View Topic

The suggestion that Sapphiron was killed in part to frame Aragonn makes a lot of sense to me. Honestly, I think that if Aragonn was a sith, him killing Sapphiron would have brought too much suspicion on him, and that's not something the sith would have wanted.

On the other hand, Wintermoot and Evelynx are looking reasonably innocent. Both of them cast early votes against Chanku, and at the time there were other options they could have taken if they were sith.

To me, it seems both groups are fairly equally innocent looking. I'd expect that if the wolves were planning on leaving Aragonn open to by lynched today, they wouldn't post anything dissuading us from doing so early on. I'd assume that means North might be a villager too, but it could always be a case of a sith trying to mislead us.

As to who I will vote for, I've had a quick look through the thread. Not a lot jumped out at me, however, on day 3 the votes against people went like this:

Sapphiron voted against Wuufu
Evelynx voted against Wuufu
Colberius X voted against Evelynx
Barnes voted against Rasdanation
Rasdanation voted against Barnes
DekuNut voted against Rasdanation
El Fiji Grande voted against Barnes

We had a sith with the most votes against them (excluding the no lynch votes). To me, that means that if people started changing their minds Wuufu could have been in trouble. 

Either DekuNut or El Fiji Grande could have been bringing the votes to a tie just in case things started to turn around.

Vote: Lynch DekuNut

Yo guys, completley forgot this was a thing for a while there. I'm gonna catch up real fast and then talk to you guys.
Also, since it's the last post before this one... *waves to aternox*

Okay, not really forgot... more like remembered it was there but didn't want to click on the link back to the game... I'm great like that

Catch-up post:

I believe that I'm going to vote No Lynch. I don't want to be responsible for Barnes' death in the event that he's innocent. I'll review in a bit though once I get to a computer.

Another post I don't like. He's worried about his reputation with the town, to such an extent that he's willing to vote no lynch to prevent being on a town wagon. If he didn't think Barnes was guilty, he would've just said it, but here it sounds like he sees the reasoning but isn't joining because rep.

Well, as luck would have it, both of my brothers participating in this game of Werewolf were knocked out, and I pointed that out. To further my bad luck, Sapph took those two quotes of mine and stuck them together as a good enough reason to knock me out too.

But there's one hole in his little theory, one which I pointed out. My brothers were targeted by two different groups; one was killed by the Sith and the other by CH-4NK0. Seeing as how these two are not in contact with each other, it stands to reason that neither group could be targeting me specifically to be their decoy. Thus, his theory turns to Swiss cheese.

Good enough explanation for you? Or do I need to recount the events of my latest trip to Jakku as well?

So you're saying that Sapph had to do with the death of at least one of your brothers?

And @Wintermoot, I had considered mentioning people, but that might get pretty spammy.

When I play on other sites, we post player lists, but without linking them. That way it's not spammy, but we can still see a list of who's alive and who's dead.

Ooh... I think that I'll be voting this round for Aragonn.  The biggest thing that I have learned in my short time in Wintreath Werewolf is that edits can be big problems... just look at what my edits last game as a newbie did.

Aragonn has been steering the conversation, and I would have assumed that the Sith would have dispatched of him already if he was controlling the conversation and moving it in a direction that they didn't like.

The first half of his reasoning seems off. I don't know what your edits did last game, but having part of your reason for a vote being edits? Is it that big of a deal to you?
As for the second half, I can more see your reasoning there, though I won't follow in your footsteps because of it.

Either DekuNut or El Fiji Grande could have been bringing the votes to a tie just in case things started to turn around.

Vote: Lynch DekuNut

Why me over Grande? Just asking

So, looking at all this, my suspicions as of now are alighting on Robin and Aragonn, mostly because of the posts above. Tomorrow I'll take a look at Chanku's death, as well as do a little more looking into those two. However, just because I need to vote before the end of the day
Vote: Brave Sir Robin
Just in case. He's on my list and has received fewer votes today than Aragonn. I'll reevaluate tomorrow.
Sorry I've been so quiet guys. I'll try to be more active from here on out.

I'm not sure who the Sith cold be at this moment, so I might as well do a random vote and let the game progress. I believe Aternox won't get voted out this round so I may as well vote for him/her.

We should probably listen to Aragonn a bit more closely...

But there's one hole in his little theory, one which I pointed out. My brothers were targeted by two different groups; one was killed by the Sith and the other by CH-4NK0. Seeing as how these two are not in contact with each other, it stands to reason that neither group could be targeting me specifically to be their decoy.

Knowing that the Sith and CH-4NK0 cannot communicate, we cannot view Aragonn with suspicion for making the comments about his brothers deaths.  I could be a bit biased in this matter, but I think that it's more likely than not that Aragonn is innocent at this point. 
Additionally, I find it interesting that DekuNut resurfaces as soon as he's accused by Aternox of being a Sith... and I mean right after.  I refuse to believe that it is simply luck that he "resurfaces" 50 minutes after he's accused.  Thoughts @North and @Evelynx ?

Well, as luck would have it, both of my brothers participating in this game of Werewolf were knocked out, and I pointed that out. To further my bad luck, Sapph took those two quotes of mine and stuck them together as a good enough reason to knock me out too.

But there's one hole in his little theory, one which I pointed out. My brothers were targeted by two different groups; one was killed by the Sith and the other by CH-4NK0. Seeing as how these two are not in contact with each other, it stands to reason that neither group could be targeting me specifically to be their decoy. Thus, his theory turns to Swiss cheese.

Good enough explanation for you? Or do I need to recount the events of my latest trip to Jakku as well?

So you're saying that Sapph had to do with the death of at least one of your brothers?

I can see how you would think that, but no, that's not what was said.

Seeing you guys finally start listening to me is cute and all, but I still have the highest vote count at two votes. I could change my vote to even it out, but it's still a 50/50 that I'll die.

I'll change my vote to DekuNut. Mootster, you've been spared a day.

DekeNut

Do we have any reason at all to suspect DekuNut? Why does Aragonn need to have evidence to be guilty but DekuNut doesn't?

I'm not pretending that Sapphiron's death doesn't implicate Aragonn at all just because it's not perfect, solid evidence. We don't have perfect solid evidence against anyone.

Do we have any reason at all to suspect DekuNut? Why does Aragonn need to have evidence to be guilty but DekuNut doesn't?

I'm not pretending that Sapphiron's death doesn't implicate Aragonn at all just because it's not perfect, solid evidence. We don't have perfect solid evidence against anyone.

Vote: DekuNut because this sounds shady

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S4 via Tapatalk

I randomly picked someone who already had a vote against them to try an save my ass before the end of the day period.

I'll vote Abstain for the time being.

The past couple of days have been stressful in Osiris, guys, and that's why I am late in voting. My bad, and I'll pay more attention to this from now on.

I can't do much to defend against this. I showed up the post after someone voted for me. Whoopty doo. Check my online status over the last week I haven't been active at all on the site. Plus, why would it matter if I got one vote? I wasn't anywhere near majority, nor the person with the most votes. I can see the reasoning for maybe one vote, but basing an entire wagon on that one thing is ridiculous.