there's no jester here. I'm the towniest town

That's not necessarily true. Michi's OP mentions a Cupcake Bridge and Creme Brulee role, and we don't know what either is. One of them could be a jester role.

Arenado is correct in that you have been by far the most suspicious person by far, unnecessarily so, right out the gate, to the point that it only makes sense to me in two scenarios: you're a jester or you're a wolf that wants to look like a jester so people will avoid voting for you.

Could this be you? Courtesy of DALL-E Mini

.rees eht rof eman eht si eelurB emerC ehT  .srednefeD eht rof eman eht si edagirB ekacpuC ehT

.seip eht sediseb pu nettirw selor rewop rehto on era erehT

You didn't need to openly say that but I appreciate it

I'm still somewhat convinced that Abbi is some kind of jester role or something similar. If they were a wolf I don't think they would have responded to an accusation that would provide them with some cover for them by categorically denying that its possible, that would only really leave one explanation, being a wolf.

Vote: Arenado

The night phase has ended.

Nobody was thrown into the trash.

@Marzipan
@Neon Abigail
@Kiddian
@Arenado
@TGN
@Gerrick
@Wintermoot
@Imaginative Kane
@BraveSirRobin

@Dolby

We move into a new day phase, which will end in 48 hours on 7/11/2022

What time is day end? So I can legacy before my untimely death?

I always feel like this at some point in a game of Werewolf...

I'm waiting a bit longer before making a vote...I think it's interesting that there was no kill last night, and since I think most everyone was active the most likely scenario is that an attack was intercepted like Kane asked about. I will point out that BraveSirRobin didn't appear until the night phase was over, but there's likely more than one wolf.

This is vanilla there's no jester here. I'm the towniest town

That's not necessarily true. Michi's OP mentions a Cupcake Bridge and Creme Brulee role, and we don't know what either is. One of them could be a jester role.

Arenado is correct in that you have been by far the most suspicious person by far, unnecessarily so, right out the gate, to the point that it only makes sense to me in two scenarios: you're a jester or you're a wolf that wants to look like a jester so people will avoid voting for you.

Could this be you? Courtesy of DALL-E Mini

The Cupcake Brigade is the name for the Defenders.  The Creme Brulee is the name for the seer.

There are no other power roles written up besides the pies.

Interesting…
in that case I’ll still probably skip because tbh they both make good points

Thanks for the clarification, Michi.

With that in mind, Vote: Neon Abigail. I don't think I've seen anyone so obviously suspicious in any game I've ever played. If she doesn't end up being a wolf, I'm going to have serious questions as to why she said the things she did here. v_v

Well, in that case, yeah, I'm voting Abbi. You've played really suspiciously and if there are no jesters or anything I can only imagine one alternative.

Vote: Neon Abigail

I'm more confused than suspicious of Abigail so far so I am not sure that they are scum yet. I think they are more likely to be an unlynchable neutralish role until more information is revealed.
Most other players are in the same situation from what I am noticing. Robin is the lone exception because of what Moot and others pointed out about their inactivity. I think voting them will reveal more helpful information than Abigail right now.

Basically my reads so far are:
Town: me
Neutral: Abigail
Slight Scum lean: BSR
Unknown: everyone else

On that note

Vote: BraveSirRobin

Michi: Everything Abbi said about roles is true.

The Scum Team of Moot and Aren: Abbi is so obviously scum I've never seen anyone act so suspicious in my life

Everyone else: