View Topic

I mean, I explained it here:

But we do know that there is a Ranger, and in my mind it's less likely that Crushita showed up, was assigned the Ranger, and correctly killed an Other all on the same night -- so I'm thinking the Ranger is either Doc or Elbbsas. And I'm pretty certain that there's an Other among the people who arrived before PowerPAOK died, which leads me to believe either Elbbsas, Crushita, or Doc is an Other.

Is it not possible that one is the Ranger while the other is an Other? Then again, Crushita may be an Other while these two are a Ranger and a Brother.

Regardless, I'll agree to change my Vote: No Lynch until I get more clues and can be more certain.

You have roughly 24 hours left to vote!

The following people have not yet posted this day phase:
@Red Mones
@Kane lives

I'm not fond of no lynch votes. Even if we lynch innocents, it narrows down the pool of suspects. But it might not be a bad idea to see what happens during the night. Therefore, I too shall vote: no lynch.

The reasoning to vote no lynch is solid, I guess. So I Vote: No Lynch

I will vote no lynch.

I will also vote no lynch

Nobody is lynched today.

The night phase begins now, and ends tomorrow, Monday, February 12, at around 7:00 PM PST.
"We don't have any wildfire or swords for you to waste here," said Ser Allister Thorne to Thoros of Myr.

@Wintermoot has arrived at the Wall! Please welcome him!

Petyr Baelish sneaked out of his quarters. He was putting his subterfuge skills to good use for once, to try to find the identity of those killers.

He'd bumped into Mance Rayder of all the people on the way north (so those rumors of the King-Beyond-the-Wall coming south occasionally were true), and when he'd offered Petyr an opportunity to support another side, he naturally accepted. Hedging one's bets when the future is uncertain is almost always the best option, after all.

As he approached his target, however, he felt something icy plunge into his back, and then the world went dark.
Littlefinger, the wildling lover, a.k.a. Gerrick, has been killed by the Others at night.

The day phase begins now, and ends in about two days, on Wednesday, February 14, at around 7:00 PM PST.

Furthermore, @North has arrived at Castle Black. Please welcome him to the Wall!

Accuse: Crushita. Suppose I'm gonna eliminate the three Gerrick was suspecting the most, for now.

Furthermore, @North has arrived at Castle Black. Please welcome him to the Wall!

Greetings to the true heir of the Iron Throne, Stannis 'the Mannis' Baratheon.
Which, if Robert were somehow to die, impossible as that would be while he's off hunting (/s), would make the amusing pun 'the King is the North' possible.
On to serious business.

Littlefinger, the wildling lover, a.k.a. Gerrick, has been killed by the Others at night.

So ends House Baelish. Double-dealing to the end. I'd seen he played both sides in the Red Keep, but having truck with wildlings? It almost makes me pleased they got him. Emphasis almost, because now we definitely need to catch the hopefully 1 but possibly 2 Others still in the game, or else we risk two killings at night instead of one.
The problem is that we have nobody who Gerrick really clearly drew battle lines up against (Elb, vaguely and me even more so, but considering he bent towards a No Lynch fairly quickly that didn't last long).
I'm beginning to see the value of banning No Lynch votes in most ordinary games of Werewolf now. This is giving us incredibly little ammunition to work with, which is making everyone worried about making a wrong choice, making us No Lynch more, giving us less ammunition to work with, all while the Others pick us off.

Oh Laurentus posted before I finished this, so I guess I'll just go with that vote instead of saying 'I'm going to go with what Laurentus goes with when he picks'. Accuse: Crushita.

DEAD

Damn. If only I had more time.

Furthermore, @North has arrived at Castle Black. Please welcome him to the Wall!

Greetings to the true heir of the Iron Throne, Stannis 'the Mannis' Baratheon.
Which, if Robert were somehow to die, impossible as that would be while he's off hunting (/s), would make the amusing pun 'the King is the North' possible.
On to serious business.

Littlefinger, the wildling lover, a.k.a. Gerrick, has been killed by the Others at night.

So ends House Baelish. Double-dealing to the end. I'd seen he played both sides in the Red Keep, but having truck with wildlings? It almost makes me pleased they got him. Emphasis almost, because now we definitely need to catch the hopefully 1 but possibly 2 Others still in the game, or else we risk two killings at night instead of one.
The problem is that we have nobody who Gerrick really clearly drew battle lines up against (Elb, vaguely and me even more so, but considering he bent towards a No Lynch fairly quickly that didn't last long).
I'm beginning to see the value of banning No Lynch votes in most ordinary games of Werewolf now. This is giving us incredibly little ammunition to work with, which is making everyone worried about making a wrong choice, making us No Lynch more, giving us less ammunition to work with, all while the Others pick us off.

Oh Laurentus posted before I finished this, so I guess I'll just go with that vote instead of saying 'I'm going to go with what Laurentus goes with when he picks'. Accuse: Crushita.

Alas, since I know nothing about Game Of Thrones that joke was lost on me.

I think I will accuse Elbbsas just so that I am not jumping on the bandwagon.

I'm beginning to suspect Doc more and more, actually. He is always a bit wordy, but he usually has an actual point to make. He also usually states a clear goal with his vote. I suppose he could be following my reasoning for Crush, though. It just seems rather less analytical than I would expect from him.

Oh, and could you give a bit of motivation for your Elbbsas vote, Kane Lives?

... Unless your point here was that the no lynch votes were giving you nothing to work with, Doc?