View Topic

I still think you're all wildly off-base here and this pile on Vro is definitely a case of Too Wolfy.
In light of this, the, er, 'wagonomics' reasoning as Lau put it, and my gut still saying he's being one of the primary drivers pushing Town in the wrong direction, Vote: Michi.

@Vro, I know I am your top scum read, at present, but clearly, my lynch is not happening today. So with that said, who are you leaning towards voting for, who could actually be a proper wagon?

So, I'm going to share my reads list in its current form. Understand that this is my first game. I'm not going off of how people have played previous games or whatever, I'm going off of mainly gut feeling.

Spoiler

@Vro, I know I am your top scum read, at present, but clearly, my lynch is not happening today. So with that said, who are you leaning towards voting for, who could actually be a proper wagon?

First of all "@Vro" That actually made me smile

I never planned on voting you anyway, and yes I can clearly see that there won't be one on you. Personally, I'm rather at a loss here. Everyone has been making the obvious choice, going for me, or the right choice, not going for me (biased I know but how else would I phrase it?) and I'm not getting a lot of information out of it because both sides have strong reasons. Michi has had by far the weakest case at least in my opinion, but I really feel that he wouldn't make that kind of mistake as scum. The other people who have posted are being extremely cautious in what they say, and I would really like the others who haven't spoken yet to share their thoughts.

If I had to vote someone right here, it would probably be Vote: Willie-Harlia. I just have so little good reads on people at this point because I'm so paranoid from the stress of being targeted that I really feel the need to scope out people who have been lurking but letting the town eat me alive.

No, I'm not going to let you start a vanity wagon.

Unvote Vroendal
Vote: Michi

And with that, I'm making two wagon choices. Anyone who votes anywhere else is dying.

This sounds very genuine, and the compelling thing about it is that you sound genuinely betrayed by Michi.

So yeah. Everyone now has a choice between Pengu and Vro. No other wagons are encouraged, because then we have a harder time analysing people's choices.

No, I'm not going to let you start a vanity wagon.

Unvote Vroendal
Vote: Michi

And with that, I'm making two wagon choices. Anyone who votes anywhere else is dying.

This sounds very genuine, and the compelling thing about it is that you sound genuinely betrayed by Michi.

So yeah. Everyone now has a choice between Pengu and Vro. No other wagons are encouraged, because then we have a harder time analysing people's choices.

Ok, I see why you did that and I respect your ultimatum, but do you truly honestly think that Michi would make a case against me without first reading the thread through/paying attention as scum (he made a mistake in his first paragraph against me) and then continue on a rather weak reason for my vote to then end up voting me? I'm willing to attribute this to my unfamiliarity, but when he played scum with me even though he had real life commitments he still made a much better attempt than this. He reads distracted town to me personally.

Town Lean: HumanSanity, Gerrick, Dawsinian, Doc

Found something intriguing - Can you explain how did you categorise Sanity under "Town Lean" when most people are reading nothing much into people engaging in minimal activity? And a bit more explanation on Gerrick and Doc would be great.

Anyone who votes anywhere else is dying.

Well, if Laurentus is unable to uphold this ultimatum, I think that would indicate that there is a good chance he is being a dishonest wolf. Either way, I find it quite likely that Lau is a powerful role, as I’d doubt he’d make these claims without being able to back them up.

No, that ultimatum will be enforced by brutalising you in the day phases until the end of time.

I won't change my vote so have at it <3

Here is my read:
Town Lock:
Myself (duh)
Dawsinian
Town Core:
Wischland
TGN/turtle, I remember feeling really confused as well my first WW game, and the sheer amount of posts probably isn't confusing them any less. If they were a Wolf, they would not be acting like this, because (presumably) the more experienced wolves would tell them what/how/when to post.
Town Lean:
Sapphiron
Laurentus
Gut feeling for both.
Null:
ogunbiyi6422, newvitalania, ENE, Dawcreek (no posts)
Flying Eagles and HS, no discernible information from their posts
BraveSirRobin, haven't seen many posts from them.
Michi I could go either way on.
Scum Lean:
Hapi, something just doesn't sit well, I don't know.
Vroendal, they've been a bit too aggressive for my liking
Gerrick, his whole voting for Dawsinian then not unvoting once posting saying he didn't mean to start a wagon thing seems weird to me.
Scum Core: None yet
Scum Lock: None
With that in mind, I am going to Vote Lynch: Gerrick

*Begins brutalising Hapi

Here is my read:
Town Lock:
Myself (duh)
Dawsinian
Town Core:
Wischland
TGN/turtle, I remember feeling really confused as well my first WW game, and the sheer amount of posts probably isn't confusing them any less. If they were a Wolf, they would not be acting like this, because (presumably) the more experienced wolves would tell them what/how/when to post.
Town Lean:
Sapphiron
Laurentus
Gut feeling for both.
Null:
ogunbiyi6422, newvitalania, ENE, Dawcreek (no posts)
Flying Eagles and HS, no discernible information from their posts
BraveSirRobin, haven't seen many posts from them.
Michi I could go either way on.
Scum Lean:
Hapi, something just doesn't sit well, I don't know.
Vroendal, they've been a bit too aggressive for my liking
Gerrick, his whole voting for Dawsinian then not unvoting once posting saying he didn't mean to start a wagon thing seems weird to me.
Scum Core: None yet
Scum Lock: None
With that in mind, I am going to Vote Lynch: Gerrick

Hmm, I am curious why you'd classify Vro as aggressive.

Hey look my wagon has support.

One thing we haven't even discussed is that nobody died last night and how or why that might be so I'm gonna need some quick clarification don't kill anyone yet please

Hey look my wagon has support.

One thing we haven't even discussed is that nobody died last night and how or why that might be so I'm gonna need some quick clarification don't kill anyone yet please

What are you expecting here? That a defender is just gonna come out and say "oh, hey, I protected this person?"