View Topic

Why would you ever ask someone who's said they'll never trust you to trust you? o.O
One thing I feel I can say without reasonable doubt is that Japi and Lau are not BOTH wolves. :p

Hapi* I apologize. Also Hapi I don't think your comment is an unreasonable one, but we'll cross that bridge when we reach it, I don't think it's something we should worry about atm, and it is indeed not a good look for you.

@Dawsinian, I'm not sure if you've been told, but you're part of this game, again.

Just from a pure game-design standpoint, it would make this game kind of wolf-sided if a dead player can become part the Wolves.

They probably can, come to think, because giving the town this ability makes the game frankly game-breakingly town-sided if there's no similar ability in the Wolf faction, but this just ain't it.

Hapi* I apologize. Also Hapi I don't think your comment is an unreasonable one, but we'll cross that bridge when we reach it, I don't think it's something we should worry about atm, and it is indeed not a good look for you.

This is the sort of nonsense that characterised your thoughts yesterday too. How do you at once tell him it's not unreasonable, and then also say it's not a good look?

Also, apologies, *her

You're just going to have to trust me, or the more fun alternative, try and case me and it. I even hope you succeed in lynching me.

Nah not my style
 
 

About the only thing that would cause me to simply trust you is if you were the one who rezzed Daws and you were town... that's currently actually what I'm leaving towards reading further into your post.

Hapi* I apologize. Also Hapi I don't think your comment is an unreasonable one, but we'll cross that bridge when we reach it, I don't think it's something we should worry about atm, and it is indeed not a good look for you.

Oh I play with the belief I'm already dead makes it easier. But trust me you do not want me dead.

48 hours and Sunday are contradictory. Can you clarify which one it is?

My bad, it is Saturday.

Also, Daws had been already notified and is aware.

@Dawsinian, I'm not sure if you've been told, but you're part of this game, again.

Just from a pure game-design standpoint, it would make this game kind of wolf-sided if a dead player can become part the Wolves.

They probably can, come to think, because giving the town this ability makes the game frankly game-breakingly town-sided if there's no similar ability in the Wolf faction, but this just ain't it.

I'd assume it to be a one shot ability.

In the summersend wolf a player joined the wolves albeit that was a choice and not a wolf ability.

I would like to speculate on two interesting players:

Vronedal: Seemed annoyed at being grouped with the townies and for a wolf to come out and express that seems unlikely but it could just be genuine frustration at me. Leaning townie for me.

Lau: Has the tone of someone who's really annoyed at something and seems to be trying to seize control of the debate. Either a townie who's helping us focus or a distracting wolf, but the tone perhaps points to the latter, as townies usually sound more cooperative.

Okay, so now that I've made it through the night phase, I'm ready to start playing this game in earnest.

Also, some pure speculation but this quote just comes off as weird. It sounds like Lau had an exceptionally tough night and is just happy to have survived it. Could be a townie scared that the wolves were coming after him/her, could be a wolf who was really stressed out debating with the other wolves what to do.

Hapi* I apologize. Also Hapi I don't think your comment is an unreasonable one, but we'll cross that bridge when we reach it, I don't think it's something we should worry about atm, and it is indeed not a good look for you.

This is the sort of nonsense that characterised your thoughts yesterday too. How do you at once tell her it's not unreasonable, and then also say it's not a good look?

I like to look at every action from both sides, whether she's town, and whether she's a wolf. I agree that casting doubt on someone incredibly likely to have been revived as a town, based on how generally common a town retributionist is to a wolf one. However I do see her point about the canon and the numbers. Also I would think you would realize, that it is entirely possible to construct an argument from rationality and still be wrong (which is exactly what is happening with your vote on me I might add).

I would like to speculate on two interesting players:

Vronedal: Seemed annoyed at being grouped with the townies and for a wolf to come out and express that seems unlikely but it could just be genuine frustration at me. Leaning townie for me.

Lau: Has the tone of someone who's really annoyed at something and seems to be trying to seize control of the debate. Either a townie who's helping us focus or a distracting wolf, but the tone perhaps points to the latter, as townies usually sound more cooperative.

Okay, so now that I've made it through the night phase, I'm ready to start playing this game in earnest.

Also, some pure speculation but this quote just comes off as weird. It sounds like Lau had an exceptionally tough night and is just happy to have survived it. Could be a townie scared that the wolves were coming after him/her, could be a wolf who was really stressed out debating with the other wolves what to do.

Woo, there's a lot to dissect here. What planet do you come from where the Wolves would ever betray anything that happened in scum-chay, especially an emotion of all things, to the rest of the thread?

Also, really? I have just evaded and propped two people I'd previously speculated as being Wolves up as my Town core, and this is what you're trying to sus me for?

Hapi* I apologize. Also Hapi I don't think your comment is an unreasonable one, but we'll cross that bridge when we reach it, I don't think it's something we should worry about atm, and it is indeed not a good look for you.

This is the sort of nonsense that characterised your thoughts yesterday too. How do you at once tell her it's not unreasonable, and then also say it's not a good look?

I like to look at every action from both sides, whether she's town, and whether she's a wolf. I agree that casting doubt on someone incredibly likely to have been revived as a town, based on how generally common a town retributionist is to a wolf one. However I do see her point about the canon and the numbers. Also I would think you would realize, that it is entirely possible to construct an argument from rationality and still be wrong (which is exactly what is happening with your vote on me I might add).

Okay, you know what, I'll take a chance on you again. Go read the thread again, even ISO me, if you have to, and come back to me with what you think is happening right now.

Okay, you know what, I'll take a chance on you again. Go read the thread again, even ISO me, if you have to, and come back to me with what you think is happening right now.

Will do, it will probably take a while, there's a lot to dissect. I would also like to ask where you've "sussed" BSR in the thread. Because I've looked at the two places I remember you doing broad reads and I see no mention of him.

Okay, you know what, I'll take a chance on you again. Go read the thread again, even ISO me, if you have to, and come back to me with what you think is happening right now.

Will do, it will probably take a while, there's a lot to dissect. I would also like to ask where you've "sussed" BSR in the thread. Because I've looked at the two places I remember you doing broad reads and I see no mention of him.

That would be right here: https://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=6948.msg153935#msg153935

Hold your ground, hold your ground! Sons of Gondor, of Rohan, my brothers! I see in your eyes the same fear that would take the heart of me. A day may come when the courage of men fails, when we forsake our friends and break all bonds of fellowship, but it is not this day.