View Topic

[Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?]

Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?

Yes

7 (87.5%)

No

1 (12.5%)

Total Members Voted: 8

Voting closed: February 24, 2021, 10:57:44 AM

ExLight, have you gotten anywhere with your reads as of yet? Interested where you're at right now.

ExLight, have you gotten anywhere with your reads as of yet? Interested where you're at right now.

Sorry, I had a test yesterday so I didn't really had the time to make a readslist. I'm currently fetching everyone's votes for analysis atm, and I'm still not sure how to interpret the flips, but I'll try to make a rainbow list for this post.


ExLight
Red Mones
Ogun of Valeria / Legacy of Smiles
Anubhav Ghosh
Minish
Wintermoot
Wischland
NyghtOwl
cozmikrae
Doc
Gerrick
Vroendal
Imaginative Kane

BraveSirRobin
Michi


Mixed feelings on the italicized ones.

This lime isn't limey enough! ùmú

cozmikrae is supposed to be italicized too mb

Curious as to why you think I'm red @ExLight

Also I'm pretty confident coz isn't a wolf now... no wolf pack would be stupid enough to kill the one person voting for one of them, and also the last minute switch is significantly less incriminating now that we know both TGN and Sapph are good guys

Curious as to why you think I'm red @ExLight

It's just a scumlean, I'm mildly on the fence about you. I just mainly can't remember much from you.

A very limited amount of posts, weird timing when people start debating your slot, votes either super early or super late in the wagons, and a readlist that seem to be a bit too focused on the D1 wagon.

ExLight, have you gotten anywhere with your reads as of yet? Interested where you're at right now.

Sorry, I had a test yesterday so I didn't really had the time to make a readslist. I'm currently fetching everyone's votes for analysis atm, and I'm still not sure how to interpret the flips, but I'll try to make a rainbow list for this post.


ExLight
Red Mones
Ogun of Valeria / Legacy of Smiles
Anubhav Ghosh
Minish
Wintermoot
Wischland
NyghtOwl
cozmikrae
Doc
Gerrick
Vroendal
Imaginative Kane

BraveSirRobin
Michi


Mixed feelings on the italicized ones.

This lime isn't limey enough! ùmú

Thanks, this is great! There's two reads I'd like to ask you on in particular, those being Wintermoot in the limes and Michi in your oranges. When you get chance, would you mind going over your thoughts on these two briefly?

Thanks, this is great! There's two reads I'd like to ask you on in particular, those being Wintermoot in the limes and Michi in your oranges. When you get chance, would you mind going over your thoughts on these two briefly?

Just reminding that some reads are likely to change once I finish doing vote analysis so the reads are really memory based.

For Wintermoot I liked the overall tone of his posts, they seem constructive and pushing discussion. I also remember him doing a super detailed vote timeline D1 that kinda stuck to me as something super townie, because I rarely see scum doing this kind of thing specially early in the game.

As for Michi, I was rereading D1 and realized his defense wasn't as good as I thought. He was being called out for antagonizing people voting, not for not voting specifically. In his defense he proves that he has both voted and not voted in previous games, sure, but that's not what he was being called out for, so he didn't really make a counterargument. I'm also not a fan on how he dropped off the game D3 and most of his posts in the other days are focused on game philosophy rather than game discussion/planning.
He does have some interactions and voting Silver when it was speeding up going for him, though, which is mainly why I'm kinda having mixed opinions on him.

Ok but if I was wolf, why would I have killed HD?

I barely remember this player. I think this link is ridiculous.

Also, TGN flipped town. As I was completely convinced he was. With the exception of Hapi in D1, I have been on no wagons that ended in a town lynch. I think should speak for my judgment and my desire to help town.

I think that* should speak...

ebwop

Also I'm pretty confident coz isn't a wolf now... no wolf pack would be stupid enough to kill the one person voting for one of them, and also the last minute switch is significantly less incriminating now that we know both TGN and Sapph are good guys

They’re probably using this to capitalize on the suspicion I picked up yesterday to drive a mislynch. If you guys vote for me, you’ll vote off yet another town player. I think we need to pay attention to who’s driving the conversations around the wagons that flipped town.

Can anyone give me a few Vro games for me to skim?
He's a bit all over the place with his votes and reads, plus overdefensiveness. Is that normal for him?

My voting patterns are usually all over the place from what I remember. I've only played 5 games before this just so you know, one of which I died in N1 as town. I don't think my reads have been "all over the place" at all, I think that I have laid them out clearly and that they have progressed as my thoughts on the game have progressed, could you explain what you mean by that? Overdefensiveness does not exist with me, if I don't want to die I will defend myself from pushes, I don't see what's wrong with that.

First game: https://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=6530.675 (subbed in as town page 46, game closed)
Second game: https://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=6575.0 (scum lynchbait, basically jester, lost)
Third game: https://forums.bulbagarden.net/index.php?threads/the-best-anime-spongemafia-endgame-n-is-for-no-survivors-mafia-win.280579/ (scum idek what role, won)
Fifth game: https://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=6948.0 (town tree stump, won)


If I had to say a scum team, I would say Kane, Wintermoot, and the last one I'm unsure of but I'm leaning Minish. If I'm wrong on either of the first two, I'll re-evaluate.

Vote - Imaginative Kane

I'm voting Kane for a number of reasons including basic suspiciousness of his vote on Sapph, if you ISO his posts you'll find that he's used a Wintermoot post as a jumping-off point for a Sapph vote, his defense and posts aren't really cutting it for me, and we need to progress this game.

Can we not do Kane today? I have a bad feeling about him.
@Minish which page in D2 you thought you had seen something?

I saw another thing that makes me not want lynch him when rereading D1.

Vote: Imaginative Kane

For the same reasons as yesterday, the sapph vote.

HumanDawn wasn't who I expected to die and I'm wondering why. They suspected cozmikrae, some shade on Gerrick and didn't appear to want to lynch BSR. Interested on opinions here of it it was a strong player kill / defender dodge or based on one of the above reads. I'm personally thinking towards it being to either (mis)chop BSR easier or to protect a wolf!cozmikrae.

I think it's likely that they killed him because he was being town-read by a majority of players. Strong player, sure, he did stimulate conversation on less talked about points. I don't know if it was necessarily a defender dodge, could have been. I don't think trying to ascertain whether a kill was based on the reads of that player s very helpful at this point unless we start to see worrying patterns later on. Right now it's going to be WIFOM if they killed to draw pushes off of themselves, if they were framing townies that were scum-read, or if it was just a defender dodge.