View Topic

Game Over on Round 4 Day

Root Host: Arenado Other Hosts: Marzipan

Players · Votes · Posts

Oh nice.

I’m hoping Vro is the vig then personally

But like

It’s Neon most of the time anyway

Ah, in that case if that's true then KoD is the vig and it is just Neon.

I claim Amne - Escort. I was Doctor "Who" and now I'm another doctor.

Ok yeah this is just locked for town then unless Michi is hostile and I very much doubt they hostile

Bc me good
KoD good
Vro good
Mel is killer -> doc
Michi is rownsiding 3P 

Vote: Neon Abigail

I've pretty much had identical vibes about you that I did with Doc for a while, but I brushed them off because KoD was clearing you and KoD was one of my top town clears.  However, that last night kill pretty much seals it for me that those vibes were correct.

I'm still confused though @Melehan. Was your claim that you were attacked N2 accurate or not? If it was true, then how could Neon have made the kill attempt if the host confirmed that going over the post limit disabled night actions? It was untrue, then why did you make up that whole convoluted mess when you could've just said that you were the medical anomaly doctor? You claimed doctor anyway.

The kill on n2 probably happened and was directed onto Mel. I’m not told if a heal is successful but I do know that I healed the anomaly. Mel’s point in that regard is just bad but it doesn’t change that they used to be the killer, whom I healed and this probably changed, there hasn’t been a killer kill since n1, and Neon is probably the wolf chief and Melehan isn’t the wolf chief. If Neon is a wolf chief and the game doesn’t end we get Mel or Michi

These are the only things about roles I know for sure right now.
1) There is a confirmed vigi.
2) I am an un-CC'd anme-escort.
3) Whichever player Michi votes is chopped with no seeming exceptions.
4) Gerrick saw Dolby visit Neon N2. Dolby is a visiting role.
5) Gerrick saw Neon visiting Aers N2. Neon is a visiting role.
6) Aers was a transporter, and KoD and Michi are late-claiming to have been transported.
7) Aers was killed by the Wolf Chief.
8 ) The Wolf Chief is still alive.
9) There has not been a kill made by the Killer since N1.
10) A medical anomaly was resolved on N2.

11) The following character roles are still alive: 
The Audience (Michi?)
The Strange Case of Doctor Jekyll and Mr Hyde (Mel?)
House (Dolby?)
The Dead Zone (Neon)
Titans (KoD?)
Doctor Who - Rocky Horror Picture Show (Myself)

I personally believe that there’s good odds that me healing Mel on N2 prevented her from committing a kill that night but like this is pure conjecture

I still believe that a role that can decide the day vote would be very unlikely to also have a kill power.

Hmmm. Spitball crackpot theory, n1 Dolby visited Neon, who hid behind Aers. Dolby was the Wolf Chief and therefore killed Aers. N2 he visited Mel which turned her into another wolf resolving the medical anomaly and that's why there was no kill, and why there's been no kill from the Killer. There was never any doctor in the game. Kane gave his neutral result without yet knowing that Mel was on the wolf team, and Dolby wasn't on yet to fix everything.

@Dolby can you help me out and tell me why this isn't true? My only reason is that you would probably be much more engaged with the thread and your team if you were a wolf, but you're also Dolby (4) so I want another reason.


Pardon my shenanigans but I do want to look into every possibility.

I’d never kill Svip as a wolf even though he is investing Neon, because I didn’t know there was a vig. That would basically just guarantee Kane as a wolf for the following day. In addition, Mel wouldn’t point out the Doc/Svip interactions kinda spewing Svip. 

Also I would never have my team both kill and investigate Mel on the same night. Thats just incredibly suboptimal

Or do whatever conversion you think was attempted while having Kne invest Mel at the same time, again, subjectively suboptimal wolf play 

I’d never kill Svip as a wolf even though he is investing Neon, because I didn’t know there was a vig. That would basically just guarantee Kane as a wolf for the following day. In addition, Mel wouldn’t point out the Doc/Svip interactions kinda spewing Svip.

Also I would never have my team both kill and investigate Mel on the same night. Thats just incredibly suboptimal

Or do whatever conversion you think was attempted while having Kne invest Mel at the same time, again, subjectively suboptimal wolf play

But because Svip was flipping investigator anyway, that would also have confirmed KoD as good and myself as bad in the eyes of the thread. You could have flipped the vote onto me. The Mel point is valid.

I'm just caught up right now on I don't know why Mel would claim to have been attacked when she wasn't, but then how does that resolve with Neon's power being taken away that night. Something very weird happened N2 and I really want to resolve what happened today. Yeah it would be incredibly suboptimal. Would only really make sense with Kane Lost Wolf, which is a very strange setup.

I'm definitely voting Neon out today, I can't really go anywhere else. Thx for humoring me.

I think the simple thing is that Mel actually was attacked N2 and neither of us were told about it

Also I personally think that a Svip flip makes Kane look much worse than you even though they were inspecting you but that’s my take and not Neon/Michi/kods take

I think the simple thing is that Mel actually was attacked N2 and neither of us were told about it

No the simple thing would be that Mel just assumed she was attacked because she turned into a doctor so she knew a doctor visited her, and there was no kill. Neon's action was host-confirmed to have been taken away for N2 right?

I just need a complete and true explanation of events from Mel. That claim was wack.

Since there were no deaths and I 100% for sure knew I had been visited by the Town Doctor (since I was now Town Doctor #2), I concluded that I had been the target of the scumteam's kill that night. It turns out, there was no kill that night because Neon's penalty was to lose her action, and Wolf Chief was the only KP on the scumteam's side.

I'd targeted KoD for a kill that night, but my conversion to Town Doctor #2 effectively blocked that.