View Topic

Ok, if roles aren’t necessarily based on alignment then I can’t say They’re both town or both scum.

Hmm.

@ExLight, did you protect Funnier?

No, I protected my own ass because I thought scum would come after me since the watcher died.

That's fair.

Okay, so I think we should start posting reads lists.

I've been wary of doing so, since this is a massive game, but that might help us get a better idea of what each of us has noticed.

On it, we could also say who has played here a lot, and who hasn't, which might help us answer the question of who is very new to the game, too.

Also, guys, please refrain from posting exact details about your night actions as far as possible.

You can use it when the time is right, for example when you can out someone's lies and help us lynch particularly tricky scum.

Scum is almost guaranteed to plan their own night actions around every piece of info they gain about our roles.

All this seems to confirm is that in every game I've played, Pengu and Laurentus seem to always end up in power roles. *cough cough experienced players bias*

OOF I'M GONNA GO BALLISTIC it logged me out mid post i am peeved. i'll try to recreate the exact post lmao

since laurentus asked, i played for a few years on zd, then fell off the wagon. i came back recently and have been playing very sporadically. (laurentus i believe we've played together before?)

i'm currently townreading barnes, laurentus, ex, minish, and hapi.

I have suspicions of varying degrees on the following players (some of these are just copy/pasted from my notes, sorry if they're difficult to read):
Sapphiron - said to be experienced. hopped in, didn't vote and instead voted to push the button.
Wintermoot - took no stance on EOD1 wagons. voted someone with no votes instead. potential distancing but that's based on nothing
El Fiji Grande - voted ex with no explanation and then dipped
Madeline Norfolk - posted nothing that actually contributes to the game. recently has said "don't lynch me i'm just here for memes" which reads to me as "help this is my first game and i rolled scum"
Red Mones - iirc there were pings throughout D1 but i didn't write them down (they must not have been very important lol). what i'm most interested in is what i perceived as a small "panic" (exaggeration on my part) when two people voted for them. this one isn't as strong as the others and i probably wouldn't pursue them today, but they're definitely on my radar.
Pengu - i've already laid out m'case

Everyone else didn't strike me. I ought to reread, but Effort™. also i think Ex vs aragorn was town vs town probably.

Also, guys, please refrain from posting exact details about your night actions as far as possible.

You can use it when the time is right, for example when you can out someone's lies and help us lynch particularly tricky scum.

Scum is almost guaranteed to plan their own night actions around every piece of info they gain about our roles.

^^^^^^this (granted, i'm a person who hates pointless roleclaims in general)

ah shit i forgot to add my consideration of button pushing. i want to push the button but i probably want to settle into the day a tad bit first. my rationale is that sure it could benefit scum but it could also benefit town, plus i want to see what it does uwu i don't often play with funky mechanics

Forgot about the button. I want to try these new mechanics Ruguo has blessed us with and i think it’ll give us information. Vote: Press the Button

Vote: Press the Button

Gimme those spicy changes

I think we should focus more on the quieter players. I think this Pengu train we are rolling on now screams of the same town vs town attack ExLight v Aragonn did.

If I were wolf I'd be playing quiet and letting the noisy players eat each other up while picking up the scraps.

I'm largely focused on Madeline, Moot, Aren, Urban, god actually looking at the list there's a LOOOOOT.

I am quietly terrified of @Marzipan as well.

@Ruguo, could you perhaps update the OP with who is dead, and who has since subbed in for who?

Also where’s @taulover and @Hydra?

I think Taus been around a bit. Hydra has been MIA though which is a concern.

Docs barely posted too.

I've never played with so many players, so I keep forgetting who everyone is that's playing in this. I mean I usually forget about a couple in our normal 12-15 person games because they're not so vocal, but this game has a lot of people going under my radar.