View Topic

You're post doesn't make sense Pengu. Why would him not being scum affect it? Scum won't kill their own. Unless he was killed by a townie, a vig/vet/etc role. Why would you assume it was town that killed him? Unless you happen to know something.

You say my post made no sense, but that made even less.  Funnier wasn't scum in the end, so I'm baffled at what you're trying to get at here.

Funnier 6 was killed last night, his role was Virtual Reality Assistance and Education Core, Command based robot

Well damn. No explanation of Funnier's role this time? Or did we only get that last time because Batma n explicitly stated theirs?

Or did we not get one this time because there's more than one of Funnier's role in the game?

Either way, sad to see you go - I was looking forward to playing with you.

Whatever the legitimacy of Mones' claims about their reasoning for saying killing off Funnier makes sense... It does make sense for people familiar with Funnier's experience to want them gone as a potential big threat.

It would, however, also make sense for those who have only heard of their experience from others to want them gone.

Decisions decisions...

NOT FUNNIER DAMMIT
agfdgdfhaaa

Does anyone have any result that might help?
Red cop checks, results that saw anyone visiting funnier?

I'll reread some stuff from after I went to bed, but I'm kinda uncomfortable with Laurentus.
The other players are surprisingly hard to read due to the lack of experience.

I see Hapi changed the pfp to a turret, which is kind of a red flag because I've seen quite a few scum doing the "hiding in plain sight" shenanigan for fun. I was townreading them, so it for now it's not something that I'd bet a finger or two on, but still kinda annoying.

Laurentus is usually one of my first night scans if I'm in the appropriate power role.  According to the answer I got back during the night (I'm the Jailer, so I also had to hold him for the night), he says he's an investigative role.  With the way he's been playing so far, I'm inclined to believe it since he's usually an easier read when he's a bad guy.

HE says so himself?

Funnier was killed. I assumed he was killed by a wolf. Why would the wolves kill one of their own? That’s why it doesn’t make sense that him NOT being scum affects anything. Are you assuming he was killed by a town killing role?

NOT FUNNIER DAMMIT
agfdgdfhaaa

Does anyone have any result that might help?
Red cop checks, results that saw anyone visiting funnier?

I'll reread some stuff from after I went to bed, but I'm kinda uncomfortable with Laurentus.
The other players are surprisingly hard to read due to the lack of experience.

I see Hapi changed the pfp to a turret, which is kind of a red flag because I've seen quite a few scum doing the "hiding in plain sight" shenanigan for fun. I was townreading them, so it for now it's not something that I'd bet a finger or two on, but still kinda annoying.

Laurentus is usually one of my first night scans if I'm in the appropriate power role.  According to the answer I got back during the night (I'm the Jailer, so I also had to hold him for the night), he says he's an investigative role.  With the way he's been playing so far, I'm inclined to believe it since he's usually an easier read when he's a bad guy.

Laurentus getting jailed doesn't mean another scumbud couldn't have performed the kill. I'd expect a bussable (weaker) scum to perform the kill, so that only means he couldn't've performed an action or be killed tonight.

The only thing that kinda holds me back from going after Lau is the fact that he's a strong player, which means that if he's town we want to keep him around as long as possible so we might want someone to help guide the newer players.

Funnier was killed. I assumed he was killed by a wolf. Why would the wolves kill one of their own? That’s why it doesn’t make sense that him NOT being scum affects anything. Are you assuming he was killed by a town killing role?

That's...a really shoddy logic right there.

Yes, Funnier was obviously not a bad guy if he was killed during the nignt, thank you for pointing out the incredibly obvious.  Nowhere did I say that anyone here thought he was scum in the first place, so your responses are coming off as incredibly weird.  In fact, I was pointing out how your response of "lol" followed by  "heh. too bad, funnier. Makes sense to kill you off though."

Just came off as a bit odd to me.  Nowhere in there do I see where you're gathering this odd assumption that I'm assuming he was "killed by a town role" or anything of that sort.

That's some really strange straw grasping there.
 

Town killing role*

Heh. Too bad, funnier. Makes sense to kill you off though.

Why's that? That's a bit of an odd thing to say since he never really came off as scum.

In fact, him, Ex, Minish, and Laurentus have all been pretty low on my scum list since, while sure, they've been a liitle aggressive, it just seems like their normal play style.

Your responses on the other hand right now are really questionable.

How is it questionable? He was simply saying it made sense for the turrets to kill him in the night.

What Aragonn said.

Heh. Too bad, funnier. Makes sense to kill you off though.

Why's that? That's a bit of an odd thing to say since he never really came off as scum.

In fact, him, Ex, Minish, and Laurentus have all been pretty low on my scum list since, while sure, they've been a liitle aggressive, it just seems like their normal play style.

Your responses on the other hand right now are really questionable.

How is it questionable? He was simply saying it made sense for the turrets to kill him in the night.

I realize it's grasping at straws a bit, but it's more the way he came off with it rather than the content.  But it's not like I'm going to start gunning for a vote anytime soon.  It just came off as pretty questionable to where I'll be keeping a closer eye.

I said:

Makes sense to kill you off though.

You replied:

That's a bit of an odd thing to say since he never really came off as scum.

Why would him not being scum have to do with anything?

Hmmm, I meant "it makes sense for the wolves to kill off a good player". Did you interpret that differently? Maybe it's just a misunderstanding.

I was just responding to something I was reading while trying to catch up on the thread. I'll just drop it here.

Okay like seriously, can anyone get me a list of who here has never played mafia before and who here has played however many games pretty please it would help a lot

I've only ever played friendly games IRL.

Hmmm, I meant "it makes sense for the wolves to kill off a good player". Did you interpret that differently? Maybe it's just a misunderstanding.

Yeah, I dunno why (probably because I was half asleep), but I interpreted it as something completely different.

But Funnier is a strong player, so in that viewpoint it would make sense.  For some reason the laughing about just rubbed me the wrong way like a gloat or something.