View Topic

I'm just noting it as a possibility. You never know what level others are playing at.

Of course, and it is possible, and you should keep it in mind. 

Day 1 Voting

Aragonn: Commander_Zemas (1)
Tainted Paws: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Rasdanation: VidiLune (1)
Evelynx: Rasdanation (1)
Barnes: Crushita Telcontar (2)
taulover: Grand Land of BLarg (1)
North: RedRevenant/Sci (1)
BraveSirRobin: RedRevenant/Sci (2)
Crushita Telcontar: RedRevenant/Sci (3)
Wintermoot: Crushita Telcontar (3)
RedRevenant/Sci: Abstain
Tomb: Crushita Telcontar (4)
VidiLune: Crushita Telcontar (5)
Laurentus: Crushita Telcontar (6)
Sapphiron: Tomb (1)
Lumenland: Tomb (2)
Crushita Telcontar: Tomb (3) from RedRevenant/Sci (2)
Gerrick: VidiLune (2)
Colberius X: VidiLune (3)
Aragonn: VidLune (4) from Commander_Zemas (0)
Hannah B: Tomb (4)
Crushita Telcontar: VidiLune (5)
North: VidiLune (6) from RedRevenant/Sci (1)
Commander_Zemas: VidiLune (7) from Tomb (3)
Broddring Empire: VidiLune (8.)
BraveSirRobin: VidiLune (9) from RedRevenant/Sci (0)
xXTheHydraXx: Bootsie (1)
Evelynx: Tomb (4) from Rasdanation (0)
Frozen: DNV
Bootsie: DNV
Grand Land of BLarg: DNV

Day 2 Voting

Laurentus: Tomb (1)
RedRevenant/Sci: Tomb (2)
Evelynx: Tomb (3)
Wintermoot: Tomb (4)
Commander_Zemas: Abstain
Tomb: Rasdanation
Lumenland: Tomb (5)
Rasdanation: Abstain
Evelynx: Abstain from Tomb (4)
Bootsie: Tomb (5)
North: Tomb (6)
BraveSirRobin: Wintermoot (1)
Frozen: taulover (1)
Crushita Telcontar: Tomb (7)
Aragonn: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Rasdanation: Wintermoot (2) from Abstain
Gerrick: Abstain
xXTheHydraXx: Abstain
Taulover: Tomb (8.)
Taintedpaws: Abstain
Colberius X: BraveSirRobin (1)
Evelynx: BraveSirRobin (2) from Abstain
Sapphiron: Tomb (9)
HannahB: DNV
Barnes: DNV
Broddring Empire: DNV
Grand Land of BLarg: DNV

Day 3 Voting

Aragonn: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Lumenland: Abstain
North: Abstain
BraveSirRobin: Wintermoot (1)
Colberius X: BraveSirRobin (1)
Barnes: Laurentus (1)
Gerrick: HannahB (1)
Laurentus: Barnes (1)
BraveSirRobin: Abstain from Wintermoot (0)
xXTheHydraXx: Bootsie (1)
Rasdanation: Wintermoot (1)
North: Bootsie (2) from Abstain
Bootsie: Abstain
Taulover: Barnes (2)
Wintermoot: Laurentus (2)
Evelynx: BraveSirRobin (2)
HannahB: BraveSirRobin (3)
Crushita Telcontar: Abstain
Commander_Zemas: Frozen (1)
Frozen: DNV
Sapphiron: DNV
Taintedpaws: DNV

Day 4 Voting

North: Abstain
Evelynx: North (1)
Aragonn: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Bootsie: North (2)
Wintermoot: Laurentus (1)
Laurentus: Wintermoot (1)
Gerrick: Crushita Telcontar (2)
Sapphiron: Commader_Zemas (1)
Evelynx: Crushita Telcontar (3) from North (1)
Laurentus: Crushita Telcontar (4) from Wintermoot (0)
Rasdanation: Lumenland (1)
Colberius X: Frozen (1)
Taulover: Bootsie (1)
North: Evelynx (1) from Abstain
Lumenland: North (2)
Crushita Telcontar: North (3)
HannahB: Evelynx (2)
Wintermoot: Crushita Telcontar (5) from Laurentus (0)
Barnes: Evelynx (3)
xXTheHydraXx: Frozen (2)
Commander_Zemas: Frozen (3)
Crushita Telcontar: Evelynx (4) from North (2)
Evelynx: North (3) from Crushita Telcontar (4)
HannahB: North (4) from Evelynx (3)
Frozen: DNV

Day 5 Voting

Laurentus: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Evelynx: Crushita Telcontar (2)
Taulover: Crushita Telcontar (3)
Aragonn: Crushita Telcontar (4)
Sapphiron: Crushita Telcontar (5)
Wintermoot: Crushita Telcontar (6)
Barnes: Evelynx (1)
Gerrick: Crushita Telcontar (7)
Lumenland: Crushita Telcontar (8.)
Bootsie: Crushita Telcontar (9)
Rasdanation: Abstain
Commander_Zemas: Abstain
xXTheHydraXx: Abstain
Colberius X: Crushita Telcontar (10)
HannahB: DNV
Crushita Telcontar: DNV

HannahB and Evelynx have voted the same every round except for when HannahB didn't vote. So, yeah, they're definitely tied to each other. I have stated before that I thought HannahB was suspicious, and the only way to find out what they are is to vote, so I vote HannahB.

I want to know what @Sapphiron has to say.

He's too experienced at this game for me to let him be this quiet.

I've been looking through, and as of I see, I think HannahB is my best bet.

Vote: HannahB

Day 1 Voting

Aragonn: Commander_Zemas (1)
Tainted Paws: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Rasdanation: VidiLune (1)
Evelynx: Rasdanation (1)
Barnes: Crushita Telcontar (2)
taulover: Grand Land of BLarg (1)
North: RedRevenant/Sci (1)
BraveSirRobin: RedRevenant/Sci (2)
Crushita Telcontar: RedRevenant/Sci (3)
Wintermoot: Crushita Telcontar (3)
RedRevenant/Sci: Abstain
Tomb: Crushita Telcontar (4)
VidiLune: Crushita Telcontar (5)
Laurentus: Crushita Telcontar (6)
Sapphiron: Tomb (1)
Lumenland: Tomb (2)
Crushita Telcontar: Tomb (3) from RedRevenant/Sci (2)
Gerrick: VidiLune (2)
Colberius X: VidiLune (3)
Aragonn: VidLune (4) from Commander_Zemas (0)
Hannah B: Tomb (4)
Crushita Telcontar: VidiLune (5)
North: VidiLune (6) from RedRevenant/Sci (1)
Commander_Zemas: VidiLune (7) from Tomb (3)
Broddring Empire: VidiLune (8.)
BraveSirRobin: VidiLune (9) from RedRevenant/Sci (0)
xXTheHydraXx: Bootsie (1)
Evelynx: Tomb (4) from Rasdanation (0)
Frozen: DNV
Bootsie: DNV
Grand Land of BLarg: DNV

Day 2 Voting

Laurentus: Tomb (1)
RedRevenant/Sci: Tomb (2)
Evelynx: Tomb (3)
Wintermoot: Tomb (4)
Commander_Zemas: Abstain
Tomb: Rasdanation
Lumenland: Tomb (5)
Rasdanation: Abstain
Evelynx: Abstain from Tomb (4)
Bootsie: Tomb (5)
North: Tomb (6)
BraveSirRobin: Wintermoot (1)
Frozen: taulover (1)
Crushita Telcontar: Tomb (7)
Aragonn: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Rasdanation: Wintermoot (2) from Abstain
Gerrick: Abstain
xXTheHydraXx: Abstain
Taulover: Tomb (8.)
Taintedpaws: Abstain
Colberius X: BraveSirRobin (1)
Evelynx: BraveSirRobin (2) from Abstain
Sapphiron: Tomb (9)
HannahB: DNV
Barnes: DNV
Broddring Empire: DNV
Grand Land of BLarg: DNV

Day 3 Voting

Aragonn: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Lumenland: Abstain
North: Abstain
BraveSirRobin: Wintermoot (1)
Colberius X: BraveSirRobin (1)
Barnes: Laurentus (1)
Gerrick: HannahB (1)
Laurentus: Barnes (1)
BraveSirRobin: Abstain from Wintermoot (0)
xXTheHydraXx: Bootsie (1)
Rasdanation: Wintermoot (1)
North: Bootsie (2) from Abstain
Bootsie: Abstain
Taulover: Barnes (2)
Wintermoot: Laurentus (2)
Evelynx: BraveSirRobin (2)
HannahB: BraveSirRobin (3)
Crushita Telcontar: Abstain
Commander_Zemas: Frozen (1)
Frozen: DNV
Sapphiron: DNV
Taintedpaws: DNV

Day 4 Voting

North: Abstain
Evelynx: North (1)
Aragonn: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Bootsie: North (2)
Wintermoot: Laurentus (1)
Laurentus: Wintermoot (1)
Gerrick: Crushita Telcontar (2)
Sapphiron: Commader_Zemas (1)
Evelynx: Crushita Telcontar (3) from North (1)
Laurentus: Crushita Telcontar (4) from Wintermoot (0)
Rasdanation: Lumenland (1)
Colberius X: Frozen (1)
Taulover: Bootsie (1)
North: Evelynx (1) from Abstain
Lumenland: North (2)
Crushita Telcontar: North (3)
HannahB: Evelynx (2)
Wintermoot: Crushita Telcontar (5) from Laurentus (0)
Barnes: Evelynx (3)
xXTheHydraXx: Frozen (2)
Commander_Zemas: Frozen (3)
Crushita Telcontar: Evelynx (4) from North (2)
Evelynx: North (3) from Crushita Telcontar (4)
HannahB: North (4) from Evelynx (3)
Frozen: DNV

Day 5 Voting

Laurentus: Crushita Telcontar (1)
Evelynx: Crushita Telcontar (2)
Taulover: Crushita Telcontar (3)
Aragonn: Crushita Telcontar (4)
Sapphiron: Crushita Telcontar (5)
Wintermoot: Crushita Telcontar (6)
Barnes: Evelynx (1)
Gerrick: Crushita Telcontar (7)
Lumenland: Crushita Telcontar (8.)
Bootsie: Crushita Telcontar (9)
Rasdanation: Abstain
Commander_Zemas: Abstain
xXTheHydraXx: Abstain
Colberius X: Crushita Telcontar (10)
HannahB: DNV
Crushita Telcontar: DNV

HannahB and Evelynx have voted the same every round except for when HannahB didn't vote. So, yeah, they're definitely tied to each other. I have stated before that I thought HannahB was suspicious, and the only way to find out what they are is to vote, so I vote HannahB.

I find this argument specious, you're cherrypicking the data. What you mean is that HannahB and I have voted for the same person twice.

This could be evidence, except numerous people have voted for the same person as someone else twice, and some have voted for the same person as other people quite a bit more often:

Code: [Select]

xXTheHydraXx+Commander_Zemas                    : 3
North+Crushita_Telcontar                        : 3
Wintermoot+Laurentus                            : 4
Lumenland+Sapphiron                             : 3
Lumenland+Evelynx                               : 3
Lumenland+Bootsie                               : 3

/r/theydidthemath

Did you just /r/theydidthemath your own post?

In that case...

/r/theydidthemath

/r/theydidthemonstermath

/r/theydidthepossiblyapsychopathmath

Yeah, I agree that's not Gerrick's best ever argument. People begin making an argument like that when they're set on one suspect (or two suspects in this case) and begin interpreting weaker evidence to relate it to their theory. I suspect Eva-B duo as much as anyone else, but we should be careful with what we view as evidence. It's not a given that the Psychos will always vote the same way. Hannah didn't always vote the same way as Crush, either. I think Broddring did, but he died so quickly that analysing his vote and using it as evidence is problematic, since we have too small a sample to work with in his case.

Did you just /r/theydidthemath your own post?

In that case...

/r/theydidthemath

/r/theydidthemonstermath

/r/theydidthepossiblyapsychopathmath

I did... =p
Thought it was funny, sorry.

Did you just /r/theydidthemath your own post?

In that case...

/r/theydidthemath

/r/theydidthemonstermath

/r/theydidthepossiblyapsychopathmath

Considering that the original third one is /r/itwasagraveyardgraph, I think /r/itmightbeapsychopath would be more in line.

Or, as reddit is more prone to do these days, /r/theydidthefuckyou.

Yeah, I agree that's not Gerrick's best ever argument. People begin making an argument like that when they're set on one suspect (or two suspects in this case) and begin interpreting weaker evidence to relate it to their theory. I suspect Eva-B duo as much as anyone else, but we should be careful with what we view as evidence. It's not a given that the Psychos will always vote the same way. Hannah didn't always vote the same way as Crush, either. I think Broddring did, but he died so quickly that analysing his vote and using it as evidence is problematic, since we have too small a sample to work with in his case.

I'm just trying to keep the argumentation fair. It's true that the voting patterns for day #1 shouldn't be taken as gospel.. at least 2 of the people in my list did turn out to be friends after all. 2 of the people were psychopath's though, and I'd say that's it's a method that has worked a fair bit more than the alternative methods, seeing as no alternative methods have produced any usable results at all.

I'd draw attention again to the fact that I've been vocally calling out ACTUAL PROVEN psychopaths since the start of cycle 2 and that HannahB's guilt is contingent on my own.

Ah, I'm sorry, but I do think I'm going to be voting for Evelynx this round, I'm very sorry. It's just, so many times we've listened to their logic and wound up killing friends or good people, so that's my reason for voting ;-;
I mean, I am suspicious of HannahB too, but I'm more suspicious of Eve at this point.

And yet you switched votes from Crush to North. If Hannah isn't a psychopath, I'd be prepared to change course, but this one is one I plan to follow up until the point that they drag Hannah's lifeless body out of the game and reveal her role.

And yet you switched votes from Crush to North. If Hannah isn't a psychopath, I'd be prepared to change course, but this one is one I plan to follow up until the point that they drag Hannah's lifeless body out of the game and reveal her role.

North was also in my list. I guess that's how this is gonna go, I guess all I can hope is that Hannah isn't a psychopath.

It's nothing personal, for the record.