View Topic

Game Over on Round 5 Day

Root Host: ☆ Princess Abigail ☆ Other Hosts: Wintermoot

Players · Votes · Posts

eh

I'm not convinced that maf!you didn't just kill and janitor Mac and claim that there's an SK while planning on finding new ways to explain why there's only one kill every night

I also find the prospect of SK kills being janitored odd in and of itself

not sold

eh

I'm not convinced that maf!you didn't just kill and janitor Mac and claim that there's an SK while planning on finding new ways to explain why there's only one kill every night

I also find the prospect of SK kills being janitored odd in and of itself

not sold

Uh-huh, I am so dumb that I would double down on my story on the day where my plan is literally basically guaranteed to fail. That's totes a real thing. 

Lau

you claimed that it was an sk kill before Aers got voted walled

Mister vote wall maker, tear down this wall!

Lau

you claimed that it was an sk kill before Aers got voted walled

I claimed it was going to be an SK kill literally at the start of night phase, keep up, bro. 

What I didn't do yet was bind myself to certain other insinuations I've been making. 

Mister vote wall maker, tear down this wall!

I agree with my SK friend here. 

Also a Dolby spouting political slogans is a scum Dolby. 

With a little over 12 hours left for the phase there's a loooot of people who still haven't posted and/or voted and activity is pretty low too right now for the phase

@Eastern New England
@Michi
@Gerrick
@TGN
@Aersoldorf
@Dolby
@ExLight
@Marzipan
@Anubhav Ghosh
@Laurentus
@KingofDominaria
@Arenado
@Vroendal
@Ruguo
@Wischland
@Melehan
@CerealKiller

In other news the vote wall maker is asking me questions about how it works so make sure you get in your votes as they might actually take down the wall

I have yet to see anything that sparks alarm bells I can make sense of. This is all so confusing. Until the puzzle pieces start to fit together, I’ll do the only thing that makes sense to me. We shall see if it even matters ultimately.

Vote: No Lynch

i think after looking through the posts of those currently with votes i am going to vote for the one that makes the most sense to me

Vote: Vroendal

i just dont trust the meme vote restriction isnt a cover for something more sinister

The vote has been rescinded the vote count is 

@Vroendal : 2
No Lynch: 2
@ExLight : 1 
@Dolby : 1

11 hours remain

Post restriction related to Lau?

I was also very tempted to legit lynch Lau out of the gate because Laurentus? Taking the pacifist route? In a game of WW? That's SUS.

But then I remembered the post restriction, and I totally buy post restriction = pacifism line of logic.

Oh well. One day, one game, we'll be able to play with each other, no holds barred, but not today, and not in this game. XD

There is no logic line in the bolded. How does this connect? At all?

I see it as feasible that a role requires a player to do something in a game like this, e.g. try to get people to no-lynch (for whatever reason). I assume this is what Melehan meant about "post restriction = pacifist line of logic".

Dolby on Lau's alignment

I'm fine with a no-lynch, because Lau is strongly implying that he (or we) will learn something through it.

If Lau fakes this as wolf, it's a one-way street to death since we'd find by D2, probably.

Alternatively Lau is a 3p that wins if he gets town to no-lynch or something similar.

Arenado and Michi are the only ones who seem to have restricted or changed posting abilities thus far, or?

yeah here's the thing

Lau claiming there's a serial killer and only 1 kill last night is whack

and wed find out much later

i personally think that Lau is a 3P who wins if town uses all 3 of their no yeets

or he's a wolf

I agree with the third line and as you've noticed I've re-assessed Lau, seeing as I, in fact, didn't follow his no-lynch voting wagon at the end of day. However, I still believe in a Laurentus = town over Laurentus = scum world currently.

Dolby calling the same post sus for the second time

Aersoldorf: Y'all can lynch me because I won't be that active
Also Aersoldorf: is the second highest poster

Not sure how I feel about this. Seems a bit scummy.

sus posting bruh

and laurentus agreeing with Aers is also sus posting bruh

I also don't agree with Lau's meta read or even that it's real given how he didn't really pressure Aers last game to my recollection

Why did you feel the need to call the same post suspicious twice?

Dolby agreeing with ExLight's tunnel on me

I'm fine with a no-lynch, because Lau is strongly implying that he (or we) will learn something through it.

If Lau fakes this as wolf, it's a one-way street to death since we'd find by D2, probably.

Alternatively Lau is a 3p that wins if he gets town to no-lynch or something similar.

Arenado and Michi are the only ones who seem to have restricted or changed posting abilities thus far, or?

How did you even get to these absurd conclusions?

Extremely scummy posts, pushes the idea of a No Lynch D1 which is CONSTANTLY disapproved by veteran, doesn't put his money where his mouth is at, put all responsibility on Lau, and even throws shade at them possibly being 3p. If you're even CONSIDERING the possibility of them not being town why in heavens would you suggest following them?

Also the post restrictions are probably memes. We have ESL players here and restrictions like these would just be brutal/unfair unless roles were handpicked as opposed to randomized.

I actually disagree with the "considering the possibility" bit bc turtle clearly isn't scumreading Lau but yeah I vibe with the idea that the conclusions are whack and just generally like the energy of this post

Aersoldorf: Y'all can lynch me because I won't be that active
Also Aersoldorf: is the second highest poster

Not sure how I feel about this. Seems a bit scummy.

this comes off as an extremely opportunistic read
Aersol is likely an erratic post as both alignments; as someone who was in the mafia team with him last game I can vouch that he seemed extremely hyperactive and thus him being unable of posting is NAI.

Really disliking the ENE content so far, I'll prolly leave my vote here for now:
Vote: Eastern New England

Yeah I agree with this

I felt that given others reactions to him that he could fake his town play as scum to

and it's really just an opportunistic read

Exlight is a townread

What type of read were you expecting from me on my third post of today if not opportunistic? Also what is my town play?

I really don't like this (the wall) post. Maybe it's the fact that you're talking about me (and therefore I'm biased), but it doesn't feel genuine. You've made it clear that you're scum-reading me, agreeing with ExLight's posts on me and calling the same post scummy multiple times over, yet you don't want to vote me. To me this looks like you just want to see whether I'm a viable lynch option for today that you can always go back to if something goes wrong with the reasoning of "I've scum-read them this whole time!". You also make it seem like you're trying to pocket/buddy up with ExLight.

I was also very tempted to legit lynch Lau out of the gate because Laurentus? Taking the pacifist route? In a game of WW? That's SUS.

But then I remembered the post restriction, and I totally buy post restriction = pacifism line of logic.

Oh well. One day, one game, we'll be able to play with each other, no holds barred, but not today, and not in this game. XD

There is no logic line in the bolded. How does this connect? At all?

Well, everyone. Sheep me for great glory. I'm dead serious.

Vote: No Lynch

@Vroendal Wiml isn't in this game so you're gonna have to be the one to thunderdome Laurentus with me

We are not no yeeting

I do in fact see this Vro.


I liked skeptical vro, WHAT HAPPENED

If I cared about hunting scum this game, I'd actually say Vro had a decent shot at being a hit. But I'm just a peace-loving nomad.

This is literally retaliation for not getting on the no yeet train.


Like there is nothing in those two memes that is anywhere near sus

I guess it could be argued that he's trying to force a mindmeld with me, but just no. No.

Melehan is so non-commital in posting it's disturbing. Questions and questions and questions to end up with more questions and null reads

This just in, has Arenado outed himself as a plagiarist?! What scandal will rock the waters of this game next? Will Batman finally come to terms with the fact that he's actually more into ducks?!

More news at 11 from your local station, I've been your wolf guide to all things wolf good, Michi!

That settles it, when I get home from work tomorrow I'm going to figure out how to vote for you

This just in, Aersoldorf threatens player for giving out fresh news on the go! What madness will happen next?

More news at 11 from your local station, I've been your wolf guide to all things wolf good, Michi.

Aers/Michi not w/w

There are some posts that would normally make me go mrrrrrrr, but alas, I don't care about hunting scum this game. I'm on a mission to spread love and peace in a world that knows only hate and violence.

this is incredibly uncharacteristic and is actually making me think that you aren't interested in scum hunting this game, which is concerning
@Vroendal let's get the thunderdome started

Whatever gave you that idea? Was it that I said I am not interested in hunting scum? 🤔

To those who find this odd: good, you should. But is that really what you expect from Wolf-me? Stop focusing on what's odd and start questioning why Mr. Yeet-them-kids-bro is suddenly a Buddhist monk.

Yeah here's the thing


if you stopped a kill last night at the cost of our yeet I'd rather have died myself and have us retain that yeet

I'm fine with a no-lynch, because Lau is strongly implying that he (or we) will learn something through it.

If Lau fakes this as wolf, it's a one-way street to death since we'd find by D2, probably.

Alternatively Lau is a 3p that wins if he gets town to no-lynch or something similar.

Arenado and Michi are the only ones who seem to have restricted or changed posting abilities thus far, or?

yeah here's the thing

Lau claiming there's a serial killer and only 1 kill last night is whack

and wed find out much later

i personally think that Lau is a 3P who wins if town uses all 3 of their no yeets

or he's a wolf

Aersoldorf: Y'all can lynch me because I won't be that active
Also Aersoldorf: is the second highest poster

Not sure how I feel about this. Seems a bit scummy.

sus posting bruh

and laurentus agreeing with Aers is also sus posting bruh

I also don't agree with Lau's meta read or even that it's real given how he didn't really pressure Aers last game to my recollection

If I cared about hunting scum this game, I'd actually say Vro had a decent shot at being a hit. But I'm just a peace-loving nomad.

Glorious Bob is very confused why every player in the game who has posted up until this point is hard wolfsiding.

my only townread is the designated yeet of today

so yes I vibe hard with yes

I'm fine with a no-lynch, because Lau is strongly implying that he (or we) will learn something through it.

If Lau fakes this as wolf, it's a one-way street to death since we'd find by D2, probably.

Alternatively Lau is a 3p that wins if he gets town to no-lynch or something similar.

Arenado and Michi are the only ones who seem to have restricted or changed posting abilities thus far, or?

How did you even get to these absurd conclusions?

Extremely scummy posts, pushes the idea of a No Lynch D1 which is CONSTANTLY disapproved by veteran, doesn't put his money where his mouth is at, put all responsibility on Lau, and even throws shade at them possibly being 3p. If you're even CONSIDERING the possibility of them not being town why in heavens would you suggest following them?

Also the post restrictions are probably memes. We have ESL players here and restrictions like these would just be brutal/unfair unless roles were handpicked as opposed to randomized.

I actually disagree with the "considering the possibility" bit bc turtle clearly isn't scumreading Lau but yeah I vibe with the idea that the conclusions are whack and just generally like the energy of this post

Aersoldorf: Y'all can lynch me because I won't be that active
Also Aersoldorf: is the second highest poster

Not sure how I feel about this. Seems a bit scummy.

this comes off as an extremely opportunistic read
Aersol is likely an erratic post as both alignments; as someone who was in the mafia team with him last game I can vouch that he seemed extremely hyperactive and thus him being unable of posting is NAI.

Really disliking the ENE content so far, I'll prolly leave my vote here for now:
Vote: Eastern New England

Yeah I agree with this

I felt that given others reactions to him that he could fake his town play as scum to

and it's really just an opportunistic read

Exlight is a townread

Vro goes from start of game being like "do you see this shit Dolby" to openly buddying with Lau

what a progression.

possible wolf

Am I laurentus in this stiuation and are Laurentus and Vro me and Wiml?

melehan posts continue to just be vibing

I hereby goal for a coalition of the willing to eliminate the heretics and their leader (Lau)

he literally follows this up with a no yeet vote.

Like
I'm not getting how Vro is switching between these two positions

Wischland had a fine post. Not super towny but enough to go above median

Under normal circumstances I'd side-eye almost the whole damned thread for not one person pointing out how easily it would be for Wolves to just jump onto No Lynch, except kinda Dolby and Vro, who, at least to my understanding, seem to implicitly think this is the case.

And just as quickly as I've opened up that can of worms I am also closing it all the way the fuck down because I still wanna no lynch today, lmao.

Considering I was the one to point out the NL most likely is linked to your role and nets you a power, I think it's more likely the wolves are avoiding the NL wagon to avoid empowering a non-wolf.

I'm just not seeing a wolfy motive for your plays so far, so you're currently in my Not A Wolf category. I do see a 3rd party motive though, so I'm not voting NL.

I would like to know who is trying to avoid the nl wagon in your eyes

vro votes no yeet, this is basically just sheeping consensus

Aers vote on ENE has such towny conviction in it, and he's saving me

ene's vote is basically retaliation to Aers's vote tbh

Vote: Aersoldorf

I don't understand why you're going here. Nor do I think that ENE's post gave out any info that's convincing

KoD has probably the player who I disagree with most that I townread most. I feel that his description of reasons to TR ENE is most relatiable but I dont agree. I also feel that while the meta point is valid that just from how people have been reacting to him across the two games that I've played with him his town and scum games are simlar

end day one

Aers and Exlight town

Wischland and KoD kinda town

way to many sus people

1) Post restriction = Lau pacifism because Lau typically does his best to drown out all opposition by burying them under mountains of posts. That's not something he can do this game,and thus we get (relatively) pacifist Lau when combined with his NL-happy role.

2) This early in the game, almost all my reads are null except for where mech is involved. This is normal.

3) I shifted off ENE's wagon because I didn't like how quickly it gained traction. At that point, the wagon was only 1 vote away from tying the NL wagon, and since I had reason to suspect that the NL was beneficial to town at that point (and bad for scum), tempting a NL fail didn't seem like a good idea. I also wanted to see what would happen to Aersol's wagon if I hopped on, and the answer was nothing.

I don't think everyone on the NL wagon is town,but I think the majority of the scumteam can be found in the names that didn't vote for NL.

🤦

This is why you don't play mafia on phone

I feel personally attacked

Vote: Dolby because I’m just now seeing “glorious bob” also because I have no option to skip

eh

I'm not convinced that maf!you didn't just kill and janitor Mac and claim that there's an SK while planning on finding new ways to explain why there's only one kill every night

I also find the prospect of SK kills being janitored odd in and of itself

not sold

But weren't you the one who pushed the janitored kill theory?

@Laurentus

Now that the 9999 votes have been retracted, how important is the NL?

Because I really want to vote Dolby at this point.