View Topic

I thought he could only kill twice. My bad.

So these are our options rn:

If we lynch then we've a 50/50 chance of getting a bad guy or ending the game.
If we don't lynch, we're betting on luck that the Lancelot kills an evil guy today and the day after and that they don't kill any of us...

If I'm honest I'd rather take my chances with lynching, since the other outcome relies heavily on the scum getting unlucky/having bad reads.

With that thought in mind...
Vote:Send Reon to the bridge

If you are a villager, please, y'know, actually try and defend yourself as opposed to being as apathetic as the others have been...

I am going to do a leap of faith here.

Most of the previous rounds of Werewolf involved Wintermoot dying early. Although Wintermoot claimed previously that the only reason why he survived till then was because the defenders had been protecting him, I am going to hazard a guess that it is in actuality because Wintermoot is one of the bad guys.

Vote: Send Wintermoot to the bridge

That is a remarkably odd leap of reasoning...for one, it's known that roles had to be re-assigned mid-game, meaning that I couldn't possibly have been a wolf during the early rounds when you claim I didn't die because I was a bad guy. Even if that were not the case, for what you say to be true both targets that I would have selected would have had to be defended during the early turns (because I've obviously been active), and I would have had to betray Libertarian Republics, since I'm the one that intially casted a vote for him, although it was luck that he happened to be a wolf.

As someone that is usually quite logical in his reasoning in this game, and usually not so vocal about voting someone off, I can only conclude that this is a rush to eliminate me, someone wolves have been unable to kill off during the night rounds, and thus win the game...therefore, I conclude that you are one of the bad guys.

Vote: Send Sapphiron to the bridge.

I am looking at the possibility of the seer-wolf scanning you as the Black Knight and revealing it to the other wolves and have Libetarian Republics lie to protect the bad guys' final hope. There may be a small gap but like I said, it's a leap of faith.

You can call it a leap of faith. I call it a desperate move to end the game asap.

With that thought in mind...
Vote:Send Reon to the bridge

If you are a villager, please, y'know, actually try and defend yourself as opposed to being as apathetic as the others have been...

So... Am I a random pick? Or do you have reasons... Because I'd like to defend myself but... It's a lot harder to do that if I'm a random pick.
On the other hand I can make this argument: I had literally no clue I was signed up for this game until I got pinged like three nights in or something and I've only said like three things. I really just haven't been that active for this game and I'm sorry for that. If we lose, it's very possible that that will be my fault for not having been here and being attentive earlier...

http://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=2218.0

I suppose I should have followed up with everyone about whether they were still in.

So... Am I a random pick? Or do you have reasons... Because I'd like to defend myself but... It's a lot harder to do that if I'm a random pick.
On the other hand I can make this argument: I had literally no clue I was signed up for this game until I got pinged like three nights in or something and I've only said like three things. I really just haven't been that active for this game and I'm sorry for that. If we lose, it's very possible that that will be my fault for not having been here and being attentive earlier...

Yeah it was random.
I was hoping voting someone would spark some life into a somewhat-dead thread. It worked!
So, my guess is, you're scum that is covering your tracks or a peasant that didn't get a PM... I'm kinda leaning towards the latter. You didn't post at all till D3, which backs up what you said, so I'm willing to trust you.
Unvote ? I don't know how it's done here...

And now I'm confused between Sapphiron and Wintermoot...

Edit: Spelling & Grammar. How do English?

I'll simply disregard your previous vote.

Hmm....both Wintermoot and Sapphiron seem logical, but Sapphiron is making a "leap of faith"....

Vote: Send Wintermoot to the bridge

I've had better experiences with leaps of faith.

Edited to fix bold

Really? There's absolutely nothing logical about Sapphiron's post, because it's not even factually possible for his story about me to be true. >.<

I'm sorry about getting to this so late again. I had a day with my family. Anyway, here we go.
The Black Knight (starring Aragonn) and the Knight of Ni (starring Reon) could barely contain their excitement as Sir Galahad (starring Wintermoot) walked down to face the riddles. As soon as he was far enough down the road, they proceeded to brutally cut down Sir Lancelot, (starring taulover), and Sir Lancelot's steward, (starring Ayanhart).

Down by the bridge, Sir Galahad got into an altercation with Tim, and soon Tim was shooting fireballs at Sir Galahad, and Sir Galahad was deflecting expertly.

Just as the witch (starring Sapphiron) was about to intervene by sacrificing a cat and making the bridge tip over, letting both men fall into the pit, suddenly the doctors and nurses from the mental institution found them. "Come along now, Sir Galahad, and where did King Arthur get to? Honestly, I thought you were cured of your insanity after getting arrested last time. Oh, well. We'll find them soon enough."

The Black Knight, Knight of Ni and Witch were dumbstruck. What the hell did they just witness?
Let me be the first to admit that this game was a bit of a train wreck, but allow me to give a hearty congratulations to Sapphiron, Reon and Aragonn for winning the game for the bad guys!

And if you're wondering what the hell was with that ending story I've just written, just watch Monty Python and the Holy Grail.

And please, I'd love feedback on the game, where I went wrong, what I could have done better and so forth. Don't worry about sparing my feelings. I don't have any.

The police arriving towards the end did leave me dumbstruck the first time I watched it. Laurentus, you had been a great host, although you shouldn't have that many direct engagements with the players besides clarifying doubts and tallying the lynch votes.

Witch's Actions
Night 1 - Colberius X
Night 2 - El Fiji Grande
Night 3 - Aragonn
Night 4 - aternox

Day 1 - No Lynch
Day 2 - Tomb
Day 3 - Libetarian Republics
Day 4 - Skipped voting due to real life commitments
Day 5 - Wintermoot

To be honest, I think the main problem was that sign-ups were held out too long...I think we lost some people during that period, which led to having to switch roles halfway through the game, which led to an even bigger mess imo.

On a personal note, I probably won't play the next game of Werewolf. I'm almost always the first to be targeted, and apparently when I'm not immediately killed off that alone is a cause for suspicion...it's just not very fun being in that situation, and I see no way of rectifying it except for taking a few games off and giving others the 'honor' of being the first one targeted.