View Topic

Yeah, TGN is probably scum if Doc flips red.

Vote: Doc

Well played, Doc. You had me fooled.

I don't know Doc's style as well as you, I'm inclined to just trust you on this one and hope he's not making a play by voting for Michi either knowing he was unaligned and somehow a threat to scum or just gunning for a town. Your reasoning regarding him seems based on a lot of experience.

I'm curious Doc, did you think Michi was unaligned and a threat to scum? Or were you just going after a suspicious person likely to get voted with superior logic to seem more genuine?

Vote: Doc

Easiest vote so far.

Interestingly enough, Doc has listed TGN as his town-core all three times that he posted a list. In his most recent version, he also listed Gerrick, Wischland, and Minnish. I don't know how much stock to put into that...at one time he had Sapphiron as his town-core too.

In the last three days, he voted for Hapi, Michi, and HumanSanity, so I'm not sure that helps much either.

Doc is just a bastard (much love, Doc, that's the biggest compliment I can give for someone in this game), and I'm not going to overanalyse his reads. He more than likely has scum buds listed in various segments of his reads lists, and going against consensus Town would honestly just be a scum tell

Hmm Intresting all things considered 

Vote:Doc

It better not be you doc or I'm dead

Vote: Doc

Well that’s quite the defense for someone whose life hangs in the balance based on the outcome of this vote.

Vote: TGN

Tsk tsk, I thought you were going to lynch me so today. Well my contribution happens to be a scum lock, my town lock remains the 2 I mentioned before

You have no power here, servant of Morgoth!

Vote: Doc

This is an out-and-out stone-cold lie.
In a bid to avert the tragedy that would result, I shall couch a 'reveal' in as poetic language as I can.

I am a son of Gondor, a scion and servant of the White Tower of Ecthelion, and the only reason I've been largely silent is because there were pressing matters which demanded my attention in Ithilien - which is why my brother was sent to Elrond in the first place, Laurentus.
Mark this; the sons of Numenor have many dreams and true visions, and seek to judge right and justly; hence my temperance and good faith thus far.
But I ask that if my brother were to die before I, if you would prefer our places had been exchanged.

That should be clear enough, I think.
Vote: Sapphiron

Tsk tsk, I thought you were going to lynch me so today. Well my contribution happens to be a scum lock, my town lock remains the 2 I mentioned before

You have no power here, servant of Morgoth!

Vote: Doc

This is an out-and-out stone-cold lie.
In a bid to avert the tragedy that would result, I shall couch a 'reveal' in as poetic language as I can.

I am a son of Gondor, a scion and servant of the White Tower of Ecthelion, and the only reason I've been largely silent is because there were pressing matters which demanded my attention in Ithilien - which is why my brother was sent to Elrond in the first place, Laurentus.
Mark this; the sons of Numenor have many dreams and true visions, and seek to judge right and justly; hence my temperance and good faith thus far.
But I ask that if my brother were to die before I, if you would prefer our places had been exchanged.

That should be clear enough, I think.
Vote: Sapphiron

Your defense is basically a "no you!" argument. This is an interesting claim, but why do you think Sapph is lying rather than thinking that perhaps his results were messed with from prediction by scum? It would not be in Sapph's best interest as scum to want to leave even before scanning you, doesn't feel like a scum thing to do. If you flip town, we'll reconsider. What will you say to any possible counter-claim?

Well that’s quite the defense for someone whose life hangs in the balance based on the outcome of this vote.

Vote: TGN

that's not defensive, that's a comment. this post, now THIS is defensive but I see that anything else I say won't change your mind.

Unvote

Actually no wait, Doc wth is that claim? Faramir is already dead. :p Newvit was modkilled.

Vote: Doc

Actually no wait, Doc wth is that claim? Faramir is already dead. :p Newvit was modkilled.

Vote: Doc

...oh, fuck
yeah, i fucked up then

EDIT: Yeah, I could try and unfuck things, but at this point that's just too embarrassing and I'd rather hide my head in shame out of what I thought was a brilliant if risky play backfiring so horrifyingly badly.

Actually no wait, Doc wth is that claim? Faramir is already dead. :p Newvit was modkilled.

Vote: Doc

...oh, fuck
yeah, i fucked up then

Awwww you hate to see it happen. You did really well Doc until that claim. The one you wanted to claim would have been Boromir not Faramir.

Actually no wait, Doc wth is that claim? Faramir is already dead. :p Newvit was modkilled.

Vote: Doc

...oh, fuck
yeah, i fucked up then

EDIT: Yeah, I could try and unfuck things, but at this point that's just too embarrassing and I'd rather hide my head in shame out of what I thought was a brilliant if risky play backfiring so horrifyingly badly.

oh... Vote: Doc

Doc, just lolcat already.

Anyway, Doc is fucked. Let's spend the rest of the phase interrogating other suspects.

Also question to @Red Mones, do we have death-by-majority?