View Topic

I mean, I've hit fuck it, so yeah, let's do this.

vote: Michi

I've been looking at that quote, and the earlier implied one from Michi too, and it just rubs me wrong, but I can't articulate why for shit.

Switching to Vote: Michi

Nope.

I am not lynching you until I can get some sort of hint from a Seer, Hapi, but I am not lynching Gerrick either.

I am lynching Michi. If Michi flips green, I am lynching Gerrick. If he flips green, I am lynching you!

I am now also forced to consider the possibility that I had my shit figured out to begin with, and that you're just a chaotic Wolf who is counting on me to perform the actions in this order, by Christ.

GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMMMMMMMMMMIIIIITTTTTTTT

OR, or, *taps fingers together* we coouuuullld do something like lynch Willie. ;p
I still think it's a very valid guess to think that there's a WW among our guests, and from seeing that Willie has been more active than most of the others and has played WW before I don't think it's a bad idea to start with them.

I do agree that we need to look at them closer as well since it's very likely at least one of them is a wolf.

After all, whatever happened to Wintreath Bros before XKI (insert rhyming word here)?

In all seriousness, I'm just feeling a bit conflicted.  On the one side, people like Hapi and Gerrick are giving town vibes the more I read their posts (the serious ones).  On the other side, I'm a bit split because of the excessive quoting and throwing at us that she could or couldn't be Aragorn just comes off as trying too hard to convince us when she very well could be a wolf.

I'm confident on my Vro vote, but I'm conflicted about the after, especially if, big shock, the person I voted for ended up flipping green because my luck in this game is usually terrible.

But at the very least, I'm glad I have someone I can talk to during these trying times.

Like anyone would want to talk to you.

I'm not listening to that.  D:

Specifically that one.

It doesn't help that Pengu throws shade at his linked partner here like this.

And if they aren't actually linked, he certainly has not gone out of his way to correct that impression.

The current vote count is:

Vroendal - 3 (Dawsinian, Michi, Gerrick)
Gerrick - 3 (Laurentus, Sapphiron, Wille-Harlia)
Wille-Harlia - 2 (Hapi, Vroendal)
Michi - 1 (Doc)

UNVOTE
Vote Gerrick
I want cook..
I mean new information has come to light

If I'm reading what's happened without missing anything, there is -
Gerrick 1 (Willie)
Vro - 3 (Daws, Michi, Gerrick)
Michi - 3 (Doc, Lau, Sapph)
Willie - 2 (Vro, Hapi)

I'm sorry Michi if you do turn out to be town, but I'm really being swayed by the argument that you're unaligned at least, and if one of your goals is to kill me I can't allow that. I want to survive.
Change Vote: Michi

Baggins: Why don't we have a game of riddles? And if I win, you show me the way out
Gollum: (talking to himself) And if he looses, what then?
Gollum: Well precious, if he looses, then we eats it! (giggles)
Gollum: (Turns to Bilbo) - If Baggins looses, we eats it all.
Bilbo: Fair enough...

Sounds like Gollum to me

If I'm reading what's happened without missing anything, there is -
Gerrick 1 (Willie)
Vro - 3 (Daws, Michi, Gerrick)
Michi - 3 (Doc, Lau, Sapph)
Willie - 2 (Vro, Hapi)

Somehow despite quoting it I still forgot to put another vote for Gerrick from TGN. -_-
Gerrick - 2 (Willie, TGN)*

Oh, yeah, @Sapphiron, just to make sure we're operating on the same frequency, do you still think they're unaligned? Because I don't, at least not as Smeagol. Unless the game's rules specifically don't apply to them, they should have gotten in the shit for hinting at these roles a long time ago.

That or they managed to circumvent a role hint / reveal because they are acting on what you and I are pushing onto them.

I honestly don’t think both are unaligned, since Mones specifically said 16 Fellowship and 4 Sauron’s Forces. Which is why I am convinced by the theory that Hapi is town-aligned Smeagol and Michi is Wolf-aligned Gollum

That or they managed to circumvent a role hint / reveal because they are acting on what you and I are pushing onto them.

I honestly don’t think both are unaligned, since Mones specifically said 16 Fellowship and 4 Sauron’s Forces. Which is why I am convinced by the theory that Hapi is town-aligned Smeagol and Michi is Wolf-aligned Gollum

There are 4 members of Sauron's forces.
Good luck, and have fun!

Actually he just said there are 4 members of Sauron's forces, unless I'm missing somewhere else where he stared how many townies there are.

Rule 12, Fellowship = Villagers. Sauron's Forces = Wolves.

Of course this opens up a can of worms whether there is a third unaligned faction but Cupid’s Lovers generally fit into traditional alignments of Town and Wolf, rather than alone

Yeah, what Daws said.

(Also thank god my Lock-town is back)

Sapp, read it here for yourself.

https://wintreath.com/forums/index.php?topic=6948.msg153737#msg153737

That or they managed to circumvent a role hint / reveal because they are acting on what you and I are pushing onto them.

I honestly don’t think both are unaligned, since Mones specifically said 16 Fellowship and 4 Sauron’s Forces. Which is why I am convinced by the theory that Hapi is town-aligned Smeagol and Michi is Wolf-aligned Gollum

I'm still swayed a bit by the unaligned argument because I don't see anywhere RM has said the number of players in the Fellowship, only that there are 4 wolves in the OP. I could see where you're going with the split team though, if I had to hazard a guess Michi's goal (as Gollum) is to get a character, whether Frodo or Bilbo idk, killed and he might be thinking it's me? Idk where his confidence in my vote is coming from, it just seems so unlike him to make that kind of mistake. So you're probably right...

Also, Sapph, Pengu began hinting at the Gollum thing before you and I began speculating they were Smeagol.