View Topic

At the time, the logic was that the following would have been claimed: Luigi, Toad, Peach. There would be 2 claimed Toads, both of whom started as toads, but one of them now Iggy. Bowser would have to counterclaim Peach or Luigi. Thus we'd narrow down who we had to lynch from there - one of the two Toad claims. Also we'd have one confirmed clear. If there were two Luigi claims and two Toad claims, then whoever claimed Peach must be the real Peach. If there were two Peach claims, similarly, whoever claimed Luigi must be the true Luigi.

Well played though, to everyone.

Even if that were the case, it would still be up to everyone to decide which of the two people were the real good people and the real bad people, a process that could have taken 2-4 turns depending on lucky guesses and the actions of the wolves. It was a bit too little, too late at the very last turn.

This is the fastest game to end though.

And it's a shame, too...I think this game fell victim to bad timing, with the beginning of the annual NS summer decline and a lot of people taking breaks and vactions. I hope we revisit this theme in the future though, cause it was bar none my favourite, and Pengu's posts brought the theme to life in his uniquely humorous way. In spite of the relative inactivity, this was my favourite game, and I even think it was more intimate in a way.

It made for an interesting game, though.

Okay, whose idea was it to get rid of me immediately, and why? 

That would be me. I believed that Laurentus would be the most formidable opponent from what I observed during the first day phase, but I felt that directly targetting him would be obvious and a waste of a vote, so I picked you instead in the hopes that someone would pick up on Laurentus mentioning you during the first day...which fortunately Sapphiron did.

I'll be revisiting it when Wintreath becomes a bit more active.  This was actually a severely watered down version of the idea that I had, and I changed the title so that I can revisit it in its entirety later, and hopefully add all of the twists and surprises that were originally intended.

Usually the summer decline ends in September...maybe after then?

Edit: Then in November we have the winter decline to look forward to.

I fucked up badly in the second day phase. I honestly couldn't think of a way to avoid suspicion after that.

I must say, I didn't expect you to go after Sapphiron so hard, but it played well into my strategy.

Good game everyone! That last day was going to be tricky for the good players for sure.

I liked the theme Pengu. I've had a Mario kart inspired theme in mind for a while, but never the time to run it. Hopefully we will get to revisit the Mushroom Kingdom again

Anyone suffering from werewolf withdraws already could sign up for the XKI game here: http://10000islands.proboards.com/thread/30487/werewolf-44-planet-express?page=2#scrollTo=1308860 Sign ups are only open for 24 more hours though.

I've never really watched Futurama, but it seems to have attracted a lot of people.

Good game everyone! That last day was going to be tricky for the good players for sure.

I liked the theme Pengu. I've had a Mario kart inspired theme in mind for a while, but never the time to run it. Hopefully we will get to revisit the Mushroom Kingdom again

Anyone suffering from werewolf withdraws already could sign up for the XKI game here: http://10000islands.proboards.com/thread/30487/werewolf-44-planet-express?page=2#scrollTo=1308860 Sign ups are only open for 24 more hours though.

Well, since Werewolf 45 is going to be the same theme in XKI, hopefully it'll be explored to it's fullest given the normal attendance of players we tend to get.  And being able to fully explore it there will help me tweak things here and there to hopefully craft and refine it for here.

I must say, I didn't expect you to go after Sapphiron so hard, but it played well into my strategy.

I had nothing else to go on. I didn't really want to go after you because the tradition of dying first wasn't a completely valid reason to go for you, and that really kicked me in the butt.

Then with the way both Sapph and I acted out of character, I couldn't really change my vote even if I wanted to, because at that stage it was between me and him.

My one last hope was to try and convince people that Aaron was our defender, but then there were too few people left, and our suspicions didn't help. I chose too late to whole-heartedly go with my suspicion that you were a Koopa.

So rather than going crazy with it:

*Wintermoot killed off Colberius X on night one, and then Aragonn in night 2.  He also kidnapped the princess on both nights.
*Taulover chose to scan Wintermoot on the first night, but was kidnapped and thus his scan was useless.  Shame about that one, really.  He didn't scan anyone on the next night.
*The defenders didn't defend anyone on night one.  Aaron defended himself on night two.

Is it okay to state that I figured Wintermoot to be King Koopa after I died?

I have a feeling most people suspected it, but since finding the Koopalings was a priority first, nobody wanted to point fingers.

I actually thought I did fairly well at masking myself.

You slipped after I died, Snowturnip.

But you were dead, and thus it didn't matter, gaming buddy.