View Topic

Game Over on Round 7 Day

Root Host: Ruguo Other Hosts: Michi

Players · Votes · Posts

Something looks way too off for Laurentus-Dolby episodes. Laurentus fakeclaimed, to which Dolby supposedly had said something to Lau, and he was 'right on money' on that part. Later on, we see that Laurentus' fake claim seems to bring Dolby to a statement where he says that most of what Lau did was fake, and it didn't seem a comfortable tone either. Some posts later that comes to a close, Dolby and Laurentus going back to a mutual feeling of comfort. There has also been a post from me, asking Dolby and Lau whether they had options to be connected, since it seemed that Dolby had previously known about his fake cop shot. That seemed to get totally ignored, I guess that could have led to some sort of soft, but it doesn't seem right in the present scenario. Dolby has also made some vague-looking comments, which I will get back to later on, because the multiquote isn't working. This looks scum Dolby. Also Laurentus has used distancing in a game where I saw him as scum. The Dolby episode did look like one.

Aer and Neon looks good(anyone who speaks Tea is good) TGN feels odd, Ex might take this mix of prior guilt during lynch and laziness as a way to shield his alignment.

Yeah here's the thing Lau

I think all of this is fakeable and I also didn't like AG's reaction to your claim.

I think that you're townreading this specifically because AG is expressing a read that we have behinds the scenes talk but frankly in this case I just don't think that it is strong, and I think it that the point that AG holds us higher really doesn't work that much. I think this is the type of thing that a scum could notice and attempt to hold over a townie. I feel say that you two aren't w/w but yeah

"So Gerrick's fate is sealed" is also totally w/v word

I was confused ovee cop shot and vigilante, I mentioned that earlier. Also I didn't really understand the Lau's statement of you being right about how the fake will play out. I thought you knew it all beforehand and you predicted how individuals will react, later on I understood it was about the fake you seemed to be predicting. 

fuck yesss

@Anubhav Gosh, @KingofDominaria
I noticed you both abstained from voting, any reason for that? who would you have voted last phase if you had to?

@Eastern New England
Do you remember what TGN's age is?

It would have been you or Lunch. 

At this point, I have no idea what Scarecrow's alignment would be, but you may as well share who you scanned, ENE.

Pennywise seemed afraid or irritated by turtles

As I look at this vote count it looks, to me, like there is at least one mafia member among those voting for CL. Why? Because CL was 3p, and Laur had accomplished the singular task of fake copping someone, lying about it, and creating a situation where CL made himself an easy target to vote. The rub with voting CL, though, comes in the form of CL's claim which is best exemplified by Laur. That is, exercising caution and going elsewhere with a vote.

We have 7 voting for CL:
Captan Lunch: 7 (Cozmikrae, Abbi, Dolby, Wintermoot, Gerrick, NoName)

And I would expect at least one to be mafia.

Notably, the only other wagon close to CL's staggering 7 votes is Gerrick at 3 which isn't saying a lot.

Gerrick: 2 (Aersoldorf, Captan Lunch, Laurentus)

Or 2 I suppose if there are shenanigans going on with the votes. Excluding CL, that leaves only Aer and Laur as the ones on Gerrick. I see Aer more on the townie side of things if only because I haven't disliked his posting. He hasn't struck me with anything scummy in terms of content, but I am interested in why he went with Gerrick here as opposed to CL. Laur's position is already known regarding why he voted Gerrick. His interactions with people are varied and idk how I'd place him as scum wrt to potential teammates (for example my take on ENE and then having to assess Laur/ENE as being on a team which calls for a look at how they've interacted -- I don't see it necessarily unless Laur is power wolfing and ENE is playing ballsy with claiming which makes for an odd combination in and of itself for D1 which I find hard to convince myself of even if I were biased).

Going back to the 7, I'd choose Wintermoot every single time. Gerrick voted the only other wagon than himself which is understandable. Dolby hasn't struck me negatively or oddly to date, and No Name has appeared townie to me with their content (most notably how they've responded to others). I'm ignoring Neon here for now because of her high fluff content and constant talk about neighbors and tea. I mean, only talking about that and posting a large amount of fluff and gifs doesn't do it. It took jumping in on CL, which was easy for anyone, to get some reaction from her, and I don't feel strongly about it. Like, hard null kind of feeling. Cozmik moves on by as not a stand out person to me.

Outside of Wintermoot, from that large group, I am looking at Anubhav with the vote on No Lynch. There's something to be said about someone who doesn't get drawn in by how CL reacted to everything. Like, not even going after CL, Anubhav opted not to go for, say, Gerrick much like Laur in an attempt to treat CL's claim seriously. Might be a time thing though. Might.

What else is there? TGN and ENE's votes? Eh.

It was 1.43 am when Lau spoke of faking, and by the time I got on this forum the next day, it was night time. I was late by 5-10 minutes:)

Fuck it

Vote: KingofDominaria

I'm just doing this cause I don't think I'd ever wanna play with you.



I only invite special people for tea

Hey, do you want a pet joey(its a baby kangaroo)?That's an alive plaything

I am quite sus about Ex and KoD. Dolby is no scum, he would have started talking abstract stuff by now, seasoning every post analysis with adjectives. That's the only scummy behaviour I ever saw from Dolby.

Ex's mix of guilt and laziness is still not explained.

KoD has been paranoid on many since the start, and since I have played like 3-4 mafia games now, this looks much like how I behaved in almost all games. But the same on KoD, looks odd.

Aers posts look good, Neon has been indicating endlessly on a loop, and I wouldn't mind saying that I have some concept of what she is referring to, but I might well be way too wrong. 

I am not good at spotting derps, and overderps. Nothing on TGN for that reason.

However @KingofDominaria can I have a read list, because I don't understand who appears scum and who appears town to you

Pinky promise isn't banned in here or is it ? @ExLight

Pinky promise isn't banned in here or is it ? @ExLight

No, it isn't, per se, but it's a definite trust tell as per MU's rules. 

Ex. If I know one thing about games that Silv does its that the flavor ALWAYS matters.  And also I know for a FACT that the characters in this flavor are in the game

it doesn't this time, and I'm 100% sure of it

While the players in the outside world made their choices and things happened, the forest clearing was back to its cheery self, though the players were growing increasingly disappointed that nothing actually happened to warrant these characters all being in such a setting.

Realizing this, Michi rewrote the story as the forest clearing scene began to shift almost violently, as it shifted through various scenes including one where apparently a rock was hurling through the air and pelted Lancelot in the face as he screamed out about how he was being oppressed.

The scene cut to what seemed to be a daycare or kindergarten classroom or kid’s party or something…it wasn’t quite clear.  But what was clear was that it was a strange group of werewolf children, which frightened some of the group, although Joffrey decided to play with a nearby dollhouse and Don Michael Corleone hired all the wolf children to be his informants.

The scene suddenly shifted again just as Joffrey was about to have the boy doll executed for not following his orders.  Now they were in a village that looked just as remarkably dull as the forest clearing, although some of the folks such as Knightman and Everyman felt instant recognition upon seeing the village…apart from what looked to be a Macys in the center square in which Mai Valentine and Ruby Red immediately ran toward, dragging the reluctant Princess Leia and lady Galadriel with them.  Lindsey Lohan and Hannah Montana followed close behind, darting over to the makeup counter.

“Uhhh, was Hannah Montana even in one of our games?” Asked player Red Mones, as Eastern New England chimed in.  “I think Michi’s getting confused since she was in one of the games that he hosted over in our region.” They replied as Laurentus facepalmed, while Wintermoot simply gave a friendly chuckle at Michi’s obvious moment of being scatterbrained.

Batman watched from afar as Joker and Two Face shared cat videos with each other near the village fountain, while the Scarecrow went crazy and threw toxin bombs everywhere in a fit of boredom, throwing the crowd into a state of mass hysteria. Folks such as Pennywise started screaming about seeing rainbows and turtles…two of his worst fears, as others screamed about anything from dental hygienists to the skyrocketing prices of fast food at McWendleking…which ironically wasn’t something they were seeing as an effect of the toxin since they miraculously weren’t near it.  Everyone seemed to get over the effects pretty quickly, though one in particular seemed to remain in that state of confusion…mistaking up from down, blue from green, and good from bad.

The villagers all sang and danced even as a bloodthirsty wolf not in sheep’s clothing tore through the village and killed them.  Erwin Smith was horrified by the villagers’ seemingly complacent behavior in this, while the village elder assured them that it was something that happened all the time…which made Erwin question why.  Jackie Chan attempted to fight back, though the large werewolf seemed to ignore him the entire time.

“Okay, now I know we didn’t have a game with Jackie Chan.” player Red Mones pointed out, as Wintreath member Barnes popped in.  “Maybe Michi is just being creative because I was going to host an Around the World in 80 Days game?” he suggested, as player Gerrick sighed.  “He could have at least taken from the good version of that story if he was going to do that.”


All actions are processed. There was no death last night. I am still in the process of sending back results to people who need them but wanted to get the day started.

Day 2 begins now and will end on Sunday, the 30th at 3pm CST.

"You'd show town"

Okay it's specifically said here that Scarecrow, Joker and a few others from the Batman game are in the game. They can't all be Wolves. I think you have a town result.

have you considered that maybe most of these characters aren't even roles in the current setup
we have characters from 24+ different mafia games, if they were evenly distributed that would be less than one character of each game

but you think the game has at least 3-4 from the batman game?
Please stop obsessing with flavor, it mean literally nothing because a) as I said the characters in these game have nothing to do with the characters from their original games, this meaning not only role but maybe alignment are unrelated; b) flavor has already been said to possibly be misleading in the very OP, meaning it shouldn't ever be seen as a reliable source of analysis or information

ENE's role is vastly useless if it's just a flavor cop and its only utility is verifying character claims which by itself is a bit useless (see point a.)

Please stop caring about flavor, it's a waste of time

I ended up agreeing it's a waste of time for me specifically, if you actually bothered to understand my next post, because having 17 roles mentioned when one person died already, as well as the person dying already having had their own role mentioned in the previous day, proved that there were more roles being mentioned than exist in the game. And my own role not once appearing yet (which I again mentioned in the next post) is what sealed the deal for me. So your interpretation of my viewpoint here is largely wrong.

Where I fundamentally disagree with you is that a flavour cop is not useless, I was that myself in Portal Mafia 2. As frustrating as it was to have to decipher my results, it resulted in the whole mafia team getting lynched on consecutive days starting from D2. I have no reason to assume that it won't be the case here. But I think pretty much only time will allow ENE to gather more info to put the various roles in context and decide alignment from them. A common theme can also start to emerge once more flips happen.

So TL/DR, flavour will mean very little to the average player, at least right now, and probably only the flavour cop is well equipped to make sense of it with time.

In portal mafia the characters were related to their alignments, right? I don't think that's the case here, Lunch was just a coincidence of being 3p in both cases, as small of a chance as that is

Ugh. I'm being tempted to do something dumb here.

not again :rinsad:

Feel free to AMA Vro, same to Neon if she comes back

Also ENE I want to talk to you

Thoughts on ExLight, please?
Also current thoughts on Anubhav?

Do you see a wolf-team potential yet for anyone?
What has been the most valuable insight from the game so far?
Why can't I ever feel confident reading you?
What's your favorite color?
Can you guess what I mean by the wine dark sea?

I'm having difficulty this game outside of establishing townreads on like half a dozen people. I think he's ok and reading back I think his reads are alright for accuracy probably

Anubhav had a bad reaction to Lau's claim. I get that there may have been confusion between cop and vig, but that post has no convinction in Gerrick's scuminess, and really without that REALLY reads like a wolf commenting on town Gerrick dying. I'm not a fan of his activity either. I didn't like him bringing up me/Lau a second time, and the only thing I liked from him was basically him saying he hasn't seen a scum me post early game

Nah, but I have some anti-aligns that I'm not gonna list
I really don't know. Maybe something said in Lau/KoD but I'm ngl my brain keeps wanting to purge itself of some of that interaction for some reason. I actually liked KoD breaking up the CL wagon even though I felt that he tossed aside half the people for not good enough reasons. Still, with activity levels being heavily skewed towards 6 people out of 16, i can't say it's unjustified
I'm to powerful
Blue
You're wifoming

I barely showed any reads other than my discontent towards Laurentus' play though? What about them did you find "alright"?

Pinky promise isn't banned in here or is it ? @ExLight

Probably not, but I'm not going to use it unless I feel like it's extremely necessary lol

page 69 is all mine so far babe hell yes

@Neon Abgail
hey I can potentially be a neighborizer too! so that's fun!


maybe we could get in the same chat and add twice as many people uwuwuwu

@Neon Abigail

frigging i

also sorry about the post spam multiquoting is hard