View Topic

So why didn't you even voice such suspicion for Gerrick, and test the waters with him too?

Yeah. You've definitely not done anything to lessen my suspicion either.

Vote: Barnes
Reasons: Operating and voting on a "gut instinct", and not satisfactorily answering why I'm being targeted instead of another, despite claiming he felt suspicious of Gerrick for much the same reason.
Degree of Certainty: 70%. He's either a Wolf, or operating on quite similar logic to that used by Amalya in Werewolf 3 when she suspected me.

Nothing against you personally. I don't want to create an intrapersonal character war.

Lol, I'm not offended. I'm just being ruthless. I'm also sorry if it sounds like it's getting a bit too heated.

That said, there is very little that will make me change my vote now.

As you suggested, Laurentus, this is what I have to say:

Vote: BraveSirRobin
Reasons: I didn't like his reasoning in that post during the last Team Discussion phase; I have no real ideas about who to vote for, I dislike randomizers, and voting for my son means I don't have to worry if he hates me for it
Degree of Certainty: 50%.  Either he's a bad guy or he isn't.

My father's logic, while I'm quite sure is well-intentioned, is not very sound, and the adherence to his logic would end pretty unpleasantly.  Firstly, he states that his principle reason for voting for me is that he did not like my logic during the last discussion round.  Perhaps this is because they (Wintermoot and Colberius) are the two defenders that are linked, or perhaps they are both something else, like Seers.  However, right after this he indicates that he "ha{s} no real ideas about who to vote for."  This, coupled with his first allegation, that he did not particularly like my reasoning last voting round, is, when taken together, self-contradictory.  My reasoning was that Wintermoot was online and focusing on other sections of the forum, whilst simultaneously seeming to avoid the Werewolf game. 

Additionally, it appears to me that Colberius and Evelynx voted for me last time?  I just found that out from Gerrick's handy voting tabulations.  That makes Colby's current reasoning strange, as clearly he wanted me out for a different reason then. 

Did I answer sufficiently, Laurentus? 

Nope. Afraid not. I'll leave your father to explain why your reasoning is off again. Best of luck, nephew.

BUT, I will say that it sounds like your inexperience is really biting you in the sphincter.

For the record, I've been focusing on the region's official business because...well, it's the highest priority. I've been dealing with things this weekend, and haven't had time to check out the entire forum. The last time I checked it was the night phase, so there was no real reason to post then.

As for who to vote for, I'm not sure yet, but I'm most suspicious of Laurentus and BraveSirRobin at the moment. I still feel like Laurentus has been suspiciously trying to steer the discussion since the game begin...just to be helpful though, or to deflect attention from him? And BSR's reasoning for voting for me doesn't make sense, since I wouldn't ignore the forum en masse just to be inactive in Werewolf...and this is the second round in a row he's voted for me for the same flawed reason.

OK.  I'm changing my vote from Wintermoot to Abstain.  Wintermoot's response has basically negated my entire reasoning, and I sincerely apoligise for suspecting him.  If anyone else has compelling evidence, I'd be happy to entertain it and change my vote accordingly.

No worries...I know it's a legitimate tactic to go inactive. It's just that I can't really afford to do that over a game.

Well. Let me ask directly then. When have I not steered a game, in any Werewolf?

I know that you're naturally given to taking charge, but it just feels different this time, like there's an ulterior purpose behind it. I can't really point to any clear evidence, but it's a feeling I have that I can't quite put my finger on.

If we choose to abstain, do we still have to fill out the form? o.o

Yes. You have to explain exactly why Abstain is a suspect, and how strongly you feel about him.

I say tar and feather that Abstain person...they're absolutely rotten. ;-;

Abstain is a mean bully who is probably the master mind behind everything >o<

I say tar and feather that Abstain person...they're absolutely rotten. ;-;

No, no, we must gag them and put them into the metal bull, that'll show them >.<