View Topic

Vote Sapph

What is an IL? @Doc

Although Vro's defense of Sapph makes me a bit nervous. I don't know why he's defending them and with a super vague, you should really reconsider...

Thanks for the ping I did almost completely forget that this was going on. This week has been extremely long for me and now I'm just continuing to procrastinate by being here .

Comizrae's last minute vote for Gerrick was pretty suspicious to me as it sealed the deal last minute. Unless they had a reason to vote specifically for Gerrick (which was not specified IIRC), they're definitely on my list. 

Thus, in the absence of any certitude one way or the other (though now would be a great time to point it out if you have it, non-Seer), I have to vote for the IL candidate.

I don't fully understand your vote for TGN. Yes, there might be some inactivity going on, but I'd rather try to seek and vote out an active human rather than just let someone who would be modkilled just get modkilled. At this point in the game, given your analysis of how the nights might go, I think a more aggressive approach is the right call -- go big or go home.

I'm not expecting to live much longer given Sapph's speculations. Not sure if they're trying to get one extra kill during the day or something else.

Tau's plays seem pretty NAI, so I don't have much to say on that front. Could definitely go either way.

Also I'm probably missing a lot of details based on my 10 minute skim per day phase.

Vote Sapph

Could we get an explanation on this vote?

I'm going to stop rambling now.

I don’t mind being lynched because I am an ordinary townie. Again, can the seer squad PLEASE make a read list with one more Town core or if luckily enough a scum core?

Honestly there’s really very few to work with now that the entire activity dipped to this level, so I am going to fully rely on mech clears and mech target. If Seer dies this night phase like Doc says, might as well gather up the 2-3 town core found and place them into a viable mason group, with rest of the surviving town following their wagon daily

It used to be that purely relying on seer clear is a very boring play, but it’s evidently the reasonable play now that everyone has gone to ~3 posts max per day

I'm not a fan of either Sapph or cozmik being wagons today, I have my reasons, but I think those considering or voting those two need to reconsider.

You have been right thus far, I just need you to put cozmik inside a read list and if it’s satisfactory I will vote another person

Vote: Doc

I would love explanations from Doc, cozmikrae, and Nyght.

What is an IL?

Inactivity lynch.

I don't fully understand your vote for TGN. Yes, there might be some inactivity going on, but I'd rather try to seek and vote out an active human rather than just let someone who would be modkilled just get modkilled. At this point in the game, given your analysis of how the nights might go, I think a more aggressive approach is the right call -- go big or go home.

It's very simple.
If both TGN and Nyght wind up inactivity lynched (and are not scum), you die in the night, and we mislynch, we lose automatically. That's it. Game over.
From 10 people, we go to 6, scum ties, we've lost.
This is explicitly a measure intended to hedge bets; if one of the otherwise-inactivity-lynch victims flips scum, great, we still have two days after all; if not, at least we still have tomorrow.
Consider; if I was scum, wouldn't I be best served throwing my effort and that of my team into driving a mislynch, hoping for IL, then a win on the back of that?

Vote: cozmikrae

Two reasons:
1. Did what appears to essentially be an OMGUS vote for Sapph
2. For someone with decent Werewolf experience and a relatively high activity level, I find it a tad hard to believe that she could've missed what was going on with the seer army reconstruction. It's certainly possible that she legitimately didn't get / hasn't gotten it, but it feels almost deliberately obtuse to me, like she's committed to feigning ignorance or something.

Further reasons against other current wagons:
Doc made a good point that we were basically guaranteed a loss if all three lynches went through. This seems like a reasonable argument to me, or at least a well-intentioned one, so I don't really see reason to find that suspect. Situation has changed now that Nyght as voted though, so as Hydra said it may be worth the risk of the double lynch; as such won't be voting TGN. As I've noted before, I think Sapph's behavior makes more logical sense as a villager than as a Human (not TWTBAW as Doc suggested, moreso just that the outing behavior on further reflection seemed more town-y to me).

Alright y'all. Sorry, I just needed to get a little info here and there more naturally. I don't want to make a full proper reads-list in this type of game, so I'll just put my most important current read. Let me put everything this way:

Scum Core -
Doc

Based on the nature of Doc's attack on Sapph last day phase, I find it rather unlikely that Sapph's w/w with Doc. @cozmikrae I apologize for lying to you, it's not like I could let Doc know before he had even made his first post you see. Please unvote Sapph and vote Doc. @Sapphiron I think there's a chance you're wrong about cozmik. For now I'm putting her in the low town-leans. @NyghtOwl what does this revelation make you think?

To say the least, I think I'm quite satisfied with the information we have from today.

I'll ping the other players that need it to make sure that this notice is clearly seen by everyone. @taulover, @Anubhav Ghosh, @BraveSirRobin, @TGN.

That's all I needed, thank you.

Unvote
Vote: Doc

Vote: cozmikrae

Two reasons:
1. Did what appears to essentially be an OMGUS vote for Sapph
2. For someone with decent Werewolf experience and a relatively high activity level, I find it a tad hard to believe that she could've missed what was going on with the seer army reconstruction. It's certainly possible that she legitimately didn't get / hasn't gotten it, but it feels almost deliberately obtuse to me, like she's committed to feigning ignorance or something.

Further reasons against other current wagons:
Doc made a good point that we were basically guaranteed a loss if all three lynches went through. This seems like a reasonable argument to me, or at least a well-intentioned one, so I don't really see reason to find that suspect. Situation has changed now that Nyght as voted though, so as Hydra said it may be worth the risk of the double lynch; as such won't be voting TGN. As I've noted before, I think Sapph's behavior makes more logical sense as a villager than as a Human (not TWTBAW as Doc suggested, moreso just that the outing behavior on further reflection seemed more town-y to me).

This is my second game of werewolf. At least in terms of forum werewolf.

I’m gonna trust someone way better than me is not screwing with me....Unvote

Vote: make Doc leave