View Topic

Game Over on Round 4 Day

Root Host: Wintermoot

Players · Votes · Posts

But wouldn’t we citizens also want to vote to avoid the same knockout rule, because if we don’t, that means less people left to stop the werewolf or werewolves from winning? You’re using an argument that can be redirected back to you, and it’s contradictory to any that you had last round. A plan that doesn’t have much regard as to who could be affected, and even state yourself that you are also a target of it. Wouldn’t carelessness for others be something that a werewolf has? And think about it, if you wipe the most talkative people of the game out, then that means a few bad events could secure our doom. I feel like you’re haphazardly planning votes that people will agree upon and carry out, for you to use previous followers against you because you can use their following as an additional reason. And a man without others to trust him is one that people will suspect of doing bad things. I will not take direct action against you, since that would be disrespectful to do on the first accusation and would just be pitiful, but know that I have eyes on you and your plans. Your plans made sense in the first day and I agreed with them, since I saw no flaws or hidden meanings behind it, but now that they’ve been voted out as a commoner and you’re plotting against me, i’m now contemplating if your voting against them was just a scheme to drag others down. In a game of trust and accusations, bad planning and follower accusing is a surefire way to get suspected of being the bad guy. And your words against me have made me lose trust within you and your plots, knowing they could be a fraud to drag innocent men and women like me down for your own personal gain. And though this message is personalized towards you, Aragonn, I am not saying you are the only one that could be a werewolf, because anyone here could be. With that said, and as a repeat of what I said before, your words of suspicion against me, a follower of your previous vote, has made me lose trust in you and has me questioning if you are even fully human. I now bid you a goodbye, and if I were to go missing by the next dawn, a farewell.

We have three people who will be eliminated this round if they do not cast a vote. If I was a wolf, I would be casting votes to avoid getting slapped with the knockout rule. The only one terribly active other than myself is Leesbra.

Successive in convincing others or not, I atleast want this message to make you realize that your logic here is less than sensible, and that I am trying to help us find the werewolf, or werewolves, among us. Not to shamefully bring our party and our town to its knees.

That was a very aggressive defense. You know what else is aggressive? A werewolf. Ha, got 'em!
In all seriousness though, don't get your whiskers in a twist. You're not going to get any hard evidence of someone being a werewolf. What you get are gut instincts and intuition. Everything is circumstantial. Yes, you did follow my line of reasoning in the first day. Who wouldn't? It's a strategy developed by werewolf veterans over the course of many, many games to allow Town to survive just a bit longer and have a better chance at winning the game. However, you did not vote for the same person as me. You voted for someone else, perhaps as a way to allow RNGesus to be the deciding factor in that lynch. Regardless, I've locked my sights onto you now. I will Vote: Leesbra. No hard feelings, bud.

Uhm...what?

You both voted for A Kindle of Kittens.  Leesbra even voted for them first at the beginning, and you later lemmed their vote when ENE didn't respond, saying it was the "popular choice at the time"

C'mon Aragonn.

Or is this some meta thing where you both played a different game together?  <.<

No, it's not a meta thing. I originally voted for someone else, Leesbra voted for Kittens, ENE said something, and then I switched over.

No, it's not a meta thing. I originally voted for someone else, Leesbra voted for Kittens, ENE said something, and then I switched over.

Okay then, the bolded bit is just really off then.  For starters, because everyone that round was voting randomly except for Rewan, who also voted for A Kindle of Kittens (which apparently they didn't do properly since it was never recorded, and I just now saw it perusing back).  But then you hopped off of ENE and voted specifically for Kittens, why? Because it was the popular choice?  Even given what I said earlier about your anti-no-kill-on-day-phases bit (which, if we're being honest, has always either resulted in a D1 villager/Seer/Guardian kill, and has yet to result in actually killing a wolf), this still feels really off for you.

Sorry man, but I'm going to have to go with my gut on this one.

Vote: Unvote
Vote: Aragonn

Gah, just noticed it didnt go through.  <.<

Vote: Aragonn

I needed a new target after ENE spoke up, and I thought Kittens had two legit votes for them. I thought that voting for someone else wouldn't change the outcome of the day. And you're getting upset at me for a D1 kill when it's literally in the rules that a vote must be cast every day. That means someone must die every day regardless of if you think it's right or not. That's just how the game flows. And yeah, it's tough getting a wolf on D1 with nothing to go off of and statistical probability not being on your side. That doesn't make me a bad guy. I'm just playing the game as written. That bolded bit was referencing them voting for Kittens after I voted for ENE. I later switched my vote to Kittens for the aforementioned reasoning. And oh no, Kittens was a townie. Statistical probability strikes again. But now we're on D2. Power roles have had a chance to do something. I understand my argument for Leesbra is more shaky than a skyscraper in an earthquake, but I can't let this one go.

I needed a new target after ENE spoke up, and I thought Kittens had two legit votes for them. I thought that voting for someone else wouldn't change the outcome of the day. And you're getting upset at me for a D1 kill when it's literally in the rules that a vote must be cast every day. That means someone must die every day regardless of if you think it's right or not. That's just how the game flows. And yeah, it's tough getting a wolf on D1 with nothing to go off of and statistical probability not being on your side. That doesn't make me a bad guy. I'm just playing the game as written. That bolded bit was referencing them voting for Kittens after I voted for ENE. I later switched my vote to Kittens for the aforementioned reasoning. And oh no, Kittens was a townie. Statistical probability strikes again. But now we're on D2. Power roles have had a chance to do something. I understand my argument for Leesbra is more shaky than a skyscraper in an earthquake, but I can't let this one go.

I promised myself I wouldn’t respond, but I need to reply. I can’t stand for slander no more.

The rules said you must cast a vote every 2 days to not be eliminated, so it isn’t even required to vote day 1. And also, my main reasoning for voting for Kittens is to keep votes balanced so it’d be a tie, and so that I could have a choice whether to partake in voting this round. Meanwhile, you could’ve checked the votes casted before switching because there is a button to show votes. Now as we go into D2 it seems you’re using the votes to try and frame somebody else as the werewolf. Like you said yourself, That doesn’t make me a bad guy. It just means that my previous theory hadn’t worked out in the way I expected it to. And now that we have progressed through a night with no deaths, I was thinking of staying back for a bit. But now that I see you keep trying to build an argument against me, even if it’s based on low amounts of evidence, I want to convince others of your less than stable structure, and how you could possibly be a werewolf yourself. My fellow townmate, I don’t want to ruin what credibility you have, low or high, but I won’t just let you try and ruin mine.

Is this the hill you’re willing to die on?

With how hard I've been going for you after the first night, your fate is now tied to mine. Either I die before you or after you. It does not matter. Resistance is futile.

Resistance is futile. Look, I get that you’re firm on believing that I am a wolf, but there is no firm evidence saying that either one of us is. Or anybody else, for that matter. What if neither of us is a wolf? Sounds unlikely, but in a game of 7 players that means there’s only a 14.3% chance that you or me are right. Plus, your argument in the first place was a hollow stand. I felt like things wouldn’t have to be hard and rocky between us, but after that accusation, I can’t trust you. I know in previous posts of mine I have said I won’t vote against you, but you’re assuming what you say is gonna be right without considering the chances.

Vote: Aragonn

I'm not arguing anymore. I'm showing people. This isn't about statistics right now. N1 has ended. Power roles have used their abilities at least once. I am hammering down on Leesbra with a hundred percent certainty that they are a wolf. What does that tell people? And Michi, you're giving off big wolf vibes right now. Are you sure you want to keep this up? You're looking ripe for the lynching too. Perhaps the good folks will have two wolf pelts by the end of this.

Okay yeah, this feels like cornered town Aragonn.  I'm going to have to rescind my vote and re-think things a bit.

Vote: Unvote

Things are pretty dicey, and hard to tell who is who now. Everyone has valid points. Voting is risky business now.

Although, I will vote Aragonn to only counter their vote on  Leesbra. 

To be frank, I have a good feeling on Michi not being it, but no proof 

Am I the only one who found that Leesbra's wall-post seemed overly defensive? It came out of nowhere. I also agree with Michi re Aragonn's most recent post.

Vote: Leesbra

I think it's most advantageous voting either Leesbra or Aragonn today, I think there's a good chance one of them is wolf and one of them is town.

Although, I will vote Aragonn to only counter their vote on  Leesbra.

To be frank, I have a good feeling on Michi not being it, but no proof

This vote didn't actually go through. Make sure to use [vote] instead of bold or what you used to link my forum profile. Also this reeks of inexperience or wolf. Or both.