View Topic

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

Aren't you supposed to try to get votes off of you? I thought the main goal of the game is to survive.

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

would you mind elaborating where my defense contradicts itself?

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

Aren't you supposed to try to get votes off of you? I thought the main goal of the game is to survive.

Yes, but if you are town, you know what your defense is because you are town. However, as WW you have to make up a defense, and Exlight's defense seems like they made up one defense, and it didn't get the votes off of them, so they made up another fake defense.

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

Aren't you supposed to try to get votes off of you? I thought the main goal of the game is to survive.

Surviving until the very end usually only matters is you're mafia. The main town objective is to lynch them, even if we have to die.


Vote: Batma n
Dropping a vote in EoD on a claimed doctor and disappearing reeks like inexperienced scum to me; you better get back here right now and explain yourself

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

Aren't you supposed to try to get votes off of you? I thought the main goal of the game is to survive.

Yes, but if you are town, you know what your defense is because you are town. However, as WW you have to make up a defense, and Exlight's defense seems like they made up one defense, and it didn't get the votes off of them, so they made up another fake defense.

"Hey guys I'm town so I'd really appreciate it if you took your votes off of me k thx"
"Oh no problem bro, I'll get right on that"

I never have ever seen that play out. Your logic and reason is sketch af.

Snarky Aragonn's appearances are far too rare. I love this. 

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

would you mind elaborating where my defense contradicts itself?

You started off really aggressive (which isn't susp alone), but then you tried to switch to a kinder defense, and now you have tried a more under-the-radar defense and it seems suspicious that you keep switching up your defense.

Ex is probably trying to figure out how the crowd rolls. As was explained before, he has a bit of experience under his belt though that experience comes from playing with a different crowd. He doesn't know this crowd, so he's trying to learn and adapt.

@Laurentus @Aragonn
@Minish @funnier6

I don't really don't want to lynch the halloween pie guy for now
would you be fine with a Batma n lynch instead? I really don't want to deal with someone acting like that later in the game

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

would you mind elaborating where my defense contradicts itself?

You started off really aggressive (which isn't susp alone), but then you tried to switch to a kinder defense, and now you have tried a more under-the-radar defense and it seems suspicious that you keep switching up your defense.

yea imagine being able to approach the game in different ways and adapt to the current situation
why would that mean I'm scummier?
and I already claimed and explained why my role is important, are you just going to assume I'm lying and help cripple town?

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

Aren't you supposed to try to get votes off of you? I thought the main goal of the game is to survive.

Yes, but if you are town, you know what your defense is because you are town. However, as WW you have to make up a defense, and Exlight's defense seems like they made up one defense, and it didn't get the votes off of them, so they made up another fake defense.

"Hey guys I'm town so I'd really appreciate it if you took your votes off of me k thx"
"Oh no problem bro, I'll get right on that"

I never have ever seen that play out. Your logic and reason is sketch af.

If you are town, you have a defense(your town role), so you can't change your defense during the game. Exlight has changed their defense many times (as explained in the previous post).

Is Batma n an experienced player? Kinda asked before and no one answered?

Is Batma n an experienced player? Kinda asked before and no one answered?

No, but I do play Town of Salem.

If you are town, you have a defense(your town role), so you can't change your defense during the game. Exlight has changed their defense many times (as explained in the previous post).

I didn't change my claim; it's a '3-shot' doctor that can self target.
Your whole argument to going after me is that it's scummy my playstyle has been changing as the game goes on, which is just a fallacy.

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

Aren't you supposed to try to get votes off of you? I thought the main goal of the game is to survive.

Yes, but if you are town, you know what your defense is because you are town. However, as WW you have to make up a defense, and Exlight's defense seems like they made up one defense, and it didn't get the votes off of them, so they made up another fake defense.

"Hey guys I'm town so I'd really appreciate it if you took your votes off of me k thx"
"Oh no problem bro, I'll get right on that"

I never have ever seen that play out. Your logic and reason is sketch af.

If you are town, you have a defense(your town role), so you can't change your defense during the game. Exlight has changed their defense many times (as explained in the previous post).

That is, of course, assuming that people believe you. You could be lying, and it's that chance that you could be lying about your role that some people don't like and will continue to press you. There's also that good chance that revealing your role will get scum to off you in the night.

After spending over an hour reading everything, I am going to Vote Exlight because their defense looks like many attempts to either get the votes off of them or move the conversation away from them, and some of the defenses contradict each other, which makes them seem very suspicious to me.

Aren't you supposed to try to get votes off of you? I thought the main goal of the game is to survive.

Yes, but if you are town, you know what your defense is because you are town. However, as WW you have to make up a defense, and Exlight's defense seems like they made up one defense, and it didn't get the votes off of them, so they made up another fake defense.

"Hey guys I'm town so I'd really appreciate it if you took your votes off of me k thx"
"Oh no problem bro, I'll get right on that"

I never have ever seen that play out. Your logic and reason is sketch af.

If you are town, you have a defense(your town role), so you can't change your defense during the game. Exlight has changed their defense many times (as explained in the previous post).

That is, of course, assuming that people believe you. You could be lying, and it's that chance that you could be lying about your role that some people don't like and will continue to press you. There's also that good chance that revealing your role will get scum to off you in the night.

What I'm saying is, if you're town, you know you're town, so why lie. Exlight defending with three vastly different defenses seems like a very weird thing for a townie to do.