View Topic

Game Over on Round 5 Day

Root Host: Caitlinuwu

Players · Votes · Posts

Wintermoot, Rem, Grace, Master Radishes is probably my PoE. I'd be fine with a Moot yeet today.

Abigail and Loona are a bit ambiguous but I'd not prioritize them yet I think

My issue is with Abi trying to force a tie espically now knowing that Sugar was a red flip. I brought it up before day 1 ended but it felt as though Abi wanted to try to get the tie to rang onto red.

I don't mind her doing tie shenanigans

but the fact she was going for a red lynch but was kinda forced to vote sugar to not look too bad after the red power role claim is kinda blergh

even if it was her vote who took sugar down
cuz it was mainly self preserv by trying to create a gap

It's probably important to remember that she initially broke the tie by voting red and wanting to vanish in the EoD until people squeezed her a bit

Heres the thing, no one really squeezed. All I said was no no no, explain your vote first, and then they immediatly came back,

notice how they never really explained it properly too lol

I was going to call for a Red kill today to clear up wagons. But now I want Winter. Obviously present, big walls with no actual outcome, decided to try and get a town over instead of the wolf.

Vote: Wintermoot

Why though? Red is the counter wagon to a wolf flip there was always a higher chance the slot was going to flip town because the likelihood of 2 mafia being the final wagons on day 1 is just super slim

loona is probably a townlean to me while abbi is a wolflean

Loona and Ex as wolves might be playing as if Sugar is also a wolf so.

I was waiting for a bit but how exlite has been playing around me today with Rem calling me a 'town clear' fake and then Loona's empty demand of me to provide a list after being afk for a whole phase.

I am pretty sure they killed the easy mislynch because they had it right. Sugar Moon + Loona + Ex Lite.

If you are town please feel free to provide a reason why Red would be killed that doesnt boil down to wifom. 

Town Clears:
Neon
Myself

Town from play:
Rem
Myself

Spewed Town:
Ori
Grace
Radish
Myself

If I am wrong because I just dont vibe:
Winter
Bell


Wrote this post up after loona asked for a reads list. But was waiting till she demanded that I respond to her. But the limp questioning didnt really want an answer, just wanted to look towny. 

Vote: Grace

I do agree we should probably hit a low poster on day 2, because otherwise they will continue to exist and just hurt the game.

Also opportunistic as fuck

Wintermoot, Rem, Grace, Master Radishes is probably my PoE. I'd be fine with a Moot yeet today.

Abigail and Loona are a bit ambiguous but I'd not prioritize them yet I think

Vote: Ex Light

Also your vote didn't count, prolly cuz my name was mispelled

I recommend using that checkmark tool in the text editor

for now I'll just
Vote: Wintermoot

I might switch to Radish later depending on moot activity

This vote makes no sense. I am a no poster from Dayphase 1 and then Ex Lite decides to ignore me and not interact with me at start of day. but Clearly knows I am "green checked" by Rem which means they cant push me so didnt put me in the low poster opportunistic push. I should be suspicious as fuck but instead votes with me on winter? But not even acknowledging or validating my reasons for voting? Just trying to keep a wagon on a town. (Alternate history if I am wrong on one of the two of them Winter is still my best top pick and could partner with either of them easily)


I have yet to find them looking for town, they are just poking people and trying to tear a town core apart. 

Vote: ExLight I am equally on Loona so if that is where you would prefer happy to go there Instead




Using more conventional knowledge.

It would point at 1 in Oricorio / Exlight / Loona. 1 in Grace/Radish. 1 in Wintermoot/Bellepi if I am wrong. 

I would look more at the Ex Light / Wintermoot or Loona / Wintermoot worlds first

After that use this vote analysis as you wish because I am dead tonight and thats ok.

Nice lynch. Couldn't be here too much today due to volunteering at a food bank but I'll try to ISO people (please tell me this site has a proper ISO feature) and look at their interactions with moon. As for the kill, not too much of a surprise as they were a PR claim and were spewed town from the lynch. We could look at who would be more motivated to kill Projekt, but nightkill analysis based off one nightkill is filled with too much WIFOM to be reliable, usually you want at least three so that the patterns become more clear.

Can't find an ISO feature anywhere (the "posts" thing at the top of the page is worthless) and not willing to ctrl+F through 30 pages for nine different players (if you could set it to 50 posts per page, though...), so shucks. I guess I'll just look at some posts around EoD for now

Vote: Sugar Moon

Their read on me was fake

So working backwards for a bit, Abby was the last voter on the Moon wagon. They gave this reason, but it was barely elaborated at all and seemingly came out of nowhere (but I can't tell for sure, because again, no ISO). If Abby could elaborate this point, it'd be nice

I was going to call for a Red kill today to clear up wagons. But now I want Winter. Obviously present, big walls with no actual outcome, decided to try and get a town over instead of the wolf.

Vote: Wintermoot

Why though? Red is the counter wagon to a wolf flip there was always a higher chance the slot was going to flip town because the likelihood of 2 mafia being the final wagons on day 1 is just super slim

loona is probably a townlean to me while abbi is a wolflean

Loona and Ex as wolves might be playing as if Sugar is also a wolf so.

I was waiting for a bit but how exlite has been playing around me today with Rem calling me a 'town clear' fake and then Loona's empty demand of me to provide a list after being afk for a whole phase.

I am pretty sure they killed the easy mislynch because they had it right. Sugar Moon + Loona + Ex Lite.

If you are town please feel free to provide a reason why Red would be killed that doesnt boil down to wifom.

Town Clears:
Neon
Myself

Town from play:
Rem
Myself

Spewed Town:
Ori
Grace
Radish
Myself

If I am wrong because I just dont vibe:
Winter
Bell


Wrote this post up after loona asked for a reads list. But was waiting till she demanded that I respond to her. But the limp questioning didnt really want an answer, just wanted to look towny.

Vote: Grace

I do agree we should probably hit a low poster on day 2, because otherwise they will continue to exist and just hurt the game.

Also opportunistic as fuck

Wintermoot, Rem, Grace, Master Radishes is probably my PoE. I'd be fine with a Moot yeet today.

Abigail and Loona are a bit ambiguous but I'd not prioritize them yet I think

Vote: Ex Light

Also your vote didn't count, prolly cuz my name was mispelled

I recommend using that checkmark tool in the text editor

for now I'll just
Vote: Wintermoot

I might switch to Radish later depending on moot activity

This vote makes no sense. I am a no poster from Dayphase 1 and then Ex Lite decides to ignore me and not interact with me at start of day. but Clearly knows I am "green checked" by Rem which means they cant push me so didnt put me in the low poster opportunistic push. I should be suspicious as fuck but instead votes with me on winter? But not even acknowledging or validating my reasons for voting? Just trying to keep a wagon on a town. (Alternate history if I am wrong on one of the two of them Winter is still my best top pick and could partner with either of them easily)


I have yet to find them looking for town, they are just poking people and trying to tear a town core apart.

Vote: ExLight I am equally on Loona so if that is where you would prefer happy to go there Instead




Using more conventional knowledge.

It would point at 1 in Oricorio / Exlight / Loona. 1 in Grace/Radish. 1 in Wintermoot/Bellepi if I am wrong.

I would look more at the Ex Light / Wintermoot or Loona / Wintermoot worlds first

After that use this vote analysis as you wish because I am dead tonight and thats ok.

this is horrible

to you both me and loona who pushed and made the sugar wagon the leading one are in your PoE? Instead of the people that didn't partake or that were sitting on the mislynch?

this doesn't even make sense, please dude

Vote: Projekt Red

Full disclosure I wanted red to react more

But moon is wolf

Admittedly this is even more weird. It's like they knew Moon was wolf, yet wanted to save them anyway. But why say that openly?

also how is red an "easy mislynch" lmfao they were literally hard cleared from Day 1

Vote: Sugar Moon

I think we got enough interactions and I'd rather go for a MIA player than Red who can continuously give us more interactions

I believe this broke a tie, so I probably wouldn't lynch here today. Leaving the vote tied for so long is... something, but that's a discussion for another day I guess. Occam's Razor suggests this is town.

Vote: Projekt Red

Full disclosure I wanted red to react more

But moon is wolf

Admittedly this is even more weird. It's like they knew Moon was wolf, yet wanted to save them anyway. But why say that openly?

I think she's implying she'd always change vote to moon last second but it just seems really unnecessary since less than two minutes left on the clock isn't exactly a lot of time for red to react to anything

red had already reacted plenty before in the EoD too so this play from her was just reckless at best and else feels scummy

Vote: Sugar Moon

dont just cause a tie cause its funny

Loona's aggressiveness in pushing the Moon lynch does look good in hindsight.

Sorry for the last minute vote...something came up I didn't expect. v_v

This is hard...I'm reminded of one good thing about not voting the first day, not having to vote when you're not entirely sure. Though I guess you're never completely sure anyways, it's just even worse on the first day.

I would have liked to hear from Sugar Moon, because I can't help but feel like an elaboration from him would have helped clear that up. I can't help but feel like the whole thing could be a misunderstanding. On the other hand, there doesn't seem to be much reasoning behind Red either...I guess it's just how it is the first day. =/

If I have to vote for one (I mean I could vote for someone else but what would be the point?), I guess it'd be Vote: Projekt Red

This does feel a bit hedgy and light on reasoning, plus it seemingly came out of nowhere (again, no ISO so I can't verify 100%). Into the POE this one goes

Vote: Sugar Moon

I think we got enough interactions and I'd rather go for a MIA player than Red who can continuously give us more interactions

I believe this broke a tie, so I probably wouldn't lynch here today. Leaving the vote tied for so long is... something, but that's a discussion for another day I guess. Occam's Razor suggests this is town.

I'd also like to point out that at one point Red removed the vote from Sugar which solidified him as the Day's lynch and both me and Loona pressed him into revoting Sugar for self preserv

It wouldn't make sense as wolf for either of us to ask for a town player to maintain the pressure on the scum wagon

Vote: Projekt Red

Gonna ghost eod good luck

Again, came out of nowhere. She eventually retracted the second part, maybe because she was aware that parking here might make her look bad? Not the best look

Loona and Ex as wolves might be playing as if Sugar is also a wolf so.

If Loona/Moon are w/w and you were town, why would Loona vote Moon over you?

Sugar stopped posting.

Which I think was why I had Loona as partnered actually.

Anyways today sucks.

Vote: Bellepi

This was the one attempt at a vanity wagon yesterday. The fact that no wolves jumped on Bellepi may say something, then again maybe they were just expecting Projekt to go down.