View Topic

Game Over on Round 7 Day

Root Host: Ruguo Other Hosts: Michi

Players · Votes · Posts

I think you're all focusing too much on the hosts I for one don't trust them. Especially that Michi fellow. Seems sus.

Honestly it's entirely possible that Lau was killed specifically to decrease the thread's post count

If this is true, are you implying that it was done by someone with a low post count or who has complained about having to read too much to keep up?

Conversely to keeping up as a motive, some players choose to off active town in order to simply hamper discussion. When town is left with just lower post count individuals, scum can control the thread narrative easier. 

As for day vs night kill, it really depends on any roles wording. I said kicking around ideas because it's really too early to determine a pattern and thus make any sort of fair assumption. They are simply things to keep in mind as we progress and gain more information. 

On black knight, I took that as more holy grail reference. Tis but a scratch. 

Also Lau getting killed D3 is weird
does anyone want to claim that? it seems busted for a scum role

I wonder if they tried to kill him last night but got blocked too?

I would be surprised if they didn't go for Lau - a Defender will generally be unprotected and thus a good hit.

I'm leaning that it was a scum day-vig, however I'm open to the possibility of a solo like SK.

Also in hindsight the KoD wagon yesterday was too stagnant, hopefully there'll be a bit more vote movement today.


I did some digging, and it's also interesting that your role showed up as a wolf role. Now I know not to trust the flavor too much and I know that my checks aren't 100% accurate, but it makes you think...

Vote: ExLight

I'd like to hear your thoughts on this.

https://ibb.co/HGNdT7Z

Went to the Wintreath Discord and didn't find this quote in the Wintreath channel, so assuming it came from a private chat that you and he and the hosts were part of?

I think you're all focusing too much on the hosts I for one don't trust them. Especially that Michi fellow. Seems sus.

You're the one focused on the hosts?

I did some digging, and it's also interesting that your role showed up as a wolf role. Now I know not to trust the flavor too much and I know that my checks aren't 100% accurate, but it makes you think...

Vote: ExLight

I'd like to hear your thoughts on this.

 Could you explain this bit a little more? Are you saying that you used role cop power on Ex and then compared that finding with previous games? If so, what role did you determine that he has?

https://ibb.co/HGNdT7Z

Went to the Wintreath Discord and didn't find this quote in the Wintreath channel, so assuming it came from a private chat that you and he and the hosts were part of?

It's in the Werewolf channel which I believe is an optable role. 
And no I'm the one saying that just because there's a rule and the hosts didn't word something a specific way does not mean that things are exactly as they appear.

But I'm going to attempt to entice my friends to help me make some sense of this all maybe over some tea and cookies. 

It is now Night 2. Send actions and all that jazz. Night will end at 4pm CST tomorrow the 31st.

Quiet Mode has been activated. Do not post if you are not designated as immune.
There have been a few complaints and people need time to catch up. Needing time to catch up is not alignment indicative and players should use the mechanic as they need. It is here for a reason. Please use it.

@Aersoldorf - this makes it sound like a host decision. But regardless, I also do agree with Ruguo here, catching up is not alignment-indicative. I'd rather have all players caught up and able to enjoy themselves as opposed to only top posters getting that privilege.

*coughs* I've been making that argument since D1 *cough*

I did some digging, and it's also interesting that your role showed up as a wolf role. Now I know not to trust the flavor too much and I know that my checks aren't 100% accurate, but it makes you think...

Vote: ExLight

I'd like to hear your thoughts on this.

Could you explain this bit a little more? Are you saying that you used role cop power on Ex and then compared that finding with previous games? If so, what role did you determine that he has?

Yes, he showed up as Perry Tealeaf. And used the search function to determine that it was a role used in the game titled Wintreath's Got Talent!, where one of the Saboteurs (Wolves) that game had that role.

It is now Night 2. Send actions and all that jazz. Night will end at 4pm CST tomorrow the 31st.

Quiet Mode has been activated. Do not post if you are not designated as immune.
There have been a few complaints and people need time to catch up. Needing time to catch up is not alignment indicative and players should use the mechanic as they need. It is here for a reason. Please use it.

@Aersoldorf - this makes it sound like a host decision. But regardless, I also do agree with Ruguo here, catching up is not alignment-indicative. I'd rather have all players caught up and able to enjoy themselves as opposed to only top posters getting that privilege.

Immediately after the 'quiet mode has been activated. do not post if you are not designated as immune' bit, they point out that 'THERE HAVE BEEN A FEW COMPLAINTS' which was the required action to trigger the mode - hence why I thought it was player triggered instead of a host decision. I'm also not suggesting that catching up is AI, but it is more beneficial to a scum player who needs to be more careful what they say to be able to keep up with the thread than it is for a town to be able to keep up because they don't have to worry about a TMI slip.

Sorry if I make you want to bang your head on your desk. I have an unusual mind and don't always think like others do.

I did some digging, and it's also interesting that your role showed up as a wolf role. Now I know not to trust the flavor too much and I know that my checks aren't 100% accurate, but it makes you think...

Vote: ExLight

I'd like to hear your thoughts on this.

Could you explain this bit a little more? Are you saying that you used role cop power on Ex and then compared that finding with previous games? If so, what role did you determine that he has?

Yes, he showed up as Perry Tealeaf. And used the search function to determine that it was a role used in the game titled Wintreath's Got Talent!, where one of the Saboteurs (Wolves) that game had that role.

That is pretty interesting and it got me to wondering about my role. I looked around a bit and managed to find it. I don't know what it means concerning your theory here, but I can say with certainty that my powers this game do NOT match those of the role by the same name in the game from which it was taken. They're a bit similar, but there are a couple of huge differences and that makes me want to think a bit more before simply jumping on this wagon with you.