Post #176191
January 07, 2025, 10:55:20 PM
That reminds me of how I tried to ask AI to run a single player DnD style campaign for me to play through. I like fantasy type stuff, used to do a lot of reading, but I still have that fear of male dominated areas that I probably mentioned 6-8 years ago, so an interactive story without that risk seemed like a great idea.
Started out great anyway. Gave me a starting area, a campaign objective, and some ideas of what I could do. But then I started to think that having an AI DM is like having a DM who is perfect in every way except that it has no memory for anything that happened more than one minute ago.
Tried having an ally. Sent them off to find more information. They immediately ceased to exist.
Ignored the quest item at first. By the next time it was mentioned, it had a completely different name.
Found out the villain had three spies in town. Tracked one down. They revealed that the villain, whose gender got swapped suddenly, has three spies in town, with no mention of the two I ignored earlier.
I set up camp for the night in a forest. The next morning, the quest was completely forgotten. Unfortunate, there was going to be a dragon.
Tried to start over with a very simple dungeon crawler. Got bored after three rooms in a row of "You find a door surrounded by runes". My impatience may have been obvious: The first time I carefully studied the runes and the entire room. The second time I stood guard while an ally solved the door. The third time I just bashed the door down.
After several restarts, I noticed that without specific input, names and themes would come up repeatedly. Expect to encounter the Mysterious Whispering Woods in the land of Elysia a lot. The AI was not really being creative, it was giving me what it thought the average DnD campaign is supposed to be. This is particularly obvious if you make the mistake of asking to start in a tavern
The only way I could keep it interesting was to become increasingly unpredictable. But then I had to stop when I realized that in order to make the fantasy world of the AI more interesting, I was basically playing a sociopath.