View Topic

Game Over on Round 7 Day

Root Host: Ruguo Other Hosts: Michi

Players · Votes · Posts

Interesting, ok. And I guess I misunderstood what the neighborhood thing is - thought it was essentially a seer army.

I swear to god your cop variant is completely absurd sdonmfsdlg
I'll never get over yall saying your cop adds town to a neighborhood because that's
b u s t e d

Could just be a semantics thing? Although we do call it a seer's army in XKI as well. If Gerrick is scum that could be an excuse to explain away the poor wording, much as he used a (bad, in my opinion) excuse to explain his (lack of) response to Lau's D1 claim against him. Hate to beat a dead horse, much less a living horse that nobody else seems to want to beat on, but I might stick with my vote in this slot again today. Unless someone has new information or a better argument elsewhere. Also willing to vote TGN if that wagon forms.

Do we have a general feeling as to whether Neon is a town role with neighborhood powers, or a 3p cult leader adding to her following? I've never played with either role that I remember so not really sure how to feel about that role. I do know that I'm not the one she added last night.

One thought that I haven't seen anyone else bring up - what are the chances that the only people who were immune to the quiet mode were all town? Seems like that would be a bit of a giveaway, so I'm thinking that at least 1 person who was able to speak during the night is a member of the scum team.

And as for the quote at the end of the night flavor post - what the heck is unexpected cheddar?

Also Lau getting killed D3 is weird
does anyone want to claim that? it seems busted for a scum role

I wonder if they tried to kill him last night but got blocked too?

What do you mean by 'busted for a scum role'? Not sure I follow what you mean here.

Also Lau getting killed D3 is weird
does anyone want to claim that? it seems busted for a scum role

I wonder if they tried to kill him last night but got blocked too?

I was kicking around the notion of a delayed kill, like a poisoner, that just triggers at the start of the second day instead of the following night. That would also account some for lack of night kills.

Seems bone headed for a Vig to off Laurentus so hastily after day start, not even giving them a chance to speak. But I guess worse plays have happened.

I agree with half of this. Lau may have been the result of a delayed kill like you suggested - it would be bad form for a vig to just waste him at that point, especially given his defender claim. That makes me think that it was more than likely a member of the scum team, or possibly a 3p with a weird win con (although I don't know if y'all have ever had one of those roles and don't feel like scrolling through all the old games looking). I don't think the lack of night kills thus far has anything to do with a delayed kill though, more likely the defenders did a great job or that the scum got role blocked in some way.

One thought that I haven't seen anyone else bring up - what are the chances that the only people who were immune to the quiet mode were all town? Seems like that would be a bit of a giveaway, so I'm thinking that at least 1 person who was able to speak during the night is a member of the scum team.

fwiw scum could have just chosen to not speak and honestly I'm not confident that every town immune spoke anyway

There was once again no death last night.

Ok yeah that was a day shot or something

One thought that I haven't seen anyone else bring up - what are the chances that the only people who were immune to the quiet mode were all town? Seems like that would be a bit of a giveaway, so I'm thinking that at least 1 person who was able to speak during the night is a member of the scum team.

fwiw scum could have just chosen to not speak and honestly I'm not confident that every town immune spoke anyway

I agree with you regarding scum choosing not to talk I guess, but didn't really consider that a town role would choose silence if they were immune.

One thought that I haven't seen anyone else bring up - what are the chances that the only people who were immune to the quiet mode were all town? Seems like that would be a bit of a giveaway, so I'm thinking that at least 1 person who was able to speak during the night is a member of the scum team.

fwiw scum could have just chosen to not speak and honestly I'm not confident that every town immune spoke anyway

I agree with you regarding scum choosing not to talk I guess, but didn't really consider that a town role would choose silence if they were immune.

K, how do you feel about Gerrick in that case

Interesting, ok. And I guess I misunderstood what the neighborhood thing is - thought it was essentially a seer army.

I swear to god your cop variant is completely absurd sdonmfsdlg
I'll never get over yall saying your cop adds town to a neighborhood because that's
b u s t e d

Could just be a semantics thing? Although we do call it a seer's army in XKI as well. If Gerrick is scum that could be an excuse to explain away the poor wording, much as he used a (bad, in my opinion) excuse to explain his (lack of) response to Lau's D1 claim against him. Hate to beat a dead horse, much less a living horse that nobody else seems to want to beat on, but I might stick with my vote in this slot again today. Unless someone has new information or a better argument elsewhere. Also willing to vote TGN if that wagon forms.

Do we have a general feeling as to whether Neon is a town role with neighborhood powers, or a 3p cult leader adding to her following? I've never played with either role that I remember so not really sure how to feel about that role. I do know that I'm not the one she added last night.

I'm just a little girl with no power hanging out in a neighborhood with my friends. I built it just for this,  lots of tea and lots of really pretty houses for everyone. None of this silly murder stuff. It's quite the place you might even call it a good place if you wanted. 

Goddess of tea and happiness

I think that Neon not only claiming being a neighborizer but also one of her targets as a neighborizer target is such a suboptimal move as a cult leader that I'm not willing to consider it. This of course assumes that there is a mafia this game and this isn't some twisted town v cult game, but at the same time I gotta think Lau HAS to have been a day vig shot from mafia. But basically, if Neon is a cult leader and claiming her neighbors, and they're confirming the neighborize, that's going to be such a bad move because eventually the mafia WILL kill them, and then it's going to be like "why is Neon's neighbor culted", we yeet Neon, she flips cult leader, then yeet her neighbors

I also kinda doubt that she has a neighborize and cult action, separately. Just to many big private chats for one person

basically, she probs town

I'm not going to guarentee that mafia or cult don't have a neighborize tbh, just seems unlikely and also the way she broke down mid d2 felt really town

I think that Neon not only claiming being a neighborizer but also one of her targets as a neighborizer target is such a suboptimal move as a cult leader that I'm not willing to consider it. This of course assumes that there is a mafia this game and this isn't some twisted town v cult game, but at the same time I gotta think Lau HAS to have been a day vig shot from mafia. But basically, if Neon is a cult leader and claiming her neighbors, and they're confirming the neighborize, that's going to be such a bad move because eventually the mafia WILL kill them, and then it's going to be like "why is Neon's neighbor culted", we yeet Neon, she flips cult leader, then yeet her neighbors

I also kinda doubt that she has a neighborize and cult action, separately. Just to many big private chats for one person

Wasn't really familiar with the differences between a 'neighborizer' and cult leader, so thanks for the clarification. I'm not convinced that Lau had to be a vig shot by scum, still could have been a 3p with a weird win con? 

I'm not going to guarentee that mafia or cult don't have a neighborize tbh, just seems unlikely and also the way she broke down mid d2 felt really town

I wasn't implying that she's scum, was merely trying to decide if she's town or a 3p.