View Topic

I'd also like to see more activitree. @Doc, got any analysis to share?

I'm gonna Vote: Kane. Not much reasoning, but hey I've got a 33% chance of being right. But this

and it sounds like the tree burners would be the evil ones, don't know about those cutters

could be a slip, although it's almost too obvious to be anything.

I'm gonna Vote: Kane. Not much reasoning, but hey I've got a 33% chance of being right. But this

and it sounds like the tree burners would be the evil ones, don't know about those cutters

could be a slip, although it's almost too obvious to be anything.

I can tell you that is most certainly not a slip.  At that point I had not quite realized that the lumberjacks were the werewolves yet.  Eventually I did figure it out though.  I had thought Doc's post about lumberjacks was just something random but obviously it was not.

I am not too suspicious of anyone yet but in the interest of seeing some reaction or defense I will vote ogunbiyi and if they respond I will hopefully change my vote in time.

I don't really have the mental energy for an impassioned defense or some deep analysis right now, particularly since there doesn't seem to be anything of any real value to look at; our only death so far has been a night kill of a player who was pretty clearly signalling town (through the combination of what I at least perceived as inexperience and his firm reticence vis-a-vis mislynching), so all I've got is that at least one of the lumberjacks is probably an experienced player. (Then again, with the benefit of hindsight, it's always super obvious that a town player was town, so maybe that doesn't even mean anything)

At this point I'm just filing Hapi away as a wildcard permanently, since the goal seems to be permanent chaos so that nobody can ever get a decent read.
For the moment, the only person I've got a vague scumread on is Mones; that's quite the judo from

So my suspicion lies with doc and mones mostly

to

I'd also like to see more activitree.

taking a combined suspicion and redirecting it by adding your own such that most of it just appears to fall on me, without actually trying to start a wagon (and thus maintaining plausible deniability).
Maybe I'm just hostile and suspicious at this time of the 'morning' and I'll regret it in the cold light of day, but for now, Vote: Red Mones.

I'm gonna Vote: Kane. Not much reasoning, but hey I've got a 33% chance of being right. But this

and it sounds like the tree burners would be the evil ones, don't know about those cutters

could be a slip, although it's almost too obvious to be anything.

I can tell you that is most certainly not a slip.  At that point I had not quite realized that the lumberjacks were the werewolves yet.  Eventually I did figure it out though.  I had thought Doc's post about lumberjacks was just something random but obviously it was not.

I am not too suspicious of anyone yet but in the interest of seeing some reaction or defense I will vote ogunbiyi and if they respond I will hopefully change my vote in time.

Well I don't know what defense that will convince you but from what I have analyzed I agree with Doc that the lumberjack is an experienced player and I'm just not very experienced and assure you I am not the lumberjack
From analysis I saw that Doc's quotes showed that he was not the lumberjack and encourage you all to not vote for him or me.
Daw has been pretty quiet, I'd like to hear something from him @Dawcreek
Before I take a vote.

There's honestly not a whole lot of evidence to go off at this point, since so far it's basically been us joking around for the first couple of pages and voting others just to get some kind of reaction out of them.

I am however rather suspicious of Ogun who has stated twice now that they are not a lumberjack, despite not having any evidence to back up their claims and accusing everyone else of being a lumberjack the first time except Doc and himself. Although, Hapi did bring up a good point about a lumberjack knowing better than to out their own team, I am still not entirely convinced and therefore I Vote: ogunbiyi6422.

Yes Doc Hapi plays for chaos but I've largely got to agree with Daws analysis here I think that what ogun is doing seems pretty scummy they've basically accused everyone at this point

Unvote

Vote: Ogun

I have provided evidence for you, basically saying that its an experienced player that is making you turn on me and thus, I am not the lumberjack. Accusing everyone of being the lumberjack is not basis for being a lumberjack. You're just gonna let the lumberjack win, and cut us all down!

But honestly, I apologize if my behavior came off as scummy, as Daw said, we were all joking around the first few pages and thus my callous behavior is not evidence for me being the lumberjack.

And for the record, I didn't accuse anyone of being the lumberjack. I said "it could be anyone else," which is an obvious thing that I just typed. Of course it could be any one of us.

If I was the lumberjack, I would limit the amount I am speaking in order to prevent something like this from happening, and the fact that most of this conversation is me joking around and typing random things shows that the lumberjack would not risk that and blow their cover.

Yeah, I'm gonna say I don't think it's Ogun based purely on the fact that he keeps saying "the lumberjack" -- as in singular. There are in fact two lumberjacks, which seems like something he'd know if he were one. Unless it's just a ploy, but seems like too particular of a thing for someone to do.

I, however, am gonna Switch Vote: Hapi since it seems she's grasping at straws to really make sure someone dies today. Daw's vote? Sure, not much to go off. But for Hapi to switch votes for that? I don't know...

But if I'm wrong and Ogun does turn out to be a wolf, please feel free to lynch me the next day as I'd deserve to die.

The day has ended. With three votes, Ogunbiyi6422, A Weeping Willow, the Seer. His seed was destroyed night one by a controlled burn, thus he will not respawn.

Remember to send in your night actions.

The Moon is Up!

Night 2 will end 10:30pm EST on the 29th.

Yeah, I'm gonna say I don't think it's Ogun based purely on the fact that he keeps saying "the lumberjack" -- as in singular. There are in fact two lumberjacks, which seems like something he'd know if he were one. Unless it's just a ploy, but seems like too particular of a thing for someone to do.

I, however, am gonna Switch Vote: Hapi since it seems she's grasping at straws to really make sure someone dies today. Daw's vote? Sure, not much to go off. But for Hapi to switch votes for that? I don't know...

But if I'm wrong and Ogun does turn out to be a wolf, please feel free to lynch me the next day as I'd deserve to die.

I switched votes because I was never really sold on Doc. His response and Oguns answers combined to change my suspicion. And it is true I did want a lynch to happen if we keep having no lynches every day we will never find the lumberjacks.


Anyways who has permission to talk at night maybe we can figure some stuff out?

The night has ended.

The Sun Rises!

No one was chopped down during the night.

Day 3 will end on September 1st at 11am EST.

Hmm very intresting.

Oh, c'mon Doc, I ask you for analysis like every game. I respect you as a player.

Oh, c'mon Doc, I ask you for analysis like every game. I respect you as a player.

Assuming the possibility that you're scum and mindgaming everybody is also a mark of respect for you as a player. It assumes a high level of competence that you've thus far lived up to.