@ Doc:
First, my analysis was geared towards "known" information given to us by others so as to limit who to look at as far as potential killers go. This led to the PoE I gave mention of which is fairly contained (though it also assumes, on your part, that you're playing in a fairly town manner ever since subbing in for Corbin).
Second, the 180 on your slot is, quite literally, because of you. My "firm" scum read of Corbin was strictly on how Corbin was approaching things. That's a far cry from how you're approaching things. So, quite literally, what else would you expect the 180 to come from?
As for Dolby, and going off my first point tangentially, I haven't eliminated him as potential scum. Based on what was claimed by Gerrick and Neon, assuming Neon is honest, there's no reason to assume Dolby made a kill action the first night. He *could* be on the scum team though. Svri, on the other hand, has checked in to say they'd participate more, but I'm not seeing that. They are in the PoE as far as being the one that could have made a kill. So, without devolving into complete paranoia about Neon, Svri is a decent target to chop through given known targets from the first night. Dolby isn't a bad target, though, imo, isn't as optimal.
That being said, yeah, I prefer to maintain a philosophy wherein scum try to play safe. This isn't a catchall though as it will miss more active scum players or power wolves definitely. If Neon is such, I'll miss it. The only issues I've had with Neon is her complete 180 on me, and the fact that Gerrick saw her targeting Aers. Aside from, since her targeting of Aers can be explained away by her claim, there's not much else to indicate Neon is scum here.
@ Mele:
I'll echo the response Neon said towards you in that, yeah, we're paired strictly as town even though she did try to elim me out of nowhere. What I don't agree with, despite being the recipient of this, is that we're paired as scum. Strictly because why, in that situation, does Neon attempt to vote me out there as opposed to Corbin as you so astutely noted? If your response is going to be in the vein of because we knew I'd survive (which thus implies that I or Neon have the ability that unilaterally secured the lynch), then that's quite the hot take to make given what Neon has claimed and was backed up by the targeting as far as targeting Gerrick and the fact that I maintain I was not the source of the Kingmaker ability.
But if that's the view you want to maintain, more power to you.
SvriI find KoD's vote against me pretty darn interesting, considering the fact that I'm extremely new at forum Werewolf, and even if I was scum, I would be absolutely trash at hiding it. But here's the kicker: I am an investigator and you, KoD, are town. I know that for a fact despite your more suspicious comments.
Bold move of you to make. There's only one problem (well a couple problems):1. I have no way of knowing how you'd be, as scum, at forum mafia. There's no reason for me to take you at your word.2. If you're an investigator, why did you only claim one result and nothing else? We've had two nights so you should have two results.Huh, perhaps you are correct and I should take you at your word about how you'd play as scum.