View Topic

Game Over on Round 7 Day

Root Host: Ruguo Other Hosts: Michi

Players · Votes · Posts

Well, Wiml is up for sub, lol.

Debates whether it would be more helpful to only read the posts from the previous player...

I mean, I kinda think that Moondrop is town regardless? Like, Neon, how long did it take to get Moondrop to claim

It depends which slot he subs into. Is it only Moondrop up for sub?

Think so, yeah.

Red Mones, Wintermoot?
I'm not sure whether Moot's hit 2 posts from a player standpoint or whether his mod posts count...

Well, Wiml is up for sub, lol.

Debates whether it would be more helpful to only read the posts from the previous player...

I mean, I kinda think that Moondrop is town regardless? Like, Neon, how long did it take to get Moondrop to claim

It depends which slot he subs into. Is it only Moondrop up for sub?

Think so, yeah.

Red Mones, Wintermoot?
I'm not sure whether Moot's hit 2 posts from a player standpoint or whether his mod posts count...

Er. Good point. @Red Mones, @Wintermoot, come post! 

Oh I'm going to get a new toy?

is wiml the turtle

is wiml the turtle

He's the demon tortoise who subbed into Attack on Titan and wrecked your collective shit, yup. 

@NoName, what is your take on Ex?

My take on Ex is tainted by KoD. I feel like the dynamic between to the two is off from it's norm. My experience with Ex is only like four/five games deep? On his own I don't feel he's particularly scummy but I've only seen his scum game once and I didn't particularly pay attention to it as I was a 3p lover with scum!KoD at the time. I'd be inclined to say that being scum together wouldn't necessarily effect their dynamic but that doesn't take into account who else may be on their team and doesn't account for the possibility that they may have drawn a lover bond themselves (which would be hilarious). 

is wiml the turtle

Tortoise*.

Could someone sum up the arguments for KoD's lynch, please? I'll go reread their posts in the meanwhile.

is wiml the turtle

He's the demon tortoise who subbed into Attack on Titan and wrecked your collective shit, yup.

*war flashbacks*

@NoName, what is your take on Ex?

My take on Ex is tainted by KoD. I feel like the dynamic between to the two is off from it's norm. My experience with Ex is only like four/five games deep? On his own I don't feel he's particularly scummy but I've only seen his scum game once and I didn't particularly pay attention to it as I was a 3p lover with scum!KoD at the time. I'd be inclined to say that being scum together wouldn't necessarily effect their dynamic but that doesn't take into account who else may be on their team and doesn't account for the possibility that they may have drawn a lover bond themselves (which would be hilarious).

oh god it's JD after all
weren't you also in tevish's end of the world mafia? I was scum there too

as much as I'd personally like to see KoD's head on a stick I don't think they've been particularly scummy?
if anything I find myself agreeing with them this game more than I'd like 

Hey Ex can I force you to give read on everyone real quick or nah

Could someone sum up the arguments for KoD's lynch, please? I'll go reread their posts in the meanwhile.

Mine is that he hasn't been trying to solve me, has cherry-picked my comments, and has actively tried to shade me for things I didn't even express, in some cases literally expressing the opposite of what he's accused me of. 

Currently, with ENE, I'm not feeling that great about him simply because of his claim. A flavor cop, a variation of the investigation role, seems more like the tool of a scum team as opposed to town. I say that strictly because of where I come from where that is very much the case, but also because of how ENE approached the cc then and how he touts his result now.

You're a town "PR" (in the sense that your role can gather info to help find scum maybe). Someone else claims to be a cop, and you have the option to counterclaim them (as I recall, you called for anyone that wanted to counterclaim right Laur?). Unless you're sure of your claim to the role, I don't see why you'd out yourself right away. Especially with no investigations under your belt (unless you got a D1 check which is rare in most games from my own experience). ENE did cc, but also was hesitant with said claim up to the point of rescinding. Like, you're not a straight cop. You get a role (or role name or something). Not an alignment. Automatic variation of a cop which opens up the door to the thought, "Hey, there *may* be more than one cop given my own role." Factor in, then, that with his result ENE is now going, "Should I or should I not," leaving it up to everyone else. Why? You've already outed yourself. Why leave it up to us when you know, if you're being honest, that everyone knows who you are. This is more akin to a scum tactic of getting in deep with the town. More so, given the claim, if ENE is said role as scum and can hunt for potential PRs based on role name (and we know that roles come from across various games -- ie. Scarecrow and the 3p role that CL was).

That's my particular take on ENE at this moment.

I'll be honest, I don't really understand the bolded section. Perhaps you could rephrase it?


What I get from this is that you didn't like my hesitancy with regards to sharing my results and that since I had outed, I should've shared it my info immediately.

My hesitancy stemmed from two main points:
- Not understanding the Scarecrow role and not knowing whether it was a good idea to out a possible town PR role
- Not wanting to out Vro in case he was town and didn't want to be outed


Additionally, you said that if I was scum with this role, I'd use it to PR hunt. In that case I don't get why I would share my result with the entire thread? I don't really see how this values the scum team.

@NoName, what is your take on Ex?

My take on Ex is tainted by KoD. I feel like the dynamic between to the two is off from it's norm. My experience with Ex is only like four/five games deep? On his own I don't feel he's particularly scummy but I've only seen his scum game once and I didn't particularly pay attention to it as I was a 3p lover with scum!KoD at the time. I'd be inclined to say that being scum together wouldn't necessarily effect their dynamic but that doesn't take into account who else may be on their team and doesn't account for the possibility that they may have drawn a lover bond themselves (which would be hilarious).

oh god it's JD after all
weren't you also in tevish's end of the world mafia? I was scum there too

You say that like you're not happy to see me. 
Also that was the one you refused to hit me at the end of the game wasn't it? I'll have to review both and see if I grab different feels then.