View Topic

Time: Round 9 Day

Root Host: Michi

Players · Votes · Posts

Vote: Wintermoot

It's not such a bad play if you can then convince others that doing so makes you less likely to be a wolf. And that doesn't really answer my question, just repeating that her actions weren't suspicious or wolfy isn't elaborating as to why. Maybe it didn't actually turn out that way, but with what I knew then my suspicions were very valid, and this pretending otherwise is really going out on a limb here.

So for that reason Vote: Dolby.

Abby doing a thing that makes her more likely to die is not wolfy, specifically her voting you. Idiosyncratic behavior is not wolfy

i don’t really care about the information arguments tbh. I didn’t find them wolfy, I can see how finding them wolfy can be valid. What you did though starting out by claiming that her voting you in such a way that made her more likely to die is wolfy was flat out wrong, and it’s easy to say that with her dead now, but 99 times out of 100 that player who has prospects for the next day but does something that makes her more likely to die that day is town


If I die in this rand kill this guy with fire. 

And yes, Abby should have voted Kiddian if he was logically consistent, that doesn’t matter though, she did something that she knew increased her odds of dying that day on principle and that should have been recognized as pure

Also yes bad arguments do exist, they don’t make people town, what I’m saying is that Abby did something mechanically that didn’t make sense for mafia to do, rather than say that Abby was town on a social level

i totally didn't self protect two nights in a row and am totally not out of self heals :p

Wintermoot straight up ignoring this is a massive lol

Actually if anyone places a last second vote on me, they should die and Wintermoot should live as duped town most likely.

If I die in a rand though he needs to get out

Also yes bad arguments do exist, they don’t make people town, what I’m saying is that Abby did something mechanically that didn’t make sense for mafia to do, rather than say that Abby was town on a social level

ok I'm realizing this may come off as insulting to Wintermoot reading this again. That is far from my intention. I was trying to explain why mechanical suboptimal behavior in the manner that Abby did was particularly towny, in comparison to any weird social behavior which... I don't think was wolfy or bad, I don't want to spark a debate midgame, but I can certainly at least see how someone can think that is wolfy

.ybloD dna ,niboRriSevarB ,toomretniW neewteb eit yaw 3 a htiw sdne yad ehT

.tressed einwot raluger a ,ekaceseehC yrrehC a saw eH  .GNR aiv eid ot nesohc neeb sah toomretniW

.stegrat noisiced lanif rieht em dnes seip dna selor rewop tnaveler lla dna yna nehw reilrae ro...51/70 no won morf sruoh 42 dne lliw tI  .thgin ot evom ew won dnA

oof

gonna try to solve the game before i eat my nk

Shoot completely forgot to post during this phase and lost track of when it would end. darn IRL concerns...

Gonna need some time to reevaluate my suspicions now that there is three day phases worth of information (though at the same time it feels like there isn't much information for reasons besides the relatively low number of posts).

From what I have seen of BSR in other games, I agree with Gerrick that they could easily be a quiet wolf and so my suspicion of BSR is rising.

Honestly, at this point, it might be a good idea just to lynch Robin and see what happens, either we kill a wolf or we kill an inactive townie, either way, with nothing else to go on, its not a bad play.

Also, sorry for being inactive, work these last two days has been, as the kids these days say, cray cray.

Vote: BraveSirRobin

You have to put a / before vote in the last brackets to count @Kiddian

Vote: BraveSirRobin

You have to put a / before vote in the last brackets to count @Kiddian

Vote: BraveSirRobin

Ah. You’d think seven months of ns wouldve taught me that 

.yltnerruc gnitov on s'erehT  .esahp thgin llits si siht ,oslA