View Topic

Because I am putting it out there the only person the human will logically kill is Vro, our only confirmed town. Ends up with Anub, Tau and me and there’s bound to be suspicion three way. This is the last phase to win, period.

The fact that Vro is still alive , while cozmik died is the only issue. I mean certainly , a defender cannot protect his target twice. So why not pick the most cleared town leader guy again , instead of the defender. But its of no use now, what's done cannot be undone here, so we can just hope Tau turns out Human , the most logical option.

My reasoning is that they decided they would rather kill the one who was doing a good job preventing all the kills so they would be guaranteed to make the nightkills they wanted later. I do think I was likely targeted the night before cozmik was nightkilled. I suppose we'll just have to ask our other questions after everything here finishes getting processed.

Alright, let's end this.

Vote - taulover

Good game!

Vote: taulover lmao

Alright, with 4/4 votes toward Tau that makes a clear majority.

Tau has been killed.  They were the last human!

That leaves our three remaining wolf buds (@Vroendal @Sapphiron, @Anubhav Ghosh) to party on, which means the game is over!  Well done players.

And apologies if my majority post of 3/5 was confusing since only 4 players were alive.  Apparently, striking through names on mobile doesn't work properly with the new system since I had done so with BSR and Nyght, only for it ignore that I had done so.  But on the plus side, this is why I also keep a total tally as well as say how each person died.

Anyways, feel free to talk about the game in here and how good the defenders (@cozmikrae and @Legacy of Smiles) were really good at anticipating the targets of the Humans (@taulover, @BraveSirRobin, @Doc).  Or just talk about how the Seer (@Hydra) was, or about what worked and what didn't work overall.  Up to you!

@Laurentus
@TGN
@NyghtOwl
@Colberius X
@Gerrick
@Eastern New England

Yay!! Congrats wolf buds! This was good game. 

When we found out that Doc was a Human, my internal reaction was WHAAAAA, we had you pegged as a potentially great Seer Army ally, very well done! You would think I had learned my lesson from LOTR, but nope. XD

The Defenders were incredible, suffice it to say I don't think we could have won at all without those saves, cozmik you did really well even after Legacy poofed, congratulations!

I had fun playing with everyone, and will definitely be taking lessons for the future from my experiences here. <3

gg everyone! I hope I was able to put up a good fight despite the circumstances.

We did kinda wreck ourselves with the night kill decisions and the WIFOM choices there. Doc had somehow already narrowed down the seer to either Colby or Hydra the second night, and we went for Colby because he was more active, and that ended up causing Vro to begin suspecting us older people even though we'd reached that choice for entirely different reasons.

Then I goofed and convinced Doc that we should just go for Hydra two nights in a row to guarantee killing him, when we should've just gone with the original plan and killed Vro the first night. Then I thought Nyght gamble was worth it. Nice work cozmik with both feigning ignorance of the Nyght argument, and using it to predict the night kill even if you didn't fully get the argument (if that was indeed true confusion).

Even though I was unable to devote the necessary time/thought into this game, I really do hope I was able to participate in good faith to help make the game worthwhile.

Ahh, I see. I had attempted to figure out both the Seer and Defenders before I was properly subbed in and didn't really get anywhere, that's impressive!

To be fair, even if you had killed Hydra instead I would probably have arrived at the same conclusions: that it wasn't a team of cozmik/Nyght/TGN/Anubhav, and killing the Seer would've made me think it was experienced Wintreans anyway. XD

I think you were able to put up a very good fight, though the PoE was pointing to you I had a very difficult time actually finding any sort of reasoning against you beyond just "I don't think it's anyone else" which means you did quite well. I thought all your posts were good ones. Your efforts certainly made the game worthwhile, and I hoped that you enjoyed it yourself!

See the first night after LoS bowed out I had realized Hydra was the seer and I defended. The next night, I knew they'd be the target again. But I couldn't protect again and I "wasted" a protect on Vro. After the fact, I asked if I could have skipped a protect, because I really would have preferred to hold on to the Vro save for a more likely scenario. But then everyone thought Nyght was the defender, so I protected Nyght right before he came out and said he was regular town. The fact that there was no kill that night was what actually mech cleared Nyght for me.

I was completely truthful all game about my confusion and general thoughts on things. Hahaha... The reason I think I was confused about the defender argument with Nyght was because I was the defender, lol, so I was curious how you all had decided on Nyght, as I didn't recall LoS particularly aligning with Nyght. But that was likely just oversight on my part. A couple times I was pushed here and there, and though LoS had left me with some posts to refer town players back to, I was afraid to use them in case I gave myself away as the other defender. So I kinda used the Nyght confusion to keep myself safe.

My last save was for Sapph, but then I got killed lol

@Vroendal at one point you asked me if I thought Nyght was defender, was that you feeling out whether it was me?

The one thing I want to learn, is how you all narrow down potential teams. I can only focus on whether one person feels sus or not, and actually my voting this game was entirely led by Vro.

I was curious how you all had decided on Nyght

@Vroendal at one point you asked me if I thought Nyght was defender, was that you feeling out whether it was me?

To first question, LOS left Nyght, Doc and Lau in town core. Doc was misread, so I misinterpreted the last one as his defender buddy. 

To second question, that was what identified you as defender for me, and I am sure what led the humans to do that too haha

Also, thanks for the game! Awesome defenders and fierce scum team  and Vro MVP 

Good game everyone, specially the defender @cozmikrae. 

Being biased against inactives is good:P , in certain occasions lol

Both Hydra and taulover were power roles! I just should've voted taulover out of the two of them lol

My fav player strikes again , Vro MVP