View Topic

I am actually that convinced, plus I am not sure if I will have the energy to look back at the game after work, that I am going to

Vote: tau

Do we lose if we mislynch today ?

If we mislynch, the remaining human would kill another townie tonight and win, so yes.

I feel it can be tau , given how he defended BSR wrt wagonomics

However I am much inclined it to be either Vro/Sapph , because this is the best time for wolf to take out the top villager. Again , tau wouldn't possibly do that and draw suspicion. However the hard claim of Nyght not being a defender , was initiated by Vro

@Vroendal that message was more for you

This statement might have gone under the radar , but a wolf would obviously try subduing Nyght now.
As of Sapph , the only reason he won't kill Vro , is because he might go all wrong as a town leader over tau. Also I don't see Sapph following the rest like the other days , he votes first today. This is atleast not in sync with what he was doing for the rest 2 phases

Since Sapph can't change his vote , @Vroendal do you want to go hasty or wait ?

Tau tried to build a wagon with Vro on it , do you think Vro that BSR and Tau will try to stay on the same wagon against you, if they are scumbuds, given their experience. Tau seems clear given this PoV

I think that 95% of the time here the remaining human is tau. I want to hear him out first though in the interest of the 5%.

I don't quite understand your point with the top villager, judging that I don't think there's a point where tau has been town-read by anyone, the top villager would be either Sapph or me, in your scenario of one of us being the remaining human. I don't think it's Sapph at this point in light of the way Doc attacked him in the phase Gerrick was lynched in, read back and look at it.

I don't think Sapph's voting times have followed any specifically notable pattern, he's pushed plenty of players independently from what I can recall.

I don't want to be hasty in cases where votes are locked, if you vote tau now that's fine, I think it's the correct choice. If I get a big revelation I can always vote with tau to make a tie and we wouldn't lose in the night phase.

You were actually the one to form the wagon on me, tau was the last to join it. I think tau's vote against me was motivated by his interest to remain alive and not because he claimed to suspect me, the purpose seemed to be to form a tie for No Lynch, ensuring tau's survival. So no this wouldn't clear tau, and in fact the two human buddies voting together to try and keep a human alive for another day phase would make sense so that actually incriminates tau.

Tau, who should I be voting today instead of you, and why?

However I am much inclined it to be either Vro/Sapph , because this is the best time for wolf to take out the top villager. Again , tau wouldn't possibly do that and draw suspicion. However the hard claim of Nyght not being a defender , was initiated by Vro

I don't think it's Vroendal because I think the evidence for Vro being on Hydra's seer army along with Laurentus is just too strong. Honestly, I still find Anubhav suspicious for not getting this in past rounds. (Then again, it's been a while since I've reviewed the evidence, perhaps it wasn't as strong as I thought, considering I was also convinced about Sapph's claim about Nyght.) I'm not sure about the day 1 seer check argument, I'm not used to games where people straight-up explicitly ask the seer to scan them so I'm not sure how to interpret that, alignment-wise.

I could get behind a Sapph wagon. I've assumed he was villager based on his attempts to deduce and reveal the roles, but as we're narrowing down the players I think the probability of that being a derp move that happened the play out well for us is increasing. If we only have enough votes to tie, that wouldn't be ideal, but it would be better than us immediately losing now, and the night kill could give us some more info.

Tau tried to build a wagon with Vro on it , do you think Vro that BSR and Tau will try to stay on the same wagon against you, if they are scumbuds, given their experience. Tau seems clear given this PoV

As I have stated repeatedly, I firmly believe (or at least believed at the time) that Vroendal was confirmed town. My vote was purely to avoid the mislynch on myself, it was literally right before the end of the day phase, there was no chance of actually killing Vro.

examples, for reference

Well uh, I hate to do this but blatant self-preservation vote lmao

Vote: Make Vroendal Leave

Reasoning: lynch town is worse than no lynch

okay I am not letting Vro die,
Vote: taulover

Tie wouldn't lead to Vro dying tho

I think that 95% of the time here the remaining human is tau. I want to hear him out first though in the interest of the 5%.

I don't quite understand your point with the top villager, judging that I don't think there's a point where tau has been town-read by anyone, the top villager would be either Sapph or me, in your scenario of one of us being the remaining human. I don't think it's Sapph at this point in light of the way Doc attacked him in the phase Gerrick was lynched in, read back and look at it.

I don't think Sapph's voting times have followed any specifically notable pattern, he's pushed plenty of players independently from what I can recall.

I don't want to be hasty in cases where votes are locked, if you vote tau now that's fine, I think it's the correct choice. If I get a big revelation I can always vote with tau to make a tie and we wouldn't lose in the night phase.

You were actually the one to form the wagon on me, tau was the last to join it. I think tau's vote against me was motivated by his interest to remain alive and not because he claimed to suspect me, the purpose seemed to be to form a tie for No Lynch, ensuring tau's survival. So no this wouldn't clear tau, and in fact the two human buddies voting together to try and keep a human alive for another day phase would make sense so that actually incriminates tau.

Tau seems most reasonable as well. One last thing , do you think the last night, in which there was no-kill, on that night the defender defended you , and you were the one humans targetted?

I don’t care if this makes me look dumb if Tau ends up not being scum, but this is so painfully obvious that I frankly cannot tell why Anub is so hesitant on this. Honestly if you guys want to lynch me, go ahead, I will laugh when I get revealed as townie.

In fact, I rather you guys lynch me and lose, than to get another ridiculous tie and patiently wait while another townie gets killed (i.e. that’s how cozmik died) 

Because I am putting it out there the only person the human will logically kill is Vro, our only confirmed town. Ends up with Anub, Tau and me and there’s bound to be suspicion three way. This is the last phase to win, period.

Its not about making the lynch, my top scumread is Tau , fact is I want to see it out.

I guess its majority eyeing a Tau lynch.
Vote: Make Taulover leave