View Topic

[Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?]

Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?

Yes

7 (87.5%)

No

1 (12.5%)

Total Members Voted: 8

Voting closed: February 24, 2021, 10:57:44 AM

Seems to confirm my belief that both Vro and Michi are town.

(Well, sorta)

Minish, would you perhaps be willing to make a new reads list? If we proceed in thinking that you're town, I'm curious to see where you would lead us next. I want to believe you, but it would help me if you led a charge against scum today, ya know?

It'll be a while til I get around to making a reads lisf because I have to look back at everything with the recent flips in mind. I stopped doing that kind of work during nights when I would get nk'd early all the time. Haha.


I will say that if you're town then it's likely there's at least 1-2 more scum on your wagon from yesterday. I feel like scum would try to push you to save Ruguo there, because it wasn't a certain thing til closer to eod. I still think Nyght is town so that leaves BSR, Winter, and Doc. I'd have to look at when exactly votes happened and everything.

OH. MY. GOD. I just realized you can add bookmarks yourself and it shows up with the thread bookmarks. This is amazing.

Ruguo was a Titan and here he tried to frame Michi and Ogun as scumbuds . From what I understand from the posts later on , Ogun is inexperienced and hence the joking post and subsequent framing by Ruguo seems impulsive . The fact that Kane supported this rather miniscule evidence makes my FoS pointed at him , as in the later point in the game we see him giving some independent analysis , but this one case of him going with Ruguo rings off to me

Ogun was removed from the game.

Not on D1 , when he was a suspect for lead-with-no-evidence sort of reasoning by Ruguo , which Kane supported , and this looks eerie when compared to his independent reasoning in later parts of the game

Fair enough I suppose. But that meta still tracks with what I saw as host of 23, so I think his posts are NAI of him/substitute.

Jesus christ I can never survive werewolf games, already 6 pages!

Lets be cautious shall we, I don't think it would be good to accidentally kill an innocent townie, like me of course 

I'd also like an explanation why we all want to kill Michi, before of course I jump on the bandwagon...?

Eager to jump on a bandwagon, are we? I dunno Ogun, this whole seems a little off to me... planting the idea you're town really early into D1, suggesting caution on a wagon of three (I think) when we've got so much room before hammer, then offering to jump on the wagon?

Ogun, are you trying to distance yourself from Michi? Are you two scumbuds?

This is also something I am wondering about after reading through posts on the topic.

For now I will use my No Lynch vote but that will change later on since I am sure some other players will eventually look more suspicious.
Melehan has been triggering some of my suspicion because from what I remember when reading and playing previous Werewolf games, the players who were committed to a role in all of their posts were usually evil or just hiding something.  Hapi in the last game proved an exception to the evil players posting in character but I think the Batman game had a few cases like that (and then there are the "generic Batman quotes").

Ruguo was a Titan and here he tried to frame Michi and Ogun as scumbuds . From what I understand from the posts later on , Ogun is inexperienced and hence the joking post and subsequent framing by Ruguo seems impulsive . The fact that Kane supported this rather miniscule evidence makes my FoS pointed at him , as in the later point in the game we see him giving some independent analysis , but this one case of him going with Ruguo rings off to me

Thinking about that post now.  I probably should have realized that at least some of that post was a joke by Ogun.  I did not realize that at the time and being suspicious of bandwagons goes hand in hand with my tendency to avoid them regardless of if I am town or scum.  I tend to just latch on to whatever pieces of "evidence" I see to justify being suspicious of a player.  Here is an example from a previous game.  The evidence Ruguo breaking down that evidence.  I will say though that with Ogun I do not actually have a grasp of their meta.  They have just been lurking in each game I have played with them from what I remember (or killed early).  That is not important now though seeing how he has been substituted.  I understand your suspicion but all I can really is that I am still grasping at straws, I just as you say am grasping my own straws.  In the previous day I was just making shots in the dark since I was not keeping up well and I would be surprised if I manage to keep up well with this day phase.  Now I know I was wrong to suspect Melehan and that Ruguo was scum so I definitely need to do some reevaluating.

I have some suspicion of Gerrick after reexamining some other games but they could just be playing like in that game I referred to where they were just town.  I don't remember seeing them being that chaotic before though.

But yeah I need to do some rereading (whether or not that ends up helping or confusing me more remains to be seen).

Goal: Hit 2,000 karma by the end of this game.

Hello guys, I’m from Bulbagarden and from here I only know of ExLight, Minish and Vroendal. It’s going to take a while for me to read the game and get my groove on. In the meantime can somebody give me a bit of notes of what went on? Day 2’s lynch was a scum lynch - what helped achieve that?

In the time before the Walls, yea, before the Titans roamed the Earth, a prophecy was spoken. Generations have risen and fallen in the centuries since, during which the fall of Humanity was all but assured, if not for the Walls.

And now, the Walls demand Sacrifice! For the sake of Humanity's survival, there must be blood offered!

Vote: Hapi

Spoiler

In all seriousness, I'm doing this for the lulz because it's not like we have any better reason to vote anyone off this early in D1.

I feel the spoiler was unnecessary - you didn’t need to explain it was a joke. When somebody overexplains something, it implies they have something to hide and want their tracks covered. Contextually, it almost beats the purpose of the vote by explaining it.

Melehan is dead lol

And was town.

In the time before the Walls, yea, before the Titans roamed the Earth, a prophecy was spoken. Generations have risen and fallen in the centuries since, during which the fall of Humanity was all but assured, if not for the Walls.

And now, the Walls demand Sacrifice! For the sake of Humanity's survival, there must be blood offered!

Vote: Hapi

Spoiler

In all seriousness, I'm doing this for the lulz because it's not like we have any better reason to vote anyone off this early in D1.

Quick question for you or anyone else here that has played a lot. Are you newer to mafia or do you have some experience? I do have reason for asking this. Haha.

I have some experience. And I have to say, some of the reactions have been Interesting.

I was originally asking because the part in your spoiler seemed a little overly cautious. Like sometimes I feel like scum feels the need to over explain something to try not to look scummy.

But this response seemed a little more townie, mentioning the reactions, so I'm back at square one.

What about the response seemed “a little more townie”? What does Melehan saying he has experience have anything to do with the overexplaining? You seem to be giving them a bone a bit too easily here for only answering they have experience - how does Melehan having experience corellate forgive overexplaining themselves?

I am getting the sense that we might need to lynch Michi based on meta.

That was a really good catch, Vro, and something I would have never picked up on. I don't think we're in any danger of a hammer at all with this many players, so let's go for a little more pressure.

Unvote
Vote: Michi

Care to explain yourself?

Yeah this is definitely buddying to get on Vroendal’s good side. Vote on Michi looks opportunistic too.

In the time before the Walls, yea, before the Titans roamed the Earth, a prophecy was spoken. Generations have risen and fallen in the centuries since, during which the fall of Humanity was all but assured, if not for the Walls.

And now, the Walls demand Sacrifice! For the sake of Humanity's survival, there must be blood offered!

Vote: Hapi

Spoiler

In all seriousness, I'm doing this for the lulz because it's not like we have any better reason to vote anyone off this early in D1.

Quick question for you or anyone else here that has played a lot. Are you newer to mafia or do you have some experience? I do have reason for asking this. Haha.

I have some experience. And I have to say, some of the reactions have been Interesting.

I was originally asking because the part in your spoiler seemed a little overly cautious. Like sometimes I feel like scum feels the need to over explain something to try not to look scummy.

But this response seemed a little more townie, mentioning the reactions, so I'm back at square one.

What about the response seemed “a little more townie”? What does Melehan saying he has experience have anything to do with the overexplaining? You seem to be giving them a bone a bit too easily here for only answering they have experience - how does Melehan having experience corellate forgive overexplaining themselves?

Those were two different things. The over explanation looked potentially scummy to me, but I didn't know how if Melehan was new to the game (because I can see new town players over explaining like that).

The fact that she mentioned the reactions was what felt more townie. I'm not personally a fan of reaction testing like that, but I could understand it coming from a town mindset.

It should be noted that Melehan just flipped vanilla town as well.