View Topic

[Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?]

Do you want to start lynching by majority this round?

Yes

7 (87.5%)

No

1 (12.5%)

Total Members Voted: 8

Voting closed: February 24, 2021, 10:57:44 AM

So is there anyone we still haven't heard from? I feel like Gerrick hasn't really said much and has just been lurking a lot. Which, from what I understand is a tactic to avoid attentions. To me that screams sus.

So is there anyone we still haven't heard from? I feel like Gerrick hasn't really said much and has just been lurking a lot. Which, from what I understand is a tactic to avoid attentions. To me that screams sus.

Gerrick and Sapph are two players that tend to lurk quite a bit. I would feel better about Gerrick if we lynched Michi and Michi flipped as a wolf. Sapph is too quiet for my liking.

@Gerrick anything to add to the discussion at this point in time? ^ ^
@Sapphiron I will not hesitate to get you voted up tomorrow for being quiet today, all <3

I need a new perspective, do you have any thoughts you're willing to share on RM, a link between cozmik and RM, Moot's vote, Minish's vote, or anything else at this time?

No.

...Fine

I think Red's defensiveness of Cozmik is NAI. I remember that when I first started taking you and Hapi to games I also was very protective of whomever I was playing with- you want your friends to succeed, simple as that. I won't deny that Red has done some very curious things on his own, but I wouldn't throw him onto the red zone for it. I'm not sure Red defending himself with his own meta is great, but it also seems like something he'd do regardless of alignment.

In regards to Moot, his post reeks of "I have no idea what's going on but really tried to make an informed effort", and I can also vouch that it has been busy within the region management. He does make a few good points, but it seems a lot like what I do- read up and only note on things that seem particularly odd, then expand a lot about a little for no good reason.

Minish is in fact, playing like Minish, and I think that her vote for Michi came from a place of one scumspect being lynched being better than no scumspects being lynched, even if it is one that is not your first choice. As Red became a more viable wagon, she swapped places- and I don't think anything is wrong with that. She had her reasons laid out in an earlier post, and has continued to lay out her point of view. It's not one I necessarily believe in, and I'll be staying where I am, but I can't fault her for it.

So is there anyone we still haven't heard from? I feel like Gerrick hasn't really said much and has just been lurking a lot. Which, from what I understand is a tactic to avoid attentions. To me that screams sus.

Shoot, you're right. Gerrick is incredibly quiet scum. We also need to hear from BSR. Neither of them lurking sits well with me.

In response to all the posts about Red's defense of me: For what it's worth, I'm pretty sure it's because I'm new here and he doesn't want to ruin my first game with you guys getting voted off day 1. I can't speak to whether he's coming from some other place of being in the know. But I can confirm even as a newb, having read through a couple games, he's flip floppy as hell with his votes. I've never played Mafia or WW with Red, ftr.

Gah. That's a fairly decent defense.

I'm not sure here. I'm kinda feeling Michi, kinda not feeling Michi ya feel?

Seems like he might be the easy lynch which I hate. But also Vro had a fair point about him.


I need to head to bed soon. Have half a mind to vote Ruguo. Because I at least know him and he's feeling a bit off to me. But I hate dropping a vote on a new wagon and peacing out.


Okay no I remembered a post and went back to check who said it. Michi tried to direct cop to check Mele so I think I just go there for that plus the meta thing. I don't feel great about it though but eh.

Unvote

Vote: Michi

Sorry, with work, the BID referendum, and trying to catch up on AoT, this game has been on the back-burner, especially with so much to catch up on (and honestly, with all the quotes, people are starting to blend together for me). I'll get to work on ISOing people now and making some sort of scum list.

Nah, Gerrick is playing exactly as he would as town. I don't think I've played in a game here that he wasn't also in, and I think this is classic town Gerrick. Pops in D1 for a ridiculous vote (Check out The beginning of the End, he votes Lau for not finishing the game of werewolf, later on votes for Aragonn because he "admitted" to being wolf). General lurkyness is normal, and yeah as a Burner I can confirm, the point about the referendum checks out. I mean, this an easy meta to keep consistent, but suspicion of him based on meta alone is ridiculous. In my opinion, Ruguo is far more analytical as town, here they're throwing suspicion on just about anyone they can (Ogun, Gerrick, BSR), but I may be reading too much into it. But yeah, nothing sus about Gerrick at all. (can't wait for the oH hE's DeFeNdInG gErRiCk NoW) Nah I'm just kidding

Sometimes I use commas weirdly

Sometimes I use commas weirdly

This is a mood.

Yeah and with no editing of posts it's like did i not learn grammar in elementary school? >_>

The one thing keeping Red off my scumspects list is the fact that Red and cozmik are apparently IRL friends, and that this is cozmik's first game here. Red being super defensive of cozmik thus makes sense because I'm sure Red wants cozmik's first game with us to be fun.

This tbh. While I don't think cozmik is likely to be the sort to bail after if they got lynched day 1 - I have faith in the Standard Of Friend Red brings around these parts - I don't know that there's too much harm in giving a day 1 'we don't know each other and we might have a wildly different playstyle from what we're used to' moment to give time to get used to it.
Perhaps best exemplified by how cozmik seemed surprised we wanted to know their strat; like, duh we want to know at least, like, 80% of your strategy, scum wins when townies plays their cards too close to their chests. It'd be one thing if there were neutral roles in this - in which case, yeah, alright, fair play - but there aren't.
Ah well. Not really a major issue though since there was never enough of a pile to be really worth worrying about getting lynched over anyway.

Who knows getting lynched D1 might make her love Werewolf here more but decide the game is better played by memeing and sowing general chaos and discontent for the lulz because you get murdered if you actually try to play the game around here :hapisip:

Anyways weather new or not weather a friend or not this is first and foremost a game and we should play it without taking any of that into consideration if someone decides not to continue playing cause the game was played and they died even D1 in their first game they shouldn't be playing. Like this is Werewolf and any suspicious activity will be noted.

What’s sus about me exactly? My Red Mones vote? That’s been retracted. How come you don’t jump on the other wagon, when that may actually help you? Why start a new one that no one else is getting on? 

Vote: Adorable Oracle Hapi

Yeah and with no editing of posts it's like did i not learn grammar in elementary school? >_>

I don't see what's weird about that use of commas.  Maybe I don't understand grammar as well as I sometimes think I do.

I think I now understand why I always seem so suspicious to yall when I play. (Even if I don't seem that suspicious yet for once)  My meta seems to be suspicious overall.  I am usually somewhat quiet whether I am town or scum.  Whether or not there are neutral roles, I am definitely a tightwad when it comes to giving information which is probably partially out of paranoia that I will immediately be targeted by enemies or breaking the rules if I open up.  Plus I tend to get rather defensive (maybe not as much as Aragonn though).

A notable part of my meta that is not too hard to confirm by reading through past games is that I tend to avoid wagons unless I agree with them (regardless of which side I am on) or I feel the need to join them for self preservation.  Also I tend to vote off of hunches when I make my votes unless the reasons for a vote seem sound and I agree with them enough to vote the same.  Seeing how big talking seems to be, I understand why I tend to be suspicious.  When asked, I will say I am innocent but can not confirm (who wouldn't in this kind of game).

For talk about the meta of others.  I have read a few of the previous games and Gerrick seems to be the meta I feel I have the best understanding of.  That meta seems to be always relatively quiet and contributing to discussions and then either someone realizing they are scum or someone taking them out at night (Though this is mostly from looking at Star Wars, Batman, and Game of Thrones).
I may have some idea of Red's meta but he has played quite a few games I have not been in so I am not sure.  The Game of Thrones meta I remember was being quiet except to vote and sometimes discussing with their votes being primarily joining wagons (mostly at the Wall when they were scum).  I think some good points were made earlier about Red on both sides so I won't vote them.  I am a little less suspicious of Minish now but still have a lingering gut suspicion (getting vibes from that Portal Werewolf when we were both scum).  Otherwise, there isn't really any new suspicions to note.  Though I had forgotten about Wintermoot being quiet earlier for some reason.

For now I will keep my vote in place.

The main player I am not at all suspicious of so far is NyghtOwl.  I like their original voting justification so for now I will go off of that in case I am not active before the day ends.  BSR seems a bit too quiet so far but they haven't been online for a while so that is somewhat excusable.  I really don't have any plausible suspicions so far.  Just weak suspicions of Robin, Melehan, and Minish.  I just have a gut feeling with Minish for some reason.  Neither Hapi nor Michi seem scummy to me.  Everyone else is generally on the same level as Hapi and Michi, neither suspicious nor not suspicious.

I will vote BraveSirRobin for now since they fit the bill and I wonder if they are doing what I often do: view the forums without logging in.

@Laurentus you seem to have missed my vote earlier when you were vote counting so here is a reminder.  Also the whole post as context for any wondering about it.

Yeah and with no editing of posts it's like did i not learn grammar in elementary school? >_>

I don't see what's weird about that use of commas.  Maybe I don't understand grammar as well as I sometimes think I do.

There were a couple of commas that should have been different pieces of punctuation, technically, but at least it was understandable.

I am tempted to switch to a joke Red vote because do you have a thing against properly punctuated lists, bro? Because it sure looks like it.