View Topic

Ey, my reads are going to continue to assume that the defenders are playing sensibly here, so I really hope they are.

after waking up at 5:01 from my nap, I now can continue playing
I have a slight read list.
I don't know about most of the people, but there are three people I can read.

TGN- Town: I just really think he plays well, town 100% (I'm sorry, I had to)

LoS- Bully lean (scum is mean and would that make US a bully if we called each other scum? [once again so sorry]): He played well last game, but now I know his starts. It seems like he hasn't posted much yet, but I got my eye on you

BSR- Town lean: seems... ok, for now.

Doc- Town: Very helpful.

IT JUST SAID 3 NEW POST WHILE I WAS TYPING!
HOW
million WPM GEEZ
THEN WHILE ADDING SOMEONE ELSE, 2 NEW POSTS!!!!!!! 
good to see u are all active tho

I actually think ENE is scum.

do you think that because there can be only one turtle?
but you do make a good point, in your other posts.
Vote: Make ENE Leave

From framing LoS as a  Bully lean to "you do make a good point"  and subsequent voting of ENE , this seems sinister to me . If ENE changing reads is fishy , I guess this looks same as well

Can you please elaborate?

I agree to everything you said , but TGN and ENE seemingly have done the same thing that makes them look scummy , so I will go for TGN today.

I mean, reads can change.

Also, TGN does actually have town leans, so he could be a defender.

Actually, good question, I don't know the current vote count myself.

I gotchu fam.

Vote Tracker:
Gerrick: LoS
Nyght: LoS
Lau: Anubhav
Gerrick: Anubhav
Doc: ENE
Anubhav: ENE
Laurentus: ENE
TGN: ENE
Sapphiron: Colby
Colby: Hydra
BSR: TGN
Anubhav: TGN

Vote Count:
LoS - Nyght (1)
Anubhav - Gerrick (1)
ENE - Doc, Laurentus, TGN (3)
Colby - Sapph (1)
Hydra - Colby (1)
TGN - BSR, Anubhav (2)

ENE is majority wagon for the moment, with TGN as secondary.
With the revelation that No Lynch does not count towards modkill and taking into account the number of people who've voted, the list of people who must vote today or risk modkill is Cozmik, ENE, and Tau.

Alright, so:

At this point I definitely think our main wagon should be ENE. If he's Town, then I am very confident he's not any role we need to worry about, like a Seer or defender, so we'd lose comparatively little. He also has a better case against him than any of the other low-posters, since it's based on meta from LoS specifically, and it will be a good chance for us to gauge to what degree we wish to trust LoS's reads going forward. If he actually does flip scum, then in my mind, I would immediately feel a lot more comfortable with LoS, since he doesn't strike me as someone who would needlessly bus.

Bolded you have your answer for question 4, Anu.
The meta LoS decided to use bothers me to some degree.

If that's a soft, it's a bit late now.

People I'd be willing to consider voting today:

ENE - For reasons previously stated. His read on me also seems super opportunistic/pockety.

Hydra - Only made one post and I think it was a scummy one but only a weak read. I'm sympathetic to the fact that they are busy but I'd ask that we deal with the slot mechanically (elimination or seer check) and not let them ride until late into the game because if they are town they will definitely get mischopped at a bad time if we don't.

Gerrick - I don't like how he made a post defending Anubhav but then had Anubhav as the second-lowest read on his list in that same post and then votes Anubhav in the following post. I feel like if his defence was genuine, Anubhav would surely be higher for him? I think the scumread on me was something he just did without putting much effort in and that he only actually justified it after I questioned him on it (and his apologetic tone makes me think he knows I'm town -> TMI). Last game Gerrick was extremely insightful and I know I personally saw him as a huge threat but I'm not seeing the genuine solving I saw then here.

 (This might be worth saying now but I don't think Gerrick is w/w with Nyght or Lau and I think if Gerrick is scum he is likely to have an inactive scumpartner based on his prodpost).

Might consider Taulover/Colberius X if either a good case is made on them or I see something bad when I have time to ISO them but for now I think they're fine.

Vote: Gerrick

ENE has enough votes for me to not need to go there rn.

Actually, good question, I don't know the current vote count myself.

I gotchu fam.

Vote Tracker:
Gerrick: LoS
Nyght: LoS
Lau: Anubhav
Gerrick: Anubhav
Doc: ENE
Anubhav: ENE
Laurentus: ENE
TGN: ENE
Sapphiron: Colby
Colby: Hydra
BSR: TGN
Anubhav: TGN

Vote Count:
LoS - Nyght (1)
Anubhav - Gerrick (1)
ENE - Doc, Laurentus, TGN (3)
Colby - Sapph (1)
Hydra - Colby (1)
TGN - BSR, Anubhav (2)

ENE is majority wagon for the moment, with TGN as secondary.
With the revelation that No Lynch does not count towards modkill and taking into account the number of people who've voted, the list of people who must vote today or risk modkill is Cozmik, ENE, and Tau.

Lol Doc I did vote no lynch yesterday.

Either way... I do intend to vote today. Need more time to make up my mind. We have more than 12 hours left right?

Lol Doc I did vote no lynch yesterday.

I won’t be around for EOD I think. So I’m gonna throw my vote on the

no lynch

pile for now.

Ah. Missed it in my votecount cause you didn't use the (Vote: XYZ) format; I've been assembling my lists specifically by searching for that.
I'd be cautious about it, because as Michi specifies,

Your choice will be marked with Vote: Make (insert name) Leave, or simply vote: (insert name) in bold.  Voted choices will be removed from the game like normally.

So in future I'd probably ensure your vote fits that format if you want to be sure it's counted.

Votetracker update:

Vote Tracker:
Gerrick: LoS
Nyght: LoS
Lau: Anubhav
Gerrick: Anubhav
Doc: ENE
Anubhav: ENE
Laurentus: ENE
TGN: ENE
Sapphiron: Colby
Colby: Hydra
BSR: TGN
Anubhav: TGN
LoS: Gerrick

Vote Count:
LoS - Nyght (1)
Anubhav - Gerrick (1)
ENE - Doc, Laurentus, TGN (3)
Colby - Sapph (1)
Hydra - Colby (1)
TGN - BSR, Anubhav (2)
Gerrick - LoS (1)

ENE is majority wagon for the moment, with TGN as secondary.
Lots of one-vote wagons, and frankly not even that big a primary one, which seems like it should be rather more of an area of concern to people, but then again the one really flipping out about diffuse wagons was Exlight last game and I didn't particularly understand his reasoning then anyway.
Also mildly surprised given his activity earlier than ENE hasn't just slapped on an OMGUS/tiemaker survival vote onto TGN to even it up.

Ahh noted.

So the scummiest on my reads list is now Colberius X . Anu has talked themself into a null for me. So with that said:

Vote: Make Colberius X leave

I'm interested in how ENE flips but I also don't have the meta to feel super comfortable placing my vote there. Right now, Colberius's lack of content makes them seem like they're hiding something.

Gerrick - I don't like how he made a post defending Anubhav but then had Anubhav as the second-lowest read on his list in that same post and then votes Anubhav in the following post. I feel like if his defence was genuine, Anubhav would surely be higher for him? I think the scumread on me was something he just did without putting much effort in and that he only actually justified it after I questioned him on it (and his apologetic tone makes me think he knows I'm town -> TMI). Last game Gerrick was extremely insightful and I know I personally saw him as a huge threat but I'm not seeing the genuine solving I saw then here.

Don't quite know where you're saying I defended Anubhav or where you think I had an apologetic tone. I said I was worried that Anubhav was trying to pocket me and then had him second-lowest on my reads list (second only because Laurentus didn't want to vote him for some reason). And I wasn't apologetic for voting you, but I was just saying that I didn't have a hard scum-read on you but that you were just the scummiest then (not counting Anubhav).

@Michi - What happens in the event of a tie?

So the scummiest on my reads list is now Colberius X . Anu has talked themself into a null for me. So with that said:

Vote: Make Colberius X leave

I'm interested in how ENE flips but I also don't have the meta to feel super comfortable placing my vote there. Right now, Colberius's lack of content makes them seem like they're hiding something.

I'm hiding (poorly) how absolutely overwhelming the amount of posts in this topic is.

Alright I've only quickly skimmed over the thread and here are some thoughts:

Town-leaning:
Laurentus
LoS
BraveSirRobin
Doc

Null/Maybe Scum-Leaning: (not a very flushed out or well-thought out list)
Gerrick
Eastern New England
Anubhav Ghosh
Cozmikrae
Colberius X
Sapphiron

Everyone not mentioned is in my null list for now. Keep in mind that this is with a VERY brief look.

For now, I'll Vote: Sapphiron but it is fairly baseless.