View Topic

Although the HumanSanity lynch really makes me question a few things, @Sapphiron.

Hmm. What are the chances that one of the scum has the ability to change which role a dead player is revealed as?

Hmm. What are the chances that one of the scum has the ability to change which role a dead player is revealed as?

I've never encountered this. Why?

Hmm. What are the chances that one of the scum has the ability to change which role a dead player is revealed as?

I would not discount it as a possibility for the future, but in this case as Eowyn is definitely good, ogun gave Lau two hints earlier, one about the soup and one just before the EoD (I was unable to figure out what he meant by father and son until his role was revealed), and no one is sussing him for that claim I would say that we should consider him as townie.

Right right. I'm just wondering because what I've seen mechanically doesn't match up with Ogun's role and the hints. It's just a weird disparity.

I'm not sure how much I can reveal without breaking the rules.

But just to double check, Lau, you got the soup last night phase? N2?

Players leaving the game is beyond game mechanics.

But just to double check, Lau, you got the soup last night phase? N2?

He visited me last night phase, but I only got notified when D3 started.

Sorry, guys. I missed the hints here. I'll promise to do better.

Also Lau, how wise do you think it is for at this point once Day Phase comes we figure out whoever rezzed Daws? I think that might clear up a few things for the future. Target or no target I think we can do a pretty good job at narrowing down who the scum might be with that information.

He visited me last night phase, but I only got notified when D3 started.

Sorry to keep chasing after you about this, I'm just trying to square things in my mind right now. Did you just learn that you got the soup, or did you specifically get told that Eowyn visited you? And if the later, it was just that Eowyn visited, without any player name attached?

I just got given the soup hint.

Also Lau, how wise do you think it is for at this point once Day Phase comes we figure out whoever rezzed Daws? I think that might clear up a few things for the future. Target or no target I think we can do a pretty good job at narrowing down who the scum might be with that information.

The answer is right there for those looking.

I just got given the soup hint.

Hmm ok. Well, I don't know how much more I can say, but there's something funky here about Ogun being Eowyn and them apparently visiting you to give you soup that just doesn't match up for me. But I'm not sure where to go from there and need to gather some more info, so I'll leave it alone for now.

I also have reason to believe I was visited by Eowyn, but this similarly had no effect. I don't think I'm breaking any rules by sharing this, as this is as a result of someone else's actions performed on me, so I'll just share the gist of what I was told, and omit the potentially rule-violating info:

My action was not successful, and I received soup from another player, although this had no effect.

This seems to reinforce the idea that I was jailed, and I think soup could be a reference to Eowyn's scene in The Two Towers where she offers Aragorn some soup and he finds the stuff awful. At any rate, this is as much as I'm getting from Google. Will again ping @Doc to see if more can be gleamed here.

Said this literally at the beginning of D3, so what are you finding funky, @Wischland?

In case I don't make it: I've been operating under the assumption that Sapphiron was the Seer. Clearly that was not the case. So I'd be very interested to hear how he's been mechanically clearing people.