View Topic

DEAD

Aw. I was hoping Boromir would survive for my flavour. 

Damn, sorry Flying Eagles.

Good news is that we have a 50/50 chance to kill wolves now as two of the following four are wolves:
@Eastern New England
@Vroendal
@Wille-Harlia
@Wischland

How would you four rank the others from most to least suspicious?

Damn, sorry Flying Eagles.

Good news is that we have a 50/50 chance to kill wolves now as two of the following four are wolves:
@Eastern New England
@Vroendal
@Wille-Harlia
@Wischland

How would you four rank the others from most to least suspicious?

From most to least, Wille, myself, ENE, Wisch.

Personally I still find Wille's playstyle to be the most suspicious starting from when he didn't even comment on you, Gerrick voting him at all, and added with the statistical possibility I would be surprised to find that he's town.

ENE had a couple posts that were logical but I didn't feel added much to the whole scheme of things, I would put them as the last wolf.

If Wisch is a wolf she has played a fantastic posting game, well done, I've been reading her as town since basically the beginning.

I've made errors to be sure that compromises my likelihood to be town, but all-in-all I would read the way I've played as townie.

Wisch
Vro
ENE
Willie
 

Wille - Put both Doc and TGN in town core in his reads list here: https://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=6948.msg154662#msg154662 (maybe I'm only digging my grave deeper cause I'm also on there, but it needs to be brought up)
Less posting then I'd normally expect from him.

ENE - Very minimal posting. I think it's ENE because I don't think it's Vro basically.

Vro - Far too helpful to be scum.

Me - I know I'm town, obviously. @Hapi why are you suspicious of me? The same argument you made before or is there something else now?

Hmm did not tag that right. Well, I'm sure you'll see it Hapi.

Dawsinian (Theoden) was killed during the night.

This is the end of Night 6, and the beginning of Day 7. Phase ends in 48 hours on Saturday, the 26th, at 12 PM PST.

Mentions

@Dawsinian
@Eastern New England
@Gerrick
@Princess Hapi
@Vroendal
@Wille-Harlia
@Wintermoot
@Wischland

Alrightie, I see they went for the safe choice to kill wherein we don't get any new information.
I'm going to get the ball rolling with a vote on:
Vote: ENE
You've had more to say than Wille, but haven't defended yourself for a while and you're high up on my PoE list, so why shouldn't I be voting you? Who do you think it is?

Nobody is going to jump off those two so eff

Vote: Willie

Yeah, I think we've found our two wolves.
Vote: Eastern New England

Damn, sorry Flying Eagles.

Good news is that we have a 50/50 chance to kill wolves now as two of the following four are wolves:
@Eastern New England
@Vroendal
@Wille-Harlia
@Wischland

How would you four rank the others from most to least suspicious?

- W-H: W-H hasn't had much to say this far and working with the PoE, they seem likely wolf.
- Wisch: I've never played with a "wolf Wisch", but the one time I played Spyfall with her, she was Spy (equivalent to wolf) and the only person who wasn't sussed at all. The Spies ended up winning that game, so I wouldn't put it past Wisch to seem very towny and still be wolf.
- Vro: Vro seems helpful and I doubt that they are wolf.
- ENE: I know I'm town.

Alrightie, I see they went for the safe choice to kill wherein we don't get any new information.
I'm going to get the ball rolling with a vote on:
Vote: ENE
You've had more to say than Wille, but haven't defended yourself for a while and you're high up on my PoE list, so why shouldn't I be voting you? Who do you think it is?

You have no reason not to vote me, I can't deny that. I still think it's likely Wisch & W-H (refer to above for reasoning), but it's up to you to decide.

Vote: Eastern New England

One of the two people I think are our wolves.

Well, it seems like I am getting lynched.

Vote: Wille-Harlia

They are most likely wolf from PoE.

Vote: Wille-Harlia

Interesting that Vro, Gerrick, and Wischland feel strongly about voting for ENE, to the point that Vro started this and Gerrick and Wischland have outright said they think they're a wolf. I don't know what happened to give them such confidence...to me it feels like overconfidence. I think I feel more comfortable voting with Hapi on this one, given that I don't have to question her motivations.

Related, was Gerrick mechanically cleared for sure? I remember Laurentus thinking he was town but not being 100% sure.

Interesting that Vro, Gerrick, and Wischland feel strongly about voting for ENE, to the point that Vro started this and Gerrick and Wischland have outright said they think they're a wolf. I don't know what happened to give them such confidence...to me it feels like overconfidence. I think I feel more comfortable voting with Hapi on this one, given that I don't have to question her motivations.

Can't speak for Vro or Gerrick, but I think WH and ENE are the wolves, so I really have no preference as to who gets lynched first between the two. I just went with ENE cause at the time that's who most people had voted for.