View Topic

This is hilarious. Refer to my reads list and respond, please.

Thank you. I'm actually sorry I'm being blind, could you either quote it again or update it here because I don't see any list from you in the past 8 or so pages.

This is hilarious. Refer to my reads list and respond, please.

Thank you. I'm actually sorry I'm being blind, could you either quote it again or update it here because I don't see any list from you in the past 8 or so pages.

https://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=6948.msg154591#msg154591

This is hilarious. Refer to my reads list and respond, please.

Thank you. I'm actually sorry I'm being blind, could you either quote it again or update it here because I don't see any list from you in the past 8 or so pages.

It's literally the one that you responded to for my read on you and TGN. It's the one that Silv edited.

Oh, my bad, it looked like a wall of text and my eyes automatically moved past it. I responded to the part about myself so I see no need to talk about it any more.

It literally could not matter less what I think right now of these reads anyway. Anyone who is suspicious of me is going to vote me, you're going to read into everything I say until I flip town, doesn't matter.

I thoroughly agree about there being lurker wolves, I haven't been getting any major scum vibes from anyone who's had a decent amount of posts. I appreciate the post percentage, that is interesting and you didn't need to do that, ty for being helpful.

I don't know Doc's style as well as you, I'm inclined to just trust you on this one and hope he's not making a play by voting for Michi either knowing he was unaligned and somehow a threat to scum or just gunning for a town. Your reasoning regarding him seems based on a lot of experience.

Moot and Sapph are tied together just like Lau and BSR, it seems likely that all 4 are town. I have no idea why you're putting Hapi so high just because of Sapph's assumptions, use your own reasoning, unless you're assuming he checked her. I think she's town. I think Wisch is town. I think Gerrick is town.

We should consider Daws as town until we can't anymore.

Turtle and TGN are two of the same to me with the exact same playstyle. Nothing I will say will alter your opinion. I think they're town.

I think Minish is town because I think Daw was town. If he was wolf he would've been helped by his teammates instead of being overwhelmed on his own. I don't have a clear read on Minish herself as a player until she's caught up. It is a regret that in the Cores and Turrets game I was only town leaning her because two townies who had played with her were. I'm not trusting that reason anymore for Minish.

Flying I have mixed feelings on, no idea.

ENE needs to talk more. Human needs to talk more. ogun I have no clue, needs to talk more.

Willie is the best bet at being scum in my eyes.

I didn't want to make this post, you don't really care, I don't really care.

The 4 scum may be -
Wille-Harlia
Flying
Human
ENE

@Vroendal


Would you be able to list your four scum in most want to lynch to least want to lynch? It's fine if not, just curious.


Just looking at the d2 voting Vro makes the most sense to vote because it would give us tons of info. But I'm willing to hear him out and look other places as well.

Here are my top Scum Leans:
Flying Eagles
Ogunbiyi
Vroendal
ENE
HumanSanity
Wille-Harlia
Will have time to explain when I get home from work. The fact that Vro's list overlaps with my so much, though, as well as his general speech makes me hesitant on voting for him. Also the only reason a few others like Doc, Sapphiron, and Wintermoot aren't being considered by me are that people I'm Town reading are saying they're safely Town. Think it's time we start putting the pressure on the XKIers, though.

It's getting rather close to EoD, I should probably vote now.
Vote: Michi

Many of the players I town-read are voting Michi, so I trust their judgement on top of my own. As Wisch pointed out, there are also a bunch of mechanical reasons.

Also - I'm running out of time and I prefer to stay alive 

Who are the players you're Town reading?

@Vroendal


Would you be able to list your four scum in most want to lynch to least want to lynch? It's fine if not, just curious.


Just looking at the d2 voting Vro makes the most sense to vote because it would give us tons of info. But I'm willing to hear him out and look other places as well.

Nah that's completely reasonable. Here you are -
1) Wille
2) Human
3) ENE
4) Flying
The reason Flying is last even though he could be considered more scummy than Willie is that he could be too wolfie to be a wolf, much like TGN and turtle. I want to hear more from all of them though.

Here are my top Scum Leans:
Flying Eagles
Ogunbiyi
Vroendal
ENE
HumanSanity
Wille-Harlia
Will have time to explain when I get home from work. The fact that Vro's list overlaps with my so much, though, as well as his general speech makes me hesitant on voting for him. Also the only reason a few others like Doc, Sapphiron, and Wintermoot aren't being considered by me are that people I'm Town reading are saying they're safely Town. Think it's time we start putting the pressure on the XKIers, though.

It's getting rather close to EoD, I should probably vote now.
Vote: Michi

Many of the players I town-read are voting Michi, so I trust their judgement on top of my own. As Wisch pointed out, there are also a bunch of mechanical reasons.

Also - I'm running out of time and I prefer to stay alive 

Who are the players you're Town reading?

Since your scum list overlaps quite a bit with Vro's would you also be willing to list them from most want to lynch to least? Even if you only do the same ones Vro did?

I don't know how well I can buy that the scum are literally all inactive.

Hmm, actually, good point, I think I saw a hint, but let's make sure: @Sapphiron, Hapi cleared because of mechanics, yay or nay?

If the current PoE doesn't work out, we've likely let scum slip into our Town cores.

@Laurentus If I may be so bold as to ask, I would like you to make 2 possible different teams of 4 scum each, one if I was scum, one if I was not. I'm asking mostly out of curiosity at this point.

I've never been good at identifying whole scum teams. I tend to take it lynch by lynch.

Hapi, Sapph and Wintermoot would be one potential scum team.

Me, BSR and Dawsinian would be another.

Gerrick, you and TGN, I feel, would be another good one. I could see Doc working here, as well.

Generally, scum tries to distance themselves somewhat, so I honestly couldn't care less what the teams look like. I wouldn't have placed many of the scum team of that second Portal game, for example.

I think I can work pretty well with just about any team here, actually.

Hell, our constant back-and-forth would be a total scum move, too.