D3 general recap and analysis:
Page 37:
-Red Mones scumreading Gerrick. I think this vote is coherent with the events from D2’s EoD and thus towny.
-Vro opposes BSR and Wintermoot. Immediately prompts me into reading Minish and questions me on why I’m townreading her.
-Wischland makes a readlist, a pretty large amount of scumleans. Shouldn’t the expected be a ton of nulls and townreads? I need to recheck later to see if her list is coherent with her plays.
-Red Mones commentary that 3 strong players subbed-in so someone should be scum for balance is nonsensical. It’s pure RNG, us being considered strong players means nothing, the host isn’t to interfere with this kind of stuff. Oh Minish points that out right after. Anyway, seeing Vro and Nyghts being core Town here bothers me a bit.
Page 38:
-HD notices Silver possibly praising Vro. Hmm, pocketing? Kinda ambiguous but favorable towards Vro.
Page 39:
-Me and Minish discussing a few things.
Page 40:
-Me and Minish discussing TGN and a bit of Vro.
-Gerrick saying they were pinged by Red. Why is Red worried about whether or not Gerrick is being voted? Can someone tell me if they’re close or something? Nevermind, Doc clarified a few pages later it was about something else.
Page 41:
-Oof TGN saying they were now focused on helping. I feel bad now, sorry again buddy.
-Sapph voted BSR. Also emphasized he did not see the Vro thing as wolfy which is kinda weird, is it coherent with his D2 mindset? Might be a green check on Vro.
Page 42:
-Hmm, I didn’t like the Silver/Ogum interactions despite the fact I’m Townreading Smiles. Am I being fooled by the turtle? I’ll still bite the bullet and trust them. Still not a fan of Moot pushing Red since I’m townreading Red.
-HumanDawn points out that weird Anubhav Ghosh interaction again, hmm. I don’t remember if I mentioned it in a previous recap. It’s a bit weird and makes me iffy of him if Vro is Town.
-Doc discussing game philosophies again. Oh ok, he explains what that ping thing was about, good. Also tunneling on a TGN and Vro scumteam, the logic here is fine. TGN flipped Town but since it was brought to me he was just a kid I don’t think he realizes in depths of the game, him not even trying to vote a counterwagon to self-preserve shows that and I feel like while this might be taken as protecting a scumbud it could be also just not being sure on how to play, and I feel like Doc should’ve been aware of this? Maybe he just had expectations too high for TGN, but still.
Page 43:
-Continuation of a small discussion on whether or not to not lynch. It’s simple, we should always expect 2 deaths per phase (unless inactives are around to mess things up that’s why everyone has to be active), so we can predict when -Lo will happen. LyLo is always better because it means smaller PoE, so better chances of lynching. It’s a bit tricky because Doctor might protect someone but if that puts us in MyLo it’s actually technically worse. I need to remember if No Lynch is allowed in MyLo, but since we can only use it once scum might be able to manipulate that with the kills, so it’s a bit weird.
-Vro says a lot.
-Smiles hardclears EME.
Page 44:
-Anubhav justifies him weird post. Hmm, it’s quite the advanced thinking for a first game, it’s kinda interesting.
-Gerrick makes am useful post. I actually agree with pretty much everything in it except for the Kane laying out thoughts well. He might be one of those players that just are able to persuade me easily so I’m mildly paranoid specially after Minish dying after slinging them out.
-Vro and Gerrick vote BSR. Ok, so see? This is the kind of shit that makes me nervous. Vro jumps right after saying they’ll bite into the BSR argument. There’s no argument, lol, you’re wanting to get rid of him because he put your ass in the line before. Big wagon forming, doesn’t really mean much. Makes me think Vro and BSR aren’t scumbuds together
Page 45:
-Discussion about the importance of Meta.
-Minish’s recap of Silver. There’s definitely stuff here hinting at other scum, hmm. It’s kinda weird. I don’t really like the Doc interaction. The BSR interaction seemed fine from what I remember? I don’t remember finding it artificial, hmm.
-Minish also seemed to think Sapph and BSR weren’t aligned. I might give another look into their interactions with each other, but Minish flipping Town makes me wanna just sheep some stuff she was into. She also gives a readlist later one, stuff didn’t change much.
Page 46:
-cozmikrae also ISOs Silver and seems to have the same feeling towards the Silver/Doc interactions that I had.
-Doc and cozmikrae vote TGN, so its wagon is now a leading one.
-Jesus Christ my opinions were completely shit, sorry I’ve been townleading :rinsad:
Page 47:
-Me pressuring TGN (sigh).
-Smiles votes somewhere else.
Page 48:
-Wischland’s post showing two sides of the same coin kinda pokes me a bit, but the logic in it is fair, I don’t think there’s anything for us here.
-Vro posts make all my red flags rise snsnfkgomdks is it the way he words these or what? He says TGN is reading townie and still says he might vote for TGN. I have no idea what that BSR interaction in the beginning was about and it also bothers me. I feel like there’s a considerable chance of Vro and BSR not being same alignment
Page 49:
-Surprisingly Doc defends BSR. I actually agree that it’s prolly NAI, but if BSR flips scum maybe I’d consider the odds of Doc and BSR being scum together slightly higher.
-Vro hits up with the generic “I don’t know who to trust!!”. A bit early for that and a bit scummy but ok.
-TGN and Sapph’s wagon gain the lead and become the guaranteed lynch of the day. I think maybe one scum in the split wagons and the other two not voting. Considering the flips and my townlocked reads that leaves Doc, Vroendal, and Wischland.
Page 50:
-Nyghts post here is interesting. Can be taken as scum voting somewhere else to not leave a trail, but could also be Town that still haven’t caught up with the latest votes and still thinks BSR is viable. This makes me think that if BSR is scum, Nyghts isn’t likely to be a scumbuddy.
Page 51:
- Wintermoot’s post. Votes Sapph while pointing out his soft as “generic”. I don’t like the rest of the post either, kinda like “twas so obvious TGN was town” vibes and I actually remember them throwing shade at TGN back in D2, so this is quite the red flag behavior.
-Oh my fucking god. What is that post from Vro quoting Sapph and asking him to soft harder because that “isn’t enough”. Rolefishing much? This also shows that the whole “Please unvote, Anubv!!” is extremely weird.
-Sapph mentioning people rolling scum twice catches my eye in his post but I’m not sure if that leads anywhere, I’ll recheck the scum from last game.
-BSR actually voices the worry about Saph being a power role, which actually makes me have really mixed feeling towards him. nsjshdnsksuwhenmf would scum do this? Was it already a guaranteed lynch to their eyes? Wouldn’t Town hesitate in trusting a soft? Really really really mixed feelings here.
Page 52:
-I hate Vro’s post. He sees Sapph’s post softing harder and goes like “nah, you did what I asked but I still don’t believe you” BUT STILL ASKS ABOUT SOMEONE TRYING TO JUMP OFF THE WAGON. He later makes a list with his scumreads, he’s suddenly trusting Sapph (despite not panicking over the fact a Power Role he trusts is being lynched) and makes a list of possible scum (which is kinda making scream internally because no way I cut or dice it it feels like everyone there has to be Town if he’s scum??).
Page 53 to 55:
-He actually seems to attempt to coordinate something to save Saph, though?? usvsigoofjosnnidindodmirb I need to reread what Vro said about this Day later on. This is a mess.
-Sapph poem.
-Vro and Anubv is basically that Spongebob scene “because he told me toooo!!!”. Vro lacked initiative to vocalize a defense of what he thought to be a power role. Hate it. If he’s scum he benefits from TGN flipping Town since Doc kept pushing that they were both paired.
-BSR makes another post pretty much OMGUSing and saying he won’t make an effort to save Sapph lol. Really hate it too.
-Doc: “Preliminary votecount off the Discord, credit to Gerrick”. Wow. You know, I made the exact same votecount before him ùmú
-cozmikrae’s tying unvote was terribly unfortunate and really pushes her a bit down in my list. From seeing her personality a bit more I feel like it was more impulsive than strategic, so it makes me think it’s more likely as town, but still a move scum would do.
No vote progression this time cuz we’re almost at deadline and I’m rushing this already.
