View Topic

I think my brain filed away the "elder Valerian" as some sort of star wars lore word for some variety of Sith... I still have no idea what it means.

I think your aggression at this point is likely the result of your past experience. This is my second game of Werewolf, so I'm just an ignorant girl here, but I suspect that you've found that only way to reliably stop a pile is to do it early and violently?

I don't want an unjustified pile any more than anyone does.

Vote: Abstain

Of course, being an experienced player yourself, you may have decided to take Sapph out, counting on your ability to talk your way out of it to save you... you'll be patting yourself on the pack quite tidily right now in that case.

Valeria is my house name, and those in my house are Valerians. The Elder Valerians are the four of us who were in Aura Hyperia together: taulover, Colberius X, Laurentus, and myself.

Also, thank you again for rescinding your vote against me.

My vote for Moot still stands, as he's experienced and definitely not stupid.

Aragonn's a Sith! He admitted it!

"I am an evil, power hungry Sith Lord bent on dominating this game"

Aragonn's a Sith! He admitted it!

"I am an evil, power hungry Sith Lord bent on dominating this game"

Jesus. What is this? The New York Times?

And @Wintermoot, I had considered mentioning people, but that might get pretty spammy.

Ooh... I think that I'll be voting this round for Aragonn.  The biggest thing that I have learned in my short time in Wintreath Werewolf is that edits can be big problems... just look at what my edits last game as a newbie did.

Aragonn has been steering the conversation, and I would have assumed that the Sith would have dispatched of him already if he was controlling the conversation and moving it in a direction that they didn't like. 

Ooh... I think that I'll be voting this round for Aragonn.  The biggest thing that I have learned in my short time in Wintreath Werewolf is that edits can be big problems... just look at what my edits last game as a newbie did.

I knew trying to fix that one line to code properly would be the death of me...

Aragonn has been steering the conversation, and I would have assumed that the Sith would have dispatched of him already if he was controlling the conversation and moving it in a direction that they didn't like. 

I'll admit I was steering the conversation at the start, but I dropped out of the spotlight when I got busy IRL. I haven't resurfaced to the forefront until people started piling on me. And can you blame me? I'm trying to survive here!

As for the Sith not killing me, I don't know what their motives are because I have no idea who they are. They could be keeping me alive because I look suspicious as fuck. It could be that they don't see me as a threat yet. Maybe both. I don't know.

I would have assumed that the Sith would have dispatched of him already if he was controlling the conversation and moving it in a direction that they didn't like.

I could be steering the conversation in a way that doesn't hurt them, in which case they'd leave me alone.

If there's one thing you learn from playing this game, it's nothing is black and white, only many shades of grey.

Watch as both Evelynx and Aragonn are innocent.

Ok, so after doing some thinking, I think I found a possibility that might interest you guys. Just before anything, I'm using a lot of what-if logic here. So, lets say the four people who first voted for me were all innocent. Ok. Then that would mean that Chanku made a late order to the Sith after seeing the stockpile. But say, perhaps none of the people who were in that stockpile gave the order, but an outer force. What I'm getting at here is close to one of Sapphiron's posts,

Rasdanation, if I were to speculate, while some of those who have voted for you may be the Siths, allow me to ask you this. What is the likelihood of you being a Sith? Before HannahB’s reasoning regarding Chanku’s abrupt vote switch, you were the most affected by the bandwagon effect.  Hypothetically speaking, it could be that since you were a “shoo-in” for being lynched, the Siths decided that it is safer for Chanku to jump on the bandwagon and vote off an ally, thus directing suspicion away from him, except Chanku did it too quickly and ended up looking even more suspicious.

but instead to the point that they used me as just a platform to execute their plan. In other words, perhaps the Sith did plan to have one or two of their members join my bandwagon, and have one of them have a suspicious vote, making everyone turn on that Sith, while having their own Sith members vote him/her out. As we do see, this member would turn out to be Chanku. So, perhaps we are close, just looking in the wrong places.

NOTE: Just to clear out Wuufu's death, as of I see it, that was an unintentional casualty, since it turned out as he died through killing RE-0N. My theory for why he joined the bandwagon instead of suppressing any suspicion on himself was because the Sith planned on using him later on to cast suspicion away from themselves in future situations.

I find it interesting how your theory excludes me, but everyone else, except Eve, finds it better to just dogpile on me.

I kinda need to vote.

On the other hand, I have no idea who to vote for!
I'll play it safe and throw away my vote to LIVE.
Vote:Pengu

Ok, so after doing some thinking, I think I found a possibility that might interest you guys. Just before anything, I'm using a lot of what-if logic here. So, lets say the four people who first voted for me were all innocent. Ok. Then that would mean that Chanku made a late order to the Sith after seeing the stockpile. But say, perhaps none of the people who were in that stockpile gave the order, but an outer force. What I'm getting at here is close to one of Sapphiron's posts,

Rasdanation, if I were to speculate, while some of those who have voted for you may be the Siths, allow me to ask you this. What is the likelihood of you being a Sith? Before HannahB’s reasoning regarding Chanku’s abrupt vote switch, you were the most affected by the bandwagon effect.  Hypothetically speaking, it could be that since you were a “shoo-in” for being lynched, the Siths decided that it is safer for Chanku to jump on the bandwagon and vote off an ally, thus directing suspicion away from him, except Chanku did it too quickly and ended up looking even more suspicious.

but instead to the point that they used me as just a platform to execute their plan. In other words, perhaps the Sith did plan to have one or two of their members join my bandwagon, and have one of them have a suspicious vote, making everyone turn on that Sith, while having their own Sith members vote him/her out. As we do see, this member would turn out to be Chanku. So, perhaps we are close, just looking in the wrong places.

NOTE: Just to clear out Wuufu's death, as of I see it, that was an unintentional casualty, since it turned out as he died through killing RE-0N. My theory for why he joined the bandwagon instead of suppressing any suspicion on himself was because the Sith planned on using him later on to cast suspicion away from themselves in future situations.

So just to follow up on this, here are the people who voted for these people

Chanku

HannahB Wintermoot Evelynx Govindia Rasdanation Feast Potatoes/Crushita Sapphiron Pengu Aternox

Wuufu

Sapphiron Evelynx

I find it interesting how your theory excludes me, but everyone else, except Eve, finds it better to just dogpile on me.

The only reason my theory didn't include you was since we don't have definitive proof on what role you are. Who knows, you could be third distraction Sith...

I'm not intentionally making myself a target!