View Topic

Game Over on Round 4 Day

Root Host: Arenado Other Hosts: Marzipan

Players · Votes · Posts

Also, Corbin has had to step away from the game due to IRL commitments. He will be replaced by @Doc from now on. Let's welcome Doc to the game!

I have a lot of reading to do.
Not as much as I feared, but damn y'all MFs go hard.

Hi Doc. Welcome to the game.

I would like to announce that someone tried to kill me last night. Considering no one else died, I was targeted by both the wolves and SK. I do believe that clears me as unambiguously town.

Hello Hellooooo is anybody hommmmeeeee?

Post pleaseeee.

Also. Incredibly sus claim by Mel. 

I have some info. The info is this. I have no info, but I don't think there's a serial killer. 

Hi Doc. Welcome to the game.

I would like to announce that someone tried to kill me last night. Considering no one else died, I was targeted by both the wolves and SK. I do believe that clears me as unambiguously town.

May you inquire as to whether you would receive two notifications if you were attacked by two different abilities?

In the unlikely event that you as a killing role decided not to attack or were unable to attack for whatever reason, and was yourself both attacked and defended/was immune, then you wouldn't be clear so it's not quite completely unambiguous. Just putting it out there. That would be wiiiiiild though so sure you can be town. Hiiiiiii!

Incredibly sus claim by Mel.

I have some info. The info is this. I have no info, but I don't think there's a serial killer.

I'mma need elaboration on why you don't think there's an sk.

I've been thinking about it and the wording used for that kill feels deliberate

Wolf Chief is a very specific role name in relation to one kill

But why Killer and not Serial Killer for the other. I'm inclined to think the killer is different than a standard SK in some way. 

Inb4 "TMI"

Answer: I'm inferring based on context thank you very much.

Hi Doc. Welcome to the game.

I would like to announce that someone tried to kill me last night. Considering no one else died, I was targeted by both the wolves and SK. I do believe that clears me as unambiguously town.

May you inquire as to whether you would receive two notifications if you were attacked by two different abilities?

In the unlikely event that you as a killing role decided not to attack or were unable to attack for whatever reason, and was yourself both attacked and defended/was immune, then you wouldn't be clear so it's not quite completely unambiguous. Just putting it out there. That would be wiiiiiild though so sure you can be town. Hiiiiiii!

Incredibly sus claim by Mel.

I have some info. The info is this. I have no info, but I don't think there's a serial killer.

I'mma need elaboration on why you don't think there's an sk.

I would not receive separate notifications, however, I do know for certain I was visited last night by multiple people.

Wolf Chief is a very specific role name in relation to one kill

But why Killer and not Serial Killer for the other. I'm inclined to think the killer is different than a standard SK in some way.

Inb4 "TMI"

Answer: I'm inferring based on context thank you very much.

Alright, that is an interesting observation. So just to clarify, you do think that there is a separate killing role but that it's probably not a cut-and-dry vanilla type killing role?

This game is supposed to have bastard elements, so it's plausible.

Intresting. I wonder if you get info similar to mine where it will tell you if your targeted but not give you info on who targeted you. 

That's what my ability does kind of. Accept my ability only tells me if I'm targeted by a killer when I hide.

Which by the way since Tracker verified Dolby visited me Dolby is at least cleared as a killing role. 

Wolf Chief is a very specific role name in relation to one kill

But why Killer and not Serial Killer for the other. I'm inclined to think the killer is different than a standard SK in some way.

Inb4 "TMI"

Answer: I'm inferring based on context thank you very much.

Alright, that is an interesting observation. So just to clarify, you do think that there is a separate killing role but that it's probably not a cut-and-dry vanilla type killing role?

Some kind of killing role yes. My brain has posited a role that kills one person who visits them at night.

Neither a kill by the bad guys nor Killer?  Interesting.

Even more interesting claim by Mel, but I don't buy that both killing roles targeted her.

I was going to grill KoD a bit this phase, but his posts during the night say enough to where I'm comfy giving him some benefit of the doubt until I see some suspicious moves otherwise, same goes for Abbi.

I am, however, intrigued by this no kill night and the claim that Mel was attacked by both the Killer and faction.  Care to explain how you know you were specifically the target, and how you escaped unharmed by both, Mel?

Intresting. I wonder if you get info similar to mine where it will tell you if your targeted but not give you info on who targeted you.

That's what my ability does kind of. Accept my ability only tells me if I'm targeted by a killer when I hide.

Which by the way since Tracker verified Dolby visited me Dolby is at least cleared as a killing role.

Yeah, I only know that I was targeted by multiple people last night, and I know one of them was a killing role because my active ability is blocked if I'm targeted for a kill.

Cool cool. This kinda just leaves Kane, Svip, and Doc in my immediate PoE right now with Michi just on the outside (I buy Neon's theory that he's the kingmaker but on reflection I'm not sure if a killing role that's able to decide the vote for every phase would be balanced so I'm more leaning town on Michi but this is also a bastard game so idk), and with KoD/Neon town-leans that self-resolve at some point. I haven't seriously looked back at what happened previously so I'll leave off on a vote for now until I have, vibes have me voting Kane though.