View Topic

NOW is the time to post a reads list.

Mine still stands where it was.

NOW is the time to post a reads list.

Eagerly waiting 

My reads have changed a lot since I posted them, will update later.

Town Leans:
BraveSirRobin - That post, tho.
NyghtOwl - Good callouts against LoS, although I am somewhat wary that he Town-read me so soon, and with the reason that I was looking genuinely solvey, when I really haven't put nearly as much effort into the game as I usually do as Town.
TGN - Good vibes, honestly.
Doc - Went against conventional wisdom in a big way, which is not something I would think likely for Wolf!Doc to do, and I would hazard to say that apart from me, he was likely to be the kill that got blocked.

Nulls:
Legacy of Smiles - Was way too eager to clear me, to be honest, which I will always find suspect, and quite a few of the arguments he made in the previous day had very weird reasoning, like his early Town read for Nyght, especially with the scum-hunting reason. Still, was not as eager to avoid confrontation as he was as Wolf. So into nulls he goes.
cozmikrae - I don't recall much content.
Gerrick - Same as above.
Eastern New England - Same, but expect this to improve a bit now that he's dead in the XKI game.
Anubhav Ghosh - Very odd reasoning which I still can't quite make sense of. How does he go from making me his top scum read to also not wishing to lynch me, and then also make the weird argument that if I'm looking scummy, I'm probably Town. Looks like a Wolf trying to get rid of a dangerous Townie, but not quite knowing how to push it because of lack of experience. At the same time, I noticed something which gives me a bit of pause to outright scum read.
Colberius X - Quite a bit of content, not a lot of it memorable.
taulover - Very inactive, but this is NAI for him and Hydra.
Hydra - See above.
Sapphiron - Almost wanna town-lean, because the content that was there was not bad, but I'm never clearing Sapph that soon.

Town Leans:
BraveSirRobin - That post, tho.
NyghtOwl - Good callouts against LoS, although I am somewhat wary that he Town-read me so soon, and with the reason that I was looking genuinely solvey, when I really haven't put nearly as much effort into the game as I usually do as Town.
TGN - Good vibes, honestly.
Doc - Went against conventional wisdom in a big way, which is not something I would think likely for Wolf!Doc to do, and I would hazard to say that apart from me, he was likely to be the kill that got blocked.

Nulls:
Legacy of Smiles - Was way too eager to clear me, to be honest, which I will always find suspect, and quite a few of the arguments he made in the previous day had very weird reasoning, like his early Town read for Nyght, especially with the scum-hunting reason. Still, was not as eager to avoid confrontation as he was as Wolf. So into nulls he goes.
cozmikrae - I don't recall much content.
Gerrick - Same as above.
Eastern New England - Same, but expect this to improve a bit now that he's dead in the XKI game.
Anubhav Ghosh - Very odd reasoning which I still can't quite make sense of. How does he go from making me his top scum read to also not wishing to lynch me, and then also make the weird argument that if I'm looking scummy, I'm probably Town. Looks like a Wolf trying to get rid of a dangerous Townie, but not quite knowing how to push it because of lack of experience. At the same time, I noticed something which gives me a bit of pause to outright scum read.
Colberius X - Quite a bit of content, not a lot of it memorable.
taulover - Very inactive, but this is NAI for him and Hydra.
Hydra - See above.
Sapphiron - Almost wanna town-lean, because the content that was there was not bad, but I'm never clearing Sapph that soon.

*Complains I townread people on single towny posts*
*Townreads BSR on a single towny post*



/joke post

You might not have agreed with my early reads on you/Nyght but I think they aged very well... actually probably the only thing from my original list that I still agree with.

@Colberius X and @Sapphiron, am I Town, scum or null to you?

Colberius X and Sapphiron, am I Town, scum or null to you?

To me? Null.

Back in the old days, I just had to assume you were scum until you killed me or we were together in the Seer's group chat. 

Now, I'm honestly so out of practice that I'm just hesitant to draw conclusions. (At least, not ones I feel strongly enough to share.) I feel like a new player again, especially with all of you guys' reads lists and fancy abbreviations. 

Yeah, what I'm looking for here is more of a gut-read based on the available posts I've made.

Yeah, what I'm looking for here is more of a gut-read based on the available posts I've made.

I'm at the stage where I would be surprised if you were anything but town to be honest.

Lau, what makes you think BSR's post was super towny? Like, I don't disagree with it being a good post but I certainly don't feel as strongly about it as you seem to.

Town Leans:
BraveSirRobin - That post, tho.
NyghtOwl - Good callouts against LoS, although I am somewhat wary that he Town-read me so soon, and with the reason that I was looking genuinely solvey, when I really haven't put nearly as much effort into the game as I usually do as Town.
TGN - Good vibes, honestly.
Doc - Went against conventional wisdom in a big way, which is not something I would think likely for Wolf!Doc to do, and I would hazard to say that apart from me, he was likely to be the kill that got blocked.

Nulls:
Legacy of Smiles - Was way too eager to clear me, to be honest, which I will always find suspect, and quite a few of the arguments he made in the previous day had very weird reasoning, like his early Town read for Nyght, especially with the scum-hunting reason. Still, was not as eager to avoid confrontation as he was as Wolf. So into nulls he goes.
cozmikrae - I don't recall much content.
Gerrick - Same as above.
Eastern New England - Same, but expect this to improve a bit now that he's dead in the XKI game.
Anubhav Ghosh - Very odd reasoning which I still can't quite make sense of. How does he go from making me his top scum read to also not wishing to lynch me, and then also make the weird argument that if I'm looking scummy, I'm probably Town. Looks like a Wolf trying to get rid of a dangerous Townie, but not quite knowing how to push it because of lack of experience. At the same time, I noticed something which gives me a bit of pause to outright scum read.
Colberius X - Quite a bit of content, not a lot of it memorable.
taulover - Very inactive, but this is NAI for him and Hydra.
Hydra - See above.
Sapphiron - Almost wanna town-lean, because the content that was there was not bad, but I'm never clearing Sapph that soon.

Which post of TGN gave you good vibes?

The pace at which he made it, as well as a general overall tone. Like, he didn't struggle to state his thoughts or the reasoning behind his thoughts, which I would anticipate to see from someone who has to think of convincing manufactured reads to form.

Hello Anubhav. Do you have any particular thoughts on any of the people I'm about to list and if so would you mind sharing them with me please?

Colberius X
Gerrick
Eastern New England
Hydra
taulover