View Topic

[Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?]

Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?

Yes

7 (87.5%)

No

1 (12.5%)

Total Members Voted: 8

Voting closed: February 24, 2021, 10:57:44 AM

Unfortunately, you either trust me or you don't. I am not going to commit the same sin as I have done last game, allowing over-investment in the game to result in roleclaiming and rule breach. That will have to do to explain for my detached way of playing this round. You guys will find out whether you are right or wrong in lynching me soon enough.

Also, I don't believe it's that implausible for a person to be given the scum role twice in a role. You guys make it sound like Doc wasn't consecutively Wolf before.

Hmm, that feels like more of a believable motivation.

However, I should also note that I think you're veering too far in the direction of the other extreme. If you do end up being lynched as a power role, I would consider the lack of a quality (or really any kind of) defense to be throwing in a way as well. If I assume you have thought about this already, I am left to suppose that you aren't a power role, or have a mindset of throwing on the other extreme to atone for throwing on the first extreme, which doesn't even make sense and I would not expect that from you.

I also really dislike that BSR is really latching onto the idea of you being a power role just from my slight musing, that's ringing alarm bells.

Can the option of lynching BSR still be on the table @ExLight? Just wondering.

What kind of quality defence are you expecting from me? Yes, I do admit my posts have been infrequent and my analysis not as substantial as usual. However, if you focus on my actions,

D1: Absolutely refused to partake in meta bandwagons, resulting in death of Hapi, which flipped green
D2: Tipped the momentum creating a tie against Vro bandwagon, instead supporting Melehan and lynching Ruguo, which flipped red

I'm going to Vote: TGN

Not only to semi protect Sapph, who appears to be doing some pretty good hinting here, but also because Vro wants to defend TGN, which makes me suspicious, because Ruguo was scum and because Hapi was innocent.  Do we not remember that Ruguo was trying to tie Hapi and myself and Sapph together, and then Hapi was flipped and Ruguo flipped scum?  That should be obvious enough.  Maybe I'm relying too much on Valeria being similar here, but I definitely don't think that we should vote off Sapph right now, especially if the power role is in play as a possibility

Also as far as defending myself from a mention which is now like ages ago, Vro and Ruguo were anti me the whole game basically, which makes me really think that they're scum and working together, which I think is an appropriate conclusion from my situation.  *shrug*

I like this point of Vro and Ruguo being against you all game. Which is interesting, considering you've posted like what? 5 times all game? I've heard your name from various people more than I've actually seen you post. I've never played with you before, but your nearly complete silence coupled with all the mentions against you is definitely interesting to me.

What kind of quality defence are you expecting from me? Yes, I do admit my posts have been infrequent and my analysis not as substantial as usual. However, if you focus on my actions,

D1: Absolutely refused to partake in meta bandwagons, resulting in death of Hapi, which flipped green
D2: Tipped the momentum creating a tie against Vro bandwagon, instead supporting Melehan and lynching Ruguo, which flipped red

Beyond just saving you, which is the better lynch from your perspective? BSR, or TGN?

Vro's voting and unvoting still remains questionable to me , after all , if he turns out as a scum , he will have the best knowledge about lynch consequences . Either way , I have strong gut feelings , that Vro will be lynched in all certainty . Ig everyone would be happy to remove one suspect of the list of scum than keep one hoping him to be innocent . Sorry Vro if this hurts u , but u made a bad name for urself. I hope u understand whatever the play is here , u have drawn far too much suspicion

this post raises !!! in my head

“ye bro sorry if you’re good man you brought it on yourself not because our thinking could be wrong”

This was a decoy sort of post i would say . What i was looking for was retaliation , which unfortunately took place before this post as many cited Vro's chance of being a townie and no one . I looked out for people who did not retaliate , because even after the best defenses and clarifications i stubbornly stood on my words , and said things as if it was fixed that Vro will be lynched by the town . The post did not go very well , as i did not receive counters until now , and here I am justifying why i did it . It was just a measure to clear out some people out of suspicion momentarily

Looking for retaliation makes sense. This post makes me feel a lot better about you. Your late vote on Ruguo at the end pings me, but... ehh?

I had to get my options reduced , I was pretty much sure that Vro was townie by then . However my doubts over the rest cleared up when Ruguo went in hot against Vro at the last moment , which looked like a vain push to me to save himself from getting lynched . And so the late voting . I was probably the 3rd/4th person voting for ruguo . Also voting and unvoting has got some big chaos running already , its better to vote once even if its late😅

what is the score?

Updated vote count

Gerrick - 1 (Red Mones)
BSR - 2 (Gerrick, Nyght)
Sapphiron - 7 (Minish, Humandawn, Legacy of Smiles, Vroendal, TGN, Wintermoot, Imaginative Kane)
TGN - 6 (cozmikrae, Doc, ExLight, Wischland, Sapphiron, BSR)

Yet to vote: Anubhav, Michi

incoherant screaming

Town reads -
Red, Nyght, HD, cozmik, Gerrick, Doc, Michi, Wisch
Nulls -
Minish, Legacy, Exlight, Sapph, TGN, Wintermoot, Anubhav
Scum reads -
BSR

If I choose to trust Minish, Anubhav, Sapph, and Legacy through gut reads I can narrow down further. Legacy is sussing Kane, for what I don't know yet. If I then assume there is at least 1 wolf up in a wagon right now, the wolves are among BSR, TGN, Wintermoot, ExLight and Kane. If BSR is viable, I want to go for it.

Change Vote - BSR

I feel strongly about this.

D2 results -

Ruguo - 9 (Red Mones, Vroendal, Gerrick, Anubhav Ghosh, Sapphiron, Minish, Michi, Melehan, Cozmikrae)
Vroendal - 5 (Ruguo, BraveSirRobin, Wintermoot, NyghtOwl, Doc)
BraveSirRobin - 1 (Imaginative Kane)
Doc - 1 (TGN)
Eastern New England - 1 (Self)

Current D3 votecount -

Updated vote count

Gerrick - 1 (Red Mones)
BSR - 3 (Gerrick, Nyght, Vroendal)
Sapphiron - 6 (Minish, Humandawn, Legacy of Smiles, TGN, Wintermoot, Imaginative Kane)
TGN - 6 (cozmikrae, Doc, ExLight, Wischland, Sapphiron, BSR)

Noteable things to me -
Kane is no longer going after BSR but is instead going after Sapph when BSR is a wagon, Wintermoot is on an opposing wagon from me again, BraveSirRobin is on an opposing wagon from me again, TGN has just been chaos, and ExLight we need more info on.

From these observations alone, I think scum are likely to be among the players I just mentioned. I may not be right, but it's interesting that there are certain players who have opposing votes as me both yesterday and today when I was on a wagon against a Titan, just saying.

Hmm. Not really a fan of who I'm in a wagon with. Plus Vro and other made some convincing arguments about how I may have misinterpreted the Ruguo/TGN mentoring thing, so I don't feel nearly as confident voting for TGN as before. But if I leave the TGN wagon then Sapph will very likely be lynched and I'm not super comfortable with that either. And time is running out. How did I get to be in this position. 

I suppose both TGN and Sapph would be good info lynches either way, so maybe leaving it up to chance is for the best. Feel free to drop advice for me though.

Hmm. Not really a fan of who I'm in a wagon with. Plus Vro and other made some convincing arguments about how I may have misinterpreted the Ruguo/TGN mentoring thing, so I don't feel nearly as confident voting for TGN as before. But if I leave the TGN wagon then Sapph will very likely be lynched and I'm not super comfortable with that either. And time is running out. How did I get to be in this position. 

I suppose both TGN and Sapph would be good info lynches either way, so maybe leaving it up to chance is for the best. Feel free to drop advice for me though.

Yeah, at this point I'm not really buying that Sapph is a Titan. Stay on TGN, if no active support appears, I'll lynch him to save Sapph and for info and accept that Doc will attack me tomorrow should I survive.

Hmm. Not really a fan of who I'm in a wagon with. Plus Vro and other made some convincing arguments about how I may have misinterpreted the Ruguo/TGN mentoring thing, so I don't feel nearly as confident voting for TGN as before. But if I leave the TGN wagon then Sapph will very likely be lynched and I'm not super comfortable with that either. And time is running out. How did I get to be in this position. 

I suppose both TGN and Sapph would be good info lynches either way, so maybe leaving it up to chance is for the best. Feel free to drop advice for me though.

Yeah, at this point I'm not really buying that Sapph is a Titan. Stay on TGN, if no active support appears, I'll lynch him to save Sapph and for info and accept that Doc will attack me tomorrow should I survive.

ok
but after that, then what
if I get lynched what will be your plan
will you be a hero if I am a wolf, or will you get sussed out if I'm not?
and if I am reading it right you will inspect my post as if there was a secret message in it?
if not I'm sorry
if so: .. / .... .. --. .... .-.. -.-- / -.. --- ..- -... - / - .... .- - .-.-.-

Can the option of lynching BSR still be on the table @ExLight? Just wondering.

why are you throwing the responsibility of your vote on me lol, you vote whoever you want
again, I’m townreading him so I’d prefer a TGN ot Sapph lynch

also I see what you’re doing there Sapph and I don’t know if I like it

oh fuck I messed formatting

it’s just me quoting Vro in the post above

ok
but after that, then what
if I get lynched what will be your plan
will you be a hero if I am a wolf, or will you get sussed out if I'm not?
and if I am reading it right you will inspect my post as if there was a secret message in it?
if not I'm sorry
if so: .. / .... .. --. .... .-.. -.-- / -.. --- ..- -... - / - .... .- - .-.-.-

Well, I don't think my plan will change a whole lot either way you flip. I will defend myself from accusations and make pushes against those players I have outlined and hope for the best, ez. I don't mind if I get sussed, but I suppose being sussed will depend on how you flip, sure.

As to ExLight, I'm not throwing responsibility I'm asking for your opinion of the situation and if you would possibly switch. It no longer seems to be viable anyway, but at the time I was wondering. Sapph is annoying  <3 and I think I see what he's doing too but also arghhhh.