I believe I've asked this before: how would you characterise Gerrick and Sapph's scum styles, and would you say they've acted that way at all so far? You're the only person in the game who has been scum with them.
I would also really like to see your reads list, especially since I feel carefully confident that you're Town, for once.
I don't really wanna speak on that, mostly because I just
don't remember; while I'm aware I've played scum with them and could probably go back through the (
two-year-old) PMs, there's a lot more of scum play here in Wintreath, in my experience, that's based on 'we have information and goals in common and...we're just gonna do our own thing until nighttime and let the chips fall where they may'.
Frankly, that seems to be Wolfing in Wintreath; the pack only comes together at night, and during the day it's every scum for themself. The only time there's really much PMing during the day seems to be when there's a scum on the chopping block, and then there's a flurry of 'do we bus them or try to clutch it out'.
As is, on a gut read I just don't think Sapph is scum this time, but I don't have the same certainty with Gerrick, (which, it should be noted, is clashing with my 'brain' read, which says that he's making good, clear posts and tells me I should clear him, but the fact that gut and brain aren't in agreement irritates me).
As for my reads list, here's a newly edited version of the original format.
more reads than a library
1) Me (Obviously, but not a very useful read for anyone else)
Turtle (more less-sus than TGN)
2)
Daws (unchanged; I'm still not persuaded he's not possibly a Ringwraith)
TGN
Sapphiron (I trust my gut)
Minish (too active to support my inactive-scum theory if Dawcreek was scum)
3)
Wischland ('limited' activity but useful)
ENE (showed up right before EOD, which would be the optimal time to put in a night action too. Again, though, based solely on my theory of 'inactive scum')
Lau + Vro (the return of TWTBAW)
Wintermoot
BSR
4)
Hapi (at this point I think she's nonaligned and consequently isn't my problem anymore)
Gerrick (my pros and cons list basically balance each other out, and more importantly my list is very top-heavy so I feel like I have to have more people to be suspicious of or I'm not doing this properly)
5)
Flying Eagles (some activity (yes, on a per-post basis, more than me, but shhhh nobody asked you) but less substantive imo; exactly the sort of chaff posting I'd do if I were scum)
ogun, HumanSanity, Wille-Harlia (inactivity, 4 people, 4 scum; do the math)
6 and 7 empty because I have no strong negative feelings about anybody
