View Topic

[Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?]

Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?

Yes

7 (87.5%)

No

1 (12.5%)

Total Members Voted: 8

Voting closed: February 24, 2021, 10:57:44 AM

ExLight, how are you feeling about Nyght?

I think that 90% of the time the scumteam is exactly two of Gerrick/Moot/Nyght.

Vote: NyghtOwl

Come on, he's obviously playing up the innocent newbie card. Why would he talk about how he didn't know how scum communicated. With how Michi was distancing from him when we were voting off TGN (on mobile at work, not gonna try to find it) and how he's been distancing himself from Wintermoot since D1, it's gotta be him and Moot.

Why would I talk about it? Because I was surprised. Pardon my inexperience in a game I've only just started playing. I've been doing my best to follow along with everything and make the best decision I could each time.

It seems like you're pretty excited to jump at any opportunity to throw suspicion into some one else at this point.

My guess is that earlier points about Moot being the unkillable titan are spot on and that puts you on the chopping block. So it would make sense to try and take whatever chance you can to save yourself. You get me lynched and then they'd have to hit you and moot in that order before you can kill anyone else. Which would be pretty damn hard now that we don't have any defenders.

Anybody know how many mislynches  we can do we before we lose? And that's counting lynching the armored titan as a mislynch.

Anybody know how many mislynches  we can do we before we lose? And that's counting lynching the armored titan as a mislynch.

We can either mislynch once or we can hit the armoured titan once.

Anybody know how many mislynches  we can do we before we lose? And that's counting lynching the armored titan as a mislynch.

We can either mislynch once or we can hit the armoured titan once.

That means we really can't afford to lynch the wrong person here. If I was a wolf, why would I be concerned about lynching someone on a day 1? I didn't want to do it because I was working under the impression that every mislynch is a point in favor of the wolves. Since then I've been trying to follow along with the many theories and trains of thought being brought to the table. And when I voted I did so because what people said was making sense. I fell behind on things because yes, I have a full time job as well as a fiance to balance. And I didn't vote because I didn't feel like I had the info I needed. But I've been trying to help when I can.

I mean, I have a full-time job as well as a spouse, but as Michi proved this game, being busy IRL does not mean you're not also scum.

And your behavior can easily be chalked up to being instructed by your scumbuds to play up being a new player just as what happened with TGN last game when he was scum.

So neither mean you aren't scum. But man, if you aren't scum then Doc or Ex are really playing us. But I don't want to think about that yet.

Thinking back through the game, I'm inclined to think Gerrick is town based on hard-clearing me early on with Sapph's poem. While most others were trying to figure out what it meant, he came out independent of anyone else and cleared me just like that. Now, I was a top townie based on the the Ruguo lynch, so it could have been a ploy to gain towncred by clearing someone who was obviously town, but I'm not really sure. In my mind wolves would obviously town clear obvious townies for towncred, not so much hard clear like he did. The Cozmik lynch could also potentially point to Gerrick as scum. They might've lynched her because at that point she was the only one pushing against Gerrick. This could also be an attempt to frame him, so idk.

Also, I'm damn glad I've been mech-cleared since I went from top town to sus in a matter of a couple hours after that Vro fiasco.

I'm also inclined to agree with Gerrick about Nyght. The new player bit seemed waaaay overplayed there.

Wait lol we literally all forgot Red existed

This happens a lot tbh. It helps me out a lot since I don't really have respond since I'm rarely called out. It does also help that I'm practically always town

Thinking back through the game, I'm inclined to think Gerrick is town based on hard-clearing me early on with Sapph's poem. While most others were trying to figure out what it meant, he came out independent of anyone else and cleared me just like that. Now, I was a top townie based on the the Ruguo lynch, so it could have been a ploy to gain towncred by clearing someone who was obviously town, but I'm not really sure. In my mind wolves would obviously town clear obvious townies for towncred, not so much hard clear like he did. The Cozmik lynch could also potentially point to Gerrick as scum. They might've lynched her because at that point she was the only one pushing against Gerrick. This could also be an attempt to frame him, so idk.

Also, I'm damn glad I've been mech-cleared since I went from top town to sus in a matter of a couple hours after that Vro fiasco.

I would actually say that Gerrick concluding quickly that you were the cop check is something that a wolf would love to do. Regardless of if you actually were the check, the absolute best person for the cop to have checked, if wolves can't make people think one of them was checked, is the person who is regarded as almost certainly town anyway. I remember people throwing around the idea of other players like Kane being the cop target. This would have been bad news for scum if this meant that somebody like Kane could no longer be mislynched.

To conclude, I think it's a reasonable thought process and definitely not a scum tell but I don't think it makes Gerrick look more town at all.

Cop = seer, noticed too late.

How would you order the five people in the PoE, Red?

Let me think about, they all seem town to me lol. I was thinking Moot should be the first target, but that last post, especially with the vote against you, seemed a bit townie to me, and the busyness definitely checks out.

Got to agree that if Moot was a wolf I think he would have picked an easier target than me (because I don't think I am an easy town to mislynch before the clear) even if him not reading the thread is just NAI.

Got to agree that if Moot was a wolf I think he would have picked an easier target than me (because I don't think I am an easy town to mislynch before the clear) even if him not reading the thread is just NAI.

Like, my first reaction was "Moot is obviously a wolf at this point. His partner is clearly Gerrick or Nyght and he's desperately trying to lynch somebody outside of the narrowed pool as a last ditch effort and went with me" but I think it would have been a much better move if wolf-Moot (assuming he genuinely didn't know about the clears) had voted for Red or Doc instead as they're both less active and were much more heavily tinfoiled / distrusted compared to me.