View Topic

Crazy stuff happening in Wintreath (ns not forum)

Vote Pengu

What is the reason for this vote?

everyone else was doing it

Ngl, that's a little suspicious to break a tie vote with the reason "everyone else was doing it."  If everyone else was, it wouldn't be a 1-1 tie

I saw around 6 votes for him so sue me if I'm wrong, maybe I was on a different tread

Crazy stuff happening in Wintreath (ns not forum)

Vote Pengu

What is the reason for this vote?

everyone else was doing it

Ngl, that's a little suspicious to break a tie vote with the reason "everyone else was doing it."  If everyone else was, it wouldn't be a 1-1 tie

I saw around 6 votes for him so sue me if I'm wrong, maybe I was on a different tread

TGN sus

you would be saying the same thing if I voted for the other person everyone was voting, I SWEAR people were voting him

you would be saying the same thing if I voted for the other person everyone was voting, I SWEAR people were voting him

wait I looked back, I thought there were more votes for Pengu my bad

I don't know what to make of your reaction. On the one hand, I doubt a wolf, even a first-time one, would pay so little attention to what was going on, but on the other, this just feels a bit too defensive.

But okay, even if this was your point of view at the time, why push Pengu to such a massive majority at the time?

But okay, even if this was your point of view at the time, why push Pengu to such a massive majority at the time?

idk

Current vote count:

Michi - 3 (Laurentus, Sapphiron, TGN)
Laurentus - 2 (Michi, Dawsinian)
Flying Eagles - 1 (Gerrick)

@Wintermoot, could you easily program in a feature that lets people see how many posts each person participating in the game has made?

Lau, I realize you're reaction testing and probing (that or trying to come up with a reason, however shaky, to 'reasonably' move beyond RVS, as I'd expect from wolf-you, but I've no reason to jump to that conclusion yet), but let's also recognize that TGN is 1) new to the game, 2) new to the community, and 3) rather younger than most of the rest of us, all of which are going to contribute heavily towards getting very defensive very quickly.
This doesn't say 'sus' to me, this says 'this is my first time doing this and I'm very worried about getting lynched over some missed cue'. To my mind, that reads Town, not scum.

Anyway, I'm going to be busy this evening so on the off-chance I don't check back in before day-phase ends (incidentally, a reminder to everyone that there's 24 hours left!), I'm going to Vote: Hapi because Hapi's meta is almost inevitably a grave danger to town, whether scum or not, on the basis of her deliberate randomness.
I'm thinking of it as a sacrifice for the greater good, which is unfortunately a joke basically nobody will get cause very few of the Among Us crew seems to be here.
(The vote is still serious, but the reasoning is half-a-joke)

I haven't come up with any town reads yet. I'd classify TGN as being ever-so-slightly a town lean just by virtue of being willing to admit that they just don't know what happened, and the game's long history of misreading inexperience as suspicion.

My gut isn't picking up anything with Doc that screams Wolf, which I suppose should be about as strong a signal as I'm going to get this early of his potential innocence, especially as nothing he's done has felt like it has an ulterior motive to it yet. It is Doc, though, so I'll reserve judgment.

I have not seen Vro pushing an agenda, which is something he tried to do quite aggressively in the last game we played together, but I also recognise him as a player with incredible potential, and would not expect him to try a style that clearly didn't work out for him last time, so that is again NAI.

Then there's frankly mostly crap-posting from a few people like Daws, Sapphiron being very tight-lipped (well within meta for either alignment), Gerrick observing everything but not engaging (again, well within meta) and @Pengu just kinda rubbing my gut wrong.

As to why that is, Pengu, I'm surprised that you characterised TGN's action for voting for you as suspicious. Until his reaction to your post, I was leaning heavily towards them just being new and having a desire to do as the Romans do, so to speak.

@Michi, apologies.

Okay, Moot is flying under my radar and this scares me.

I quite agree with Doc about TGN.

Of all the people you mentioned Lau including yourself, the person I feel most comfortable voting right now is actually Gerrick. While I concede that he may be in the meta for either alignment, his vote was very weird considering it had no follow-up. I just really don't understand it and I dislike not understanding something.

Also speaking of the last game we played together in regards to Gerrick, you voted him yourself D1 "because he has a lurky playstyle". I get that Pengu's is rubbing you wrong, but I feel that Gerrick has been even more weird than Pengu, and I feel has talked less than any other game I've played with him which is screaming danger to me. Is there a reason you're not pushing him as hard now?

If only to ask "what's up?", Vote: Gerrick

Sorry for being a bit late to join the game here. As Wischland said, you guys are a lot more vote-happy than we are in XKI. Usually, rather than a Random Voting Phase, we vote No Lynch for the first day, until we have some information for the fear of lynching a town. Seeing that, I am just going to wait and watch until some information presents itself.