View Topic

I'll vote Marz. He seems quiet.

Mars is a she as an FYI, but you'd have no way of knowing so don't feel bad.
EDIT TAKEBACKSIES: you WOULD, her signature says 'daughter of the House of Kaizer'! SHAME!

Rudimentary creatures of blood and flesh, you touch my mind, fumbling in ignorance, incapable of understanding.

Okay, I think North has been directly slaved to the will of Sovereign, so we should probably have him killed to prevent the Reapers from being able to seize control of the Citadel.

I'm not about to get into trouble for editing~

As I mentioned above, if you finish your edit within about a minute, it won't show the 'edited' line.

Now for the meat and bones:

I am currently leaning towards lynching someone as opposed to not lynching someone because I think the no lynch vote would be better saved for another time.

'No Lynch' should be saved for a time when we have more information? If you believe in no-lynching (disclaimer: I no longer do, largely all it does is give an extra day for the scum to pretty-much-guarantee-a-kill) he time to be No-Lynching is early, not late, to keep as many people alive as possible until Sufficient Information has been acquired to really nail one (or more!) scum accurately - not saved until the penultimate vote for...some bizarre reason I can't even think of.
That sounds scummy to me, simply on the grounds that saving No Lynches to be used later (rather than not wanting to use them at all) is a move that solely benefits scum. Not enough to justify a vote on that basis, but if we had, like, a suspicion meter, Kane would be up a level or two on that.

(Disclaimer in case somebody has an (inaccurate) 'aha!' moment about 'uh since when do you not believe in no lynch': when I told North not to use his no lynch, that was primarily motivated by 'clearly he finds it useful if he intends to use it, and it will be wasted since nobody else is voting that way' - not me personally finding it useful. You can still advise someone on how best to pursue a course of action, even if you disagree with it.)

As for people I'm genuinely suspicious of - that axe primarily falls on Hydra, as someone who we have seen on many an occasion (most recently in Avalon!) to be most often silent when he's scum.
Hydra has also made exactly two posts in the board - his vote, and his confirmation of role receipt.
While those are also his most recent two posts period (you can independently confirm this by clicking on his profile and going to 'show posts')...I dunno. Silence, when it comes to Hydra and Werewolf, is generally indicative of something.
Vote: Hydra, with the disclaimer that I'm not married to voting this way if anyone comes up with something more convincing.

As I mentioned above, if you finish your edit within about a minute, it won't show the 'edited' line.

Your words are as empty as your future. I am the vanguard of your destruction. This exchange is over.

RNGesus is gonna have a field day if nothing changes.
Official vote count:

Gerrick:1 (North)
Marzipan:1 (El Fiji Grande)
Kane: 1 (Kane)
El Fiji Grande: 1 (German)
Shadow: 1 (Marzipan)
Pengu:1 (Pengu)
BSR:1 (BSR)
Hydra: 1 (Doc)

Not voting: Gerrick, Wintermoot, Melehan, Shadow, Hydra,

With 13 players it takes 7 for majority vote.


There are currently 5 hours left in this day phase.

If you are tagged below, you have not posted once for this day phase.
@Wintermoot
@Gerrick
@ShadowX4life
@Hydra

I don't know if I'll be online later today, so I'm going to vote for German because his logic on the first day struck me as pretty scummy, and he argued pretty strongly with Deku (who we now know was definitely Crew).

Though we have a lot of very quiet people around...

Feel like I'm being unfair to Marz. Everyone's quiet.

Yeah, I do think that voting for Marz just for being afk is harsh. There might be stuff going on IRL. But really Marz you going to throw me out of the spaceship (I would say under the bus, but we're in space) like that!

I vote for Marz.

It's nothing personal- I was trying to leave us in the hands of the RNG gods instead of needlessly piling without evidence. Someone's awful touchy, considering there was no clear vote lead.

lol, I like how people are meticulously avoiding piling on so they aren't accused of piling on.

I'm comfortable with my vote from the first round, and voting for himself might just be a ploy to avoid further suspicion, so I'm going to Vote: BraveSirRobin. Though I will point out that BSR, Marz, and German all voted with each other on that first round, too.

As I stated when signing up for this game (and also on Discord's RP channel), I'll be extremely busy for the next couple of months. Therefore, I have to give many thanks to Ruguo for all the pokes and reminders.

I was going to follow Pengu's lead and vote for myself, but I guess that's not an option anymore. I'll Vote: Wintermoot to stay alive.

I'm going to VOTE: SHADOW for being the first to make vote number 2 for another player this day.

Well, these are interesting votes.

After further consideration, and particularly considering he was so quiet he didn't actually vote D1, I'm switching my vote to Pengu. Self-voting as a ploy to deflect suspicion looks very plausible under those circumstances.

The crew had once again settled in my office, hesitant to name names. But as our time drew to a close, they began throwing accusations until only a few suspects remained. At the end of the day, it seemed that Shadow would be the one taken by C-sec. However, when the officers came and pulled him aside, he only had to say a few, inaudible words, before the officers walked away, almost in a trance, refusing to arrest him. A few voices protested, but nothing seemed to enter the ears of the officers. With no further choice, the crew returned to the ship.

Official vote count:
Gerrick:1 (North)
Marzipan:2 (El Fiji Grande, Shadow)
Kane: 1 (Kane)
El Fiji Grande: 1 (German)
Shadow: 2 (Marzipan, Gerrick)
Pengu:2 (Pengu,Melehan)
BSR:2 (BSR, Wintermoot)
Hydra: 1 (Doc)
Wintermoot: (Hydra)

RNGesus proofs, where Marz is 1, Shadow is 2, Pengu is 3, BSR is 4. Rolled five times to account for larger number of people.

proofs

https://ibb.co/zfVZZKK
https://ibb.co/b5H8Dmg
https://ibb.co/jrwWxv6
https://ibb.co/0Vrg62G
https://ibb.co/SB04dhj

Night two begins now. It will run until Sunday, September 15th at 9:00 Central time.
Night talk is allowed.

Players with actions, please PM me what you wish to do.

So what was Shadow?

If Shadow wasn't taken by c-sec, does that mean they are still in the game or is that just a story gimmick?

To be clear: Shadow is not out of the game. As such, his role will not be revealed. Speculate as you will.